Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 21 · 22 May 1903
12printed page
scan 12 of 20
Facsimile · scan 12 of 20
Scan of p. 12
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 12 — "Die Welt" — No. 21

(continued from page 11)

…bill of damages ought to be paid by the many anti-Zionist Jews in St. Petersburg and Riga and the Jewish Russians. The Jewish readers of a New York paper have subscribed 1500 pounds sterling for Kishineff, more than they have ever given for Zionism. But prevention is better than cure. Jewish money can be had for every purpose save a Jewish one. A Jew offered thousands of pounds for a statue of Kosciuszko, the Polish hero of liberty. They were refused as an impertinence, because they came from a Jew. He did not seem to think of supporting his own heroes of liberty. A Jewish lady in London spends 10,000 pounds a year on musical institutions. There is no Jew in the world who has ever once given Zionism 10,000 pounds. But then, of course, it is vulgar to buy Palestine.

Palestine Can Only be Created, not Bought.

My friends, you cannot buy Palestine. If you had 100 millions, you could at most buy the place where Palestine once stood. Palestine itself you would have to create anew by labour, until milk and honey flow there again. The land is a good land, not so good as Samuel Montagu described it before he became a Baronet, not so bad as he now asserts it to be. But it needs a great scheme of irrigation. To return thither needs no miracle; even to-day a third part of the population there is Jewish. If the Almighty Himself brought the rest of us to Palestine by a miracle, what should we gain but a free passage? In the sweat of our brow we should have to till our Palestine, and therefore the day on which we obtain Palestine, though it were the most joyful, will also be the hardest of our movement.

Dr. Herzl on the Progress of Zionism.

Is that day near? I do not know. I can only say that Dr. Herzl was in London a few days ago and authorised me to tell this meeting that he is satisfied with our progress and that the next Congress will be a momentous one. I personally have never expected that the confusions of 1800 years would clear themselves up in a day. All that we can do is to begin to turn towards our goal, to work and to wait, to organise our forces so as to be ready for the opportunity. History moves not in days, but in epochs.

A Preparatory School for Palestine.

"It is not thy task to complete the work," says the Talmud, "but thou hast not the right to neglect it." Instead of waiting idly, it would perhaps be time to make a beginning somewhere in our old, historic dwelling-places. The idea is already beginning to occupy other heads than ours. In the Birmingham "Daily Post" of May 7th, Chamberlain's organ, I read an article under the heading "Ancient Chaldea," which dealt with the view of Sir William Willcocks that Mesopotamia, if it were treated like Egypt, would bear fruit likewise and would once more become the garden of the East. The author develops this in a manner which may interest you. To put 16 million pounds into this undertaking certainly seems a better business than 20 or 30 into the Bagdad Railway. In any case the figures and expectations of Sir W. Willcocks warrant serious consideration. It may be pointed out that the millions of Baron Hirsch which were left to further the return of the Jews to Palestine lie, so far as we know, unused, and probably the trustees do not quite know how to employ them. It would be a chance for Zionism if all that Mr. W. Willcocks says could be carried out. It is remarkable that I myself, in my first article on Zionism in the "Contemporary Review," suggested the same region as a place of settlement. Our ties with Chaldea stand second only to those with Palestine. Some of our prayers are Chaldaic, such as the Kaddish, the holiest of them all. The Babylonian Talmud stood higher than the Jerusalem. Perhaps Chaldea, in the words of Colonel Goldsmid, may be a preparatory school for Palestine. Perhaps we must, like our forefathers, wander forty years in the wilderness. But we must have a plan, and the "Ica" cannot keep its millions from us, even if we demand the capital and not merely the revenues.

The Secret of Success.

I see a spark of Jewish humour in one of Baron Hirsch's provisions. The "Ica" must spend its whole annual income every year; it may not save. How well the Baron knew the petty mind and Philistinism of the Jewish "philanthropists," their reluctance to draw a bold line under the expenditure! The Baron could permit the society to spend millions, but he could not make sure that it would do so. One thing he could ordain: they should spend their income to the last kreuzer. But now I call upon them to employ their capital upon a centralised colonisation, similar to that which the Birmingham "Daily Post" suggests. Nor will I flog a dead horse and prove once more how impossible it is for a committee scattered over all Europe to oversee small colonies scattered over three continents. Months ago I received a piteous petition from a colony in North America. I turned to an American friend, and he wrote and telegraphed to Paris, whence he learned that this colony was under the direct supervision of London. London doubted the correctness of the complaint. But Paris doubted the correctness of the London views, and finally the wretched colonists were furnished with cattle and agricultural implements. I was glad of it, but I do not see why I should do the work of the "Ica." For this work is impossible. One great colony is worth more than a hundred scattered ones. A man of business knows how to concentrate his labour and reduce his expenses. I am only an idealist, but I see that Mr. Carnegie describes the secret of success thus: "that one puts all one's eggs in one basket and watches that basket!"

Zion, the Home of the Jews.

The Jews must be brought out of Russia into a central home. Russia has not changed her view since that Council of Ministers. She is still in favour of letting the Jews go.

How do I know this? Well! Last year a Russian Zionist Congress took place at Minsk. Five hundred delegates from all parts of Russia assembled there. The Russian Jews, who are forbidden to organise self-help societies, are encouraged to form associations for leaving Russia! To get the Jews out of Russia and to regenerate them was Hirsch's highest thought. Zionism offers him the fulfilment of his dream and an army of capable workers. "Here