Page 12. — "Die Welt" — No. 7.
Arnold Toynbee.
(1852—1883.) By Dr. Martin Weismann.
Toynbee shares the fate of true philanthropists and genuine folk-poets: he is almost entirely — forgotten. His name has become a generic term and as such has travelled round the universe, but his personality itself, his life and work, are unknown. Not only on the Continent, but in England too, nay, even in London. People perhaps still know tolerably well what Toynbee Hall signifies, but they do not know who Toynbee was; they know in London that Toynbee Hall is situated somewhere in the East, but they do not know the life of the man who stamped his mark upon this Hall, nor do they trouble themselves about it, any more than they seek to discover what King's Hall, Guild Hall, etc., may signify. In the din of the city of six millions the quiet call that goes forth to the public from the modest Toynbee Hall is lost, the more so as tom-tom beats and boom-boom-tarara are not in favour there. A puffer and a seeker after advertisement Arnold Toynbee had never been. Oh! that least of all; and his Hall, too, does not love the false renown of the fairground barker. In quiet seclusion Toynbee lived for his heart's desire and his ideal — the education of the "outcasts" of London and the bridging of the gulf between the poor and the rich. In letters of gold he wrote his name in the closed breast of the "most desperate of the desperate", in which he now lives eternally and imperishably, like the gardener who has done his duty in the garden he has tended well, without outward signs proclaiming it, like the great folk-poets whose songs the whole nation sings without knowing their names.
The life of Toynbee is short and not rich in events. He never held a great public position, and the writings he has left us, though not without special merit, are few in number and fragmentary in form. Toynbee's real significance lies in the personal influence he exercised upon every one who had met him even once, and in his honest endeavour to help the working population of the unhappy East of London to "the rights of man". The stone-hard politician of Ireland, Michael Davitt, says of him: "Few men have ever made such an impression upon me as Arnold Toynbee, who was possessed by so passionate a desire to mitigate the misery of mankind." Sympathetic and full of feeling, Toynbee was loved and loved others, especially those who were pursued by fate. To them he devoted his life, even though his health was thereby undermined. His endeavour was directed towards spreading the young ideas of the University for political reform among the people; he wished to wed the ideas of the educated with the deeds of the half-educated and the uneducated, "to unite the flame of the mind with the flame of the workshop into one sacred fire", as Jaurès says. "I wish to attain the position of a man who is consumed with thirst for truth and justice," he writes in 1875 from the University of Oxford, at the age of 23. And in truth he "consumed himself" in his burning desire to enlighten the English working class and by enlightenment to better it. In the Middle Ages, in an England inclined towards pietism, Toynbee would have become the founder of a religious sect; in the nineteenth century he took up the cause of suffering humanity and became a social politician in the noblest and best sense of the word.
Arnold Toynbee was born, the second son of Josef Toynbee, on the 23rd of August 1852 in Savile Row (London S.). His father, who concerned himself with the poorer population of that part of London, gave the working men of his neighbourhood instruction in the elementary subjects. After much wavering whether to take up a military, an official, or a legal career, young Toynbee at length resolved to choose the study of history, which had interested him from his earliest youth, and thereby the profession of teacher. As he pursued this study as a self-taught man, Arnold Toynbee, scarcely 21 years old, was unable in the year 1873 to satisfy the curiosity of his examiners and — failed, although even then in many departments of history he knew more than his pig-tailed examiners themselves. This failure had a bad effect upon young Toynbee's health, which was in any case weak: the doctors forbade him all mental excitement, and he was to give up his beloved profession of teacher. Sensitive and delicate, Toynbee was already at this time an excellent speaker, who spoke much and always to the point, without becoming too trivial or too pathetic. The summer of 1875 Arnold Toynbee spent in Whitechapel (Commercial Road, West London) in a lodging-house, in order to become acquainted with the conditions of the London outcasts in that quarter; his real residence, however, was the university town of Oxford, where he remained the eternal student and later (1878) held the post of lecturer and tutor (at Balliol College).
Like his two predecessors in the great work of "the peaceful enlightenment of the working classes", Fred Maurice (1860) and Denison (1867), Toynbee came to the conviction that it was not fitting to flatter the poor, as the demagogues do, and to instil into them pernicious theories which, moreover, they would never understand, but that one must "enlighten the unfortunates for practical action", that one must "support" them and not "relieve" them, so that they may be able to help themselves. The money thrown to the poor, he held, helps them only momentarily out of their difficulty, merely demoralises them for the future and breeds "professional beggars". To bring about a lasting improvement of their condition one must lend them one's own brain ("Lend them your brains!"). "Personal service," says Oates, a disciple of Toynbee, "is true charity, and not the sum of money which one offers up on the altar, and that mostly unwillingly into the bargain. I do not ask for your money, but for intercommunication between the rich and the poor. The hand that gives should go further still; it should also clasp the hand of the unfortunate, in order to raise him, to lead him, and to hold him upright." To this end, it was held, one must live among the poor, study them themselves as well as their inclinations and passions, their dwellings and places of amusement, their bearing and behaviour, and make them one's — friends. One must descend to them in order then to raise them up to oneself. One would understand them only if one had lived for some length of time with them and among them under the same conditions. "It is not easy," says Miss Susan Wharton of America, "to learn the language of the uneducated. They speak a language for
