No. 13 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(Great hilarity on the Right.) The only question is whether the German Reichstag has the right to intervene against this treatment of the Roumanian Jews. A certain right I concede, because the Treaty of Berlin contains provisions which the Roumanian Government is alleged to have violated. (!) The Roumanian Government, however, is not of the opinion that it has done so, and the European Governments have not declared that opinion. The suggestion of America has met with no response. Had the honourable previous speaker read what Liberal papers such as the 'Frankfurter Zeitung' have written about the Roumanian Jews, he would understand that the Roumanian Government is seeking to protect its own population against certain emigratory inclinations (!) of the Jewish-Roumanian population, which is in itself alien." Such was the answer given on this point by a German deputy to the Reichstag. He praises and approves without reserve the indescribable proceedings of the Roumanian Government — no sympathy, no sense of justice stirs in him.
The Struggle for the Emancipation of the Jewish Communities in Alsace-Lorraine.
By Dr. Elias (Mülhausen).
For some years a movement has been stirring among the Jews of Alsace-Lorraine which seeks to modify the present legal conditions of Jewish worship. At first it was only a few large communities of the two northern districts that demanded, and also carried through, a change of system in the administration of worship; now the agitation has taken hold of the most various communities of the country.
In order to make clear to those who stand at a distance for what reasons reforms in the administration of worship are being striven for in Alsace-Lorraine, it is necessary to review the present state of affairs and its legal foundation.
The constitution of worship of the Jews of the Imperial Territory corresponds on the whole to that of their French co-religionists. Its characteristic feature is the circumstance that the individual communities do not constitute juristic persons, that they are therefore without rights, and that the administration of worship of all the communities of a district is centralised in the hands of one authority, the District Consistory. The District Consistory appoints and supervises the boards of the individual synagogue communities and of the most various religious societies; it further supervises religious instruction and the exposition of the Law; without its sanction no assembly may be formed that pursues the object of praying in common; it makes proposals to the Government for the filling of rabbinical posts, etc. The District Consistory consists of the Chief Rabbi and 26 lay members, of whom four must reside at the seat of the Consistory. The lay members are elected for eight years; half their number is renewed every four years, and that by an electoral body to which, with few exceptions, all Israelites belong who have resided a certain number of years in the district, who are at least 25 years of age, and who have undertaken to pay contributions for worship or other official religious institutions.
The constitution of Jewish worship in Alsace-Lorraine rests upon an ordinance of King Louis Philippe of the year 1844, which regulated Jewish worship in the whole of France. It was altered by later Governments in only a few details. The most important alteration consisted in this, that after the year 1870 the German Government refrained from creating a Central Consistory and transferred its powers (mediation of intercourse between the District Consistories and the Government, chief supervision, etc.) to the District Presidents. For intelligible reasons the District Presidents interfere as little as possible in Jewish affairs of worship; and so a large measure of independence fell to the District Consistories.
The Jews of Alsace-Lorraine have no reason to boast of their consistorial constitution. By the circumstance that the holders of power, the members of the Consistory, proceed from general elections, a little democratic cloak is hung about the whole system. But this little cloak is of very thin stuff: let it be considered that the individual members of the Consistory are elected for eight years, and that the electors are restricted in their choice by the provision that two-thirds of those elected must reside in a particular town. Lift this thin democratic covering, and one comes upon an organism whose spirit, centralisation à outrance, stands in direct contradiction to modern principles of administration and of liberty.
As soon as the consistorial elections are over, the individual communities and their members are deprived of every possibility of taking part in the direction and administration of their affairs of worship. Current business is dispatched without them; without their being consulted, and often against their wishes, community administrators are appointed and rabbis proposed. For this reason, too, interest in communal affairs has in most cases died out, and communal life is entirely or almost wholly stifled. The indolence and apathy bred by the present legal conditions go so far that very often at consistorial elections, which alone afford the possibility of prescribing a definite course to the administration of worship, the great majority of the electors stay away from the ballot-box. An opposition to these patriarchal conditions formed after the annexation. Many Jews of the Imperial Territory became acquainted with the conditions in the Jewish communities of the Empire proper; they saw a lively activity there, and told themselves that self-government would have produced the same. On the other hand, Jews from the Empire proper had immigrated into Alsace-Lorraine who felt themselves cramped by the new conditions of worship. Instead of having a voice and a hand in matters of worship, as in their own homes, they now had only the right to pay and be silent; instead of being, as formerly, active members of the communal organism, they had now sunk to be objects of communal or consistorial administration.
In the middle of the 'eighties, various occurrences became known which justified the conclusion that certain members of the Strasburg communal administration were in no way fitted for their office. The elements from which the opposition in Strasburg was recruited drew from these occurrences the further conclusion that the Consistory was not in a position to secure orderly conditions in the individual communities, and especially in Strasburg; they therefore demanded that the Consistory should hear the community in appointing the members of the Strasburg communal administration. After severe struggles the Lower Alsatian Consistory gave way and accepted the proposals which the community made. Later this measure was extended to the whole of Lower Alsace and to Lorraine. In Upper Alsace everything remained as of old. A large number of Mülhausen communal electors did indeed, three years ago, request the Consistory to appoint the communal commission anew on the basis of proposals from the community. They were, however, refused; and for reasons connected with local conditions they did not wish to risk conflicts with the Consistory.
