No. 21 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
...distributed among 7 colonies, and continues: "You must not forget that all this is only the beginning of my undertaking. This land suffices for only 10,000—15,000 people. But what is that? A mere trifle. I need more land. I shall shortly appoint a special commission, which is to work out a scheme of colonisation on a broader basis and to purchase at least 3 to 4 million acres of land. Meanwhile I intend to send over 4000—5000 people a year, and in two years I hope to be in a position to invite the leading representatives of the European and American press to visit my colonies and to convince themselves with their own eyes whether the Jews are fit for something better than mere trading. Mr. Wolf seems to have been surprised by this great new scheme of emigration. In his breast the rival hope of an improvement of the situation in Russia seems at that time still to have reigned. "Is there no hope of better days in Russia?" he asks. "None whatever — at least for a long time to come. The persecution of those of other faiths is inseparable from the present state of things in Russia. But if my scheme succeeds, it will bring the blush of shame to the face of every Russian. The time will come when I shall fetch 300,000—400,000 Jews who are prospering in their flourishing homesteads in Argentina — peaceful and respected citizens, a valuable source of national wealth. Then we shall be in a position to set them over against their brethren who are demoralised by the persecutions. What will the Jew-haters say then? I have set my mind on not leaving off the work. If my strength or my fortune could accomplish it, believe me, the whole Jewish population of Russia would be removed from the country."
"In two years —" instead of the visit to the Jewish colonies, the press reported the funeral ceremonies of Baron Hirsch. And his ideas were buried with him. "The first thing the trustees did," says Mr. Lousada, "was to call a halt to emigration to Argentina." There were 3000 souls there in the year 1894; in the year 1903 there are 4274 there all told.
Baron Hirsch on His Life's Task.
But perhaps even the most reliable interview is still no fully valid testimony. Is there no testimony from the Baron's own hand? That too I had the good fortune to discover. It appeared three months before the above-quoted poem of "Punch," in the "North American Review." In this article the great philanthropist sets forth his ideas, "It is my inmost conviction that I may regard myself only as the temporary administrator of the fortune which I have amassed . . . . . I am quite decidedly opposed to the old system of alms-giving, which only produces more beggars . . . . . I see my highest task in opening up to the professors of Judaism, who have been oppressed for thousands of years, the possibility of a physical and moral regeneration.
That was Baron Hirsch's highest task in life!
A Dreamer of the Ghetto.
Unhappily he did not understand how to carry it out. He had not the political genius to carry out his own wishes — he was only a good man. He knew how to project railway lines, but the line along which his people might be led to physical and moral
regeneration he did not know how to build. He wished to lead them back to agriculture, to re-accustom a too impatient race to the processes of Nature, which demand patience, but alas — he was himself an impatient child of the Ghetto. He was the greatest Ghetto dreamer of our contemporary generation. One of his dreams was that one could pluck the Jews out of their overcrowded Ghettos at a single grasp and transplant them to lonely farms at the other end of the world. And yet it is strange that he did not recognise that Palestine was the only land whose soil could exercise an attraction upon the Jews, for in his own article, combating the idea that the Jews had no inclination for agricultural or industrial labour, he pointed out that the ancient Israelites had been husbandmen par excellence, that they had tilled their fields so long as they were politically independent; that they had then bred their flocks and practised handicrafts. But notwithstanding his failure to recognise the true solution, the only solution of the Jewish question, "the creation of a home in Palestine secured by public law," several causes obscured the truth from him. His own experiments in Argentina were due not to free choice but to the accident of his taking over the debt-titles of certain Argentine territories which were among the assets of the Murietta bankruptcy. He made provision for colonists, but not for markets. And instead of the pauperisation of the emigrants being avoided and their physical and moral regeneration furthered, the first steps were attended by painful acts of mendicancy and immorality.
A Tale from the Thousand and One Nights.
One need only hear this good man speaking to Mr. Lucien Wolf to see how impossible success was. Every group of 50 Russian families, provided with a rabbi and a doctor, formed a complete community by itself. On arrival each family went straight to its house, which it found ready and finished in every detail, with 6 or 8 oxen in the stalls, 2 ploughs and 2 harrows in the sheds, and some 190 acres of land nicely prepared for it. Have you ever heard such a fairy-tale?
The majority of the poor people came from the cellars of their Russian hovels, in ships of which they had never before had any notion, crossed an endless, mysterious expanse of water, and were set down in palaces, wonderful to them, standing ready for them in every detail, with beds made and clocks going, with pepper and salt in the boxes; they are shown stables with terribly horned wild beasts, which they do not know to be oxen, and round about a white strip of land which, they are told, belongs to them. It is touching. It is like a tale from the Thousand and One Nights, and the Baron is the good genie. Dear, good magician, our hearts overflow towards thee! But the most naïve part is yet to come. "So complete are the preparations," says the good Baron, "that the colonists can set to work the very next morning."
"The Peasant Is No Toy."
They have scarcely stopped rubbing their eyes and already they are setting about the tillage of their broad land. My God, such a clockwork scheme was doomed to failure. The Baron did not understand that peasants cannot be set up in Argentina like toys bought in a shop.
But the real root cause of his mistake was that he acted entirely alone. The Jew had not nö
