Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 29.
(continued from page 5)
…brethren in Russia might perhaps incur unpleasantness, not to reply.
After Major Gordon had apologised to the expert for the lengthy examination and thanked him for his ready answers, the Commission adjourned for luncheon.
The afternoon sitting began with the
Examination by Mr. Vallence.
Mr. Vallence first asks the expert what he understands by assimilation.
Dr. Herzl: By assimilation I understand literally what the word means: to become so alike that one differs in nothing.
Mr. Vallence: Supposing that dispersion were possible, would it not lead to assimilation in your sense?
Dr. Herzl: No. The dispersion has already lasted 1800 years. 1800 years ago the Jews were dispersed, and to this day they are not assimilated.
Mr. Vallence: Regarding the question from an English standpoint, and supposing that the aliens had not concentrated themselves in one district but had dispersed over the whole country — do you believe that the alien immigration question would then have arisen?
Dr. Herzl: I believe so indeed.
Mr. Vallence: And you believe that there is no possibility of dealing with the question except at its origin?
Dr. Herzl: That I believe.
Mr. Vallence: I am not quite clear what you have in mind when you say that "the stream of immigration into this country should be diverted at its source." Have you a particular plan in view?
Dr. Herzl: Certainly!
Mr. Vallence: Would you not describe it?
Dr. Herzl: I prefer to set it forth here only in broad outline, and should be happy if I might communicate the details to the Chairman privately; if he thinks it worth while, he may bring it to the knowledge of all the gentlemen.
Mr. Vallence: And in what direction does your plan tend?
Dr. Herzl: It aims at creating a centre of sufficient attraction that the Jews would go thither.
In answer to a question of Mr. Vallence, Dr. Herzl replies that the restrictive laws at present in force in America can easily be evaded, since the sum which every immigrant must show to be in his possession before landing can easily be borrowed and returned after landing.
Examination by Sir Kenelm Digby.
Sir K. Digby: From your standpoint you do not advocate the exclusion of the Jews from the countries to which they now go, nor any restrictive measure?
Dr. Herzl: No. There are regions of ill repute which may do such a thing, regions which do not lay such weight upon the preservation of their old renown and their ideas of liberty as England does. These may do such a thing.
Sir K. Digby: If your ideas should prove successful and be realised, that would surely not stop the Jews from going elsewhere? I do not believe you expect that?
Dr. Herzl: I think it will not only stop the movement of immigration, but will also draw thither all those who themselves feel, or are made to feel, that they are not wanted elsewhere, that they are regarded as superfluous.
Sir K. Digby: You believe, then, that the religious idea as well as their material advantage will draw them thither?
Dr. Herzl: The whole block of advantages.
Sir K. Digby: You do not advocate — in view of the fact that your idea would thereby make progress — that other nations should exclude the Jews from their countries? You do not consider that a necessary stage in the propagation of your idea?
Dr. Herzl: No. I would prefer to be a dreamer of dreams, and would rather see the facts fail to prove that I had the right foresight.
Sir K. Digby: Do you apprehend any real danger from an awakening of antisemitism in a country like ours?
Dr. Herzl: There is a French proverb: "Cet animal est très impatient, il se défend quand on l'attaque." — If the Jews are attacked, they will defend themselves, and you will have internal disturbances.
Sir K. Digby: Do you apprehend serious danger to the Jews if they are attacked?
Dr. Herzl: I know antisemitic countries, unfortunately.
Sir K. Digby: You have so far brought no proof that an antisemitic current is arising in this country.
Dr. Herzl: I remember the time before the appearance of antisemitism in France. I was living there at the time of the beginning of the Dreyfus affair. At that time there was as yet no antisemitism there, but it has now taken up its abode there. I do not believe it is good for a country to have antisemitism — not for the Jews, but not for the country either.
Examination by Lord Rothschild.
Lord Rothschild: I should like to recall to your memory some of the answers which you gave Major Gordon. Do you believe it possible that a Jew may be an adherent of Dr. Herzl and a Zionist — whatever that may mean — and at the same time a good citizen of his native land, a good Englishman, or American, or Austrian?
Dr. Herzl: I am deeply convinced of it, and you have had the proof of it in the last war. I am aware that two Zionist societies existed in your army.
Lord Rothschild: I put this question to you because I believe that you did not understand Major Gordon, although I believe he meant to put the questions in the way that I did. But he was more politic than I. For it was said here at the beginning of the sittings of this Commission that the fact of a man's being a Zionist prevented him from being a good citizen of this country and made it imperatively necessary to exclude him from this country. I thought it necessary to tell you this, so that you may explain to the Commission how it is compatible for a man to have sympathy for his persecuted brethren in Roumania and yet be a good citizen of his country.
