Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 49
The best material for proving this assertion is furnished, as on other occasions too, by our opponents. It is precisely they who show, in the manner in which they justify their standpoint, that the Jewish people follows a peculiar mode of thought, and that national feeling rests upon spiritual qualities of the whole.
First there are the Orthodox. In so far as they make war upon Zionism, they do so "because the Zionists do not all keep the Law, and the Basle Programme does not even aim at the general observance of the Law."
On the other hand, they eagerly protest against the charge that they would not live and work together with free-thinking Jews. Only to Erez Israel may one not return together with them. And why not? "Because the goal is the Kingdom of God, in which all form one congregation in order to worship Him."*)
So it is not religious difference that occasions the difference of opinion. Heaven forbid. Zionism merely injures, so it is alleged, the idea of the Kingdom of God that is to be striven after, and therefore "écrasez la Pologne."
Then come the cosmopolitans. They too strive after a Kingdom of God, but one built upon a very obscure foundation. None the less they justify their standpoint exactly as the Orthodox do:
"Zionism aims at the re-establishment of Jewish nationality. But the final goal of mankind is to be that state in which all dividing barriers are cleared away for ever and all men live together as brothers. Since, then, Zionism allegedly works against this course of development, it must be combated."
And the Liberal opponents annihilate us by proving that Judaism has had a "mission" conferred upon it, namely the charge of preserving the monotheistic idea of God pure for all peoples and all times, so that one day the pure faith in the one and only God may reign everywhere.
Even our deserters often enough argue in this characteristic fashion. As the justification of this step we have heard it said: "The Jews produce no geniuses of the first rank, but they stand on the average above the Aryan level. Therefore we must merge in other peoples and fructify them."
Further: "The Jews are the best scientific heads. They must merge in the German nation, so that knowledge may be advanced by their collaboration." And: "The highest purpose is the ennobling of the race. The children of mixed marriages are the handsomest and cleverest, therefore we have the duty of contracting mixed marriages."
Each of us has surely listened to similar arguments by the dozen, and although a great deal of hypocrisy creeps in, it would yet be foolish to suppose that all those reasons are merely pretexts. At the very least an attempt is always made to hang a little teleological cloak about the hypocrisy.
Would the German, the Frenchman, the Englishman seek to prove things in the same manner? Hardly. In the time of the highest religious ecstasy the Christian hosts marched towards Jerusalem. To advance the knowledge of the truth, perhaps? Oh no. Whoever had made the pilgrimage to the Holy Sepulchre had secured his salvation. And then it was a disgrace to Christendom that unbelieving Mohammedans guarded the Church of the Sepulchre and plundered the pilgrims. It is true they fought under the battle-cry "Dieu le veut!" God wills it! But this willing referred not to the progress of the whole, the great distant goal of development, the unknown destiny towards which mankind is hastening, but to the happiness of the individual, the destruction of the enemy, the averting of disgrace.
Because it was meritorious for the good Christian, they burned the Jews, the murderers of the Saviour; because it was commanded, they struck the heretics dead.
Only tell our fellow-countrymen about the idea of the Mission. Blank astonishment will be the answer. And it is well so. For if the arrogance that lies in this idea were understood, antisemitism would be heightened more than by all the crimes ever committed by Jews.
How little the cosmopolitan idea has been able to take root in Christian circles is best attested by the membership lists of the Society for Ethnic Culture. Our "co-religionists" there are pretty much among themselves. The German-national idea has conquered all minds. But how far removed is this nationalism from ours!
German nationalism is exclusive, ours is transcendental and therefore without any hatred. Read, for example, Herzl's "Altneuland." There all who wish the new land well fight against the party of Dr. Geyer, who wants Judæa for the Jews alone and will not declare the strangers equal in rights.
"All your plantations are worth nothing," David Littwak calls to the farmers of Neudorf, "if liberality, magnanimity and love of mankind do not flourish among you." And Dr. Friedrich Löwenfeld, in the newly built Temple in Jerusalem, understands why the Temple of the Omnipresent could be raised only upon Zion: "Because it was only here that they had grown into the free community in which they could work for the highest ends of mankind." ("Altneuland.")
With these views, so far as we know, all Zionist authorities are in harmony. And now compare German nationalism. It first shows itself in the Burschenschaften, in which hatred of the French and of the Jews forms the ferment. Think of the well-known demonstrations at the Wartburg Festival, of Jahn and Massmann, and above all of the latter's devouring hatred of foreigners. Then it grows, very soberly, into the Zollverein, which is after all designed to serve material interests. And how is it sought to justify it for fifty years, until German unity is attained? "The Germans, too, demand their place in the sun." "Nationalism is the will to power." The patriots weep over the disunion and impotence of their country, over its dependence upon Russia and Austria, over all the disgrace of foreign influence and the decline of their native character.
But we have nowhere in our memory a passage in which it is said: "Germandom is destined by Providence to set other men free, to devote itself to the development of the idea of humanity, to bring brotherhood to all." Only one people besides the Jews has said anything of the kind, though it did not do it — that was the French. And how the notion was handled in practice there may be taken as universally known.
In Germany and everywhere else, save among ourselves, nationalism contains the element of hatred of foreigners, of contempt for other peoples, of seclusion. The French Nationalists, the Pan-Germans, the Hungarian adversaries of the Transylvanians and Roumanians, the American Jingoes, etc., have all sprung from the same soil. They are all, too, the chief bearers of antisemitism in their home countries. In the Jewish national party alone lies the consciousness: "Every people has a special endowment which it is called upon to develop." As the family, by preserving tradition, forms an artistic or a commercial sense and fosters legal or social interests, so too should the nation-
*) Cf. the frequent disquisitions in the "Israelit."
