Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 23 · 6 June 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16
Facsimile · scan 2 of 16
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 23.

After the Alliance Elections.

By Dr. Elias (Mühlhausen).

According to semi-official communications from the Alliance leadership, our list has been defeated. Some election returns have not yet arrived in Paris, but they are said to be unable to alter the result, which is already established.

It is probable that the statements of the Alliance leadership are correct. But we have the right not to regard them as incontestable truth so long as we are prevented from studying the election returns. For the persons who before the election were our opponents are now judging and proclaiming the result of the election as judges. In a court of law we should, with every right and reason, challenge them for bias. At the ballot-box we must tolerate them as judges; but their verdict we may, and must, call in question so long as we cannot check the evidence on which their judgment rests.

A priori a victory for our list was not improbable.

We had put forward candidates who, in their great majority, believe in a Jewish future, who had worked for such a future and will continue to work for it; most of them are the pride and joy of our Jewish people.

Opposed to them stood a number of men, many of whom had done nothing or next to nothing for Judaism, most of whom will hear nothing of a national and cultural future for Judaism, and some of whom follow in the train of the man who does not shrink from assimilation in religious matters through the abolition of the ritual laws and of the Sabbath.

We had put forward a programme which every Jew whose heart beats for Jewish ideals could sign.

They entered the contest without a programme. They had come together from the most diverse points of the political and religious horizon; they could draw up no common programme.

Nor could they, because they had formerly belonged to the Alliance directorate, point to their past activity. The Alliance, at least in recent years, carrying out the plans of a small but powerful party, had worked in the interest of a political party, of a religious outlook, of a nationality. For all four members of the directorate — and they form the majority — who do not belong to this political party, who do not profess this religious outlook, who may not have any particular fondness for this nationality, an open statement was impossible. Against their will, or without being conscious of it, they had helped to cultivate that shallow Liberalism which does not need political freedom in order to force its will upon others and to sacrifice the future of a whole people to its own interests or to those of its tribe, and which, under the mask of progress, distils out of our national belief in God a vague Deism; they had helped to spread the French idea of the State, instead of keeping Jewish interests alone in view. They were obliged to keep silent about their work in the past and about their future activity as well. The Congress of Deputies which they constitute could continue to sit only if it acted on the saying: Silence is golden. By open speech it would have been broken up, and the distressed Jews, enlightened as to the true intentions of their "benefactors," would have waved them away.

We might further count upon the sympathies of the bulk of the Alliance members. They stand in no opposition to us. They pay their subscriptions in the belief that they are contributing their mite towards relieving or removing Jewish distress. Whoever furnished them with the proof (and we have furnished it) that the present Alliance leadership has neither done much good in the past nor can be of much help in the future, might reckon on their taking another course along with him.

We could further count upon the sympathies and the help of all those who have had occasion to observe the past work of the Alliance at close quarters. And in fact the political daily press in Egypt, and in Constantinople the Spanish paper "El Telegrafo," came out with great energy for our list, and doubtless others besides, quite apart from the Zionist papers, which naturally fought alongside us to infuse new blood and new life into the ageing organism of the Alliance.

And yet, in spite of the valuable help that came to us from the most diverse quarters, in spite of the fact that the official list of candidates had many points in common with an equation with many unknowns, although it was not accompanied, and could not be accompanied, by an explanatory programme, it appears that our list has not carried. Various factors have brought about this result. Part of the blame lies with the indifferentism that was fostered among the Alliance members by their being excluded as far as possible from any share in the work. For years no general meetings and no elections to the directorate had taken place; for years the minutes of the directorate's sittings had also ceased to be published. The directorate gradually came to believe in its omnipotence and its infallibility; it grew accustomed to regarding the members of the society merely as the paying public, and the members gradually contented themselves with the modest part assigned to them. It was therefore difficult to rouse them from their lethargy and to bring home to them the idea that the directorate is merely an executive organ, and that it is they, and not the members of the directorate, who have to determine which way the Alliance shall go.

Furthermore, certain bureaucratic tricks contributed to bringing about our fall.

They contrived to keep the date of the election concealed from us as long as possible. Nor did they fix one definite day as election day for all the Alliance groups; in some countries the election was fixed earlier, in others later.

There was no question of observing a definite election period. In some places the Alliance members were notified of the forthcoming election barely 24 or 48 hours beforehand. A further artifice was to instruct the most important local committees on no account to show us the lists of members.

Yet none of these obstacles was insurmountable; in spite of all these difficulties we should have won had we been supported by all those on whose help we confidently counted, had all the Zionist associations concerned regarded and treated the fight against the present Alliance leadership as a Zionist matter. A large number, however, of those men who are known as good Zionists, who have shrunk from no sacrifice for the spread of the idea of Zion, who have worked, and are still working, industriously for the Colonial Bank, the Shekel, the National Fund, remained deaf to our arguments and, in spite of our most urgent entreaties, were not to be won for an action, or an energetic action, against the present Alliance leadership. Some could not be convinced of the importance of the Alliance elections; others held them to be hopeless. They contented themselves with attending the spectacle as impartial onlookers.