Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 42
(continued from page 1)
…is suddenly set down in the Argentine, in an uncultivated region, and is to make the soil arable. He toils in the sweat of his brow, but he does not understand the business, and even if he readily grasps the instructions, he is not so readily equal to the labour. He toils one, two, three years. He sees that he is getting nowhere. He begins to reflect. For what is he toiling at a wholly unaccustomed, heavy labour? He has nothing from it, neither his wife nor his child. And the Argentine? What is the Argentine to him? What's Hecuba to him? He lacks all sentimental romanticism. He leaves plough and flail lying, goes to Buenos Aires and deals in old clothes. Well, and in Palestine? Yes, there sentimental romanticism helps him over many difficulties. The same Melamed, the same broker and trader who comes to Palestine as a colonist has, to be sure, to struggle there too with great, perhaps even greater difficulties. But before he went there, he prayed three times a day, his face turned towards the East, for the return of the Jews to Palestine. Now he is there. He must work hard and go in want besides. His patience is sorely tried. But he has a moral stay; he has a great idea which drives him to persevere. He knows that he is a pioneer for the re-establishment of the Jewish people, and he works and goes without — for his people, for his land. This idea affords him a spiritual delight which rewards him for all his toil. That is what sentimental romanticism does! This is not merely a clever contrivance; it is really so, and is proved by facts. Almost all the colonists of the Argentine are Zionists and shekel-payers, and wish for nothing more ardently than to be transferred to Palestine. The Palestinian labourers, on the other hand, are not to be induced to leave Palestine even by larger offers of money.
As regards the unfruitfulness of Palestine, the soil of Palestine, neglected for centuries, certainly cannot in general be called fruitful. But who does not know that this was once the land that flowed with milk and honey? And does the Imperial Chancellor doubt that by industry and perseverance, with the aid of present-day means of cultivation, it can be made such again? Had he visited the Jewish colonies when he was in Palestine, this doubt would have been removed. The Zionist deputation to the German Emperor in Palestine visited these colonies and was especially delighted with Rishon le Zion, which looks not like a village but like a splendid garden. One of the gentlemen remarked that the entire surroundings consisted of nothing but sandy soil. Whereupon a colonist observed: "Before we founded Rishon, it was exactly the same sandy desert as its surroundings." A few years of enthusiastic labour had sufficed to conjure a garden into a desert. That is what sentimental romanticism has done. Enthusiasm in work is the best manure.
The view that the educated and well-to-do do not join in colonization is no doubt well founded in the case where it is a question of bread. But it cannot be maintained when it is evident that a national movement is concerned. Moreover, the contrary has been proved by facts. Among the first pioneers of Palestinian colonization were Jewish university students from Russia, who founded the colony of Chederah. The colony of Rechovoth was founded without any assistance whatever by well-to-do people only. Recently the society "Geulah," consisting of people in good circumstances, has been formed for similar purposes. Of the hundreds of thousands of Zionists a considerable part belongs to the well-to-do and a still greater part to the educated class. Whoever attends the Zionist Congresses will not find that the hundreds of delegates are schnorrers.
It is to be wished that the much-occupied Chancellor of the German Empire may find some leisure to inform himself exactly as to the true substance and purpose of Zionism; then assuredly he, too, will correct his opinion of it.
Sir Harry Johnston on the East Africa Project.
Mr. J. L. Greenberg has lately received the following letter from the well-known explorer of East Africa, Sir Harry H. Johnston:
Dear Mr. Greenberg! In reply to your letter of 26 September, I can tell you that I have carefully considered the question of the founding of a Jewish colony in British East Africa in connection with the information received from you. Since you ask me for my personal opinion, I shall give it to you in the following remarks. First, then, the situation of the territory which the British Government would place at the disposal of the Jewish colony. The boundaries you indicated on the map would have to be altered a little before they would appear to me entirely suitable. These alterations I have indicated to you. Should my suggestions be accepted by your Committee and approved by the English Government, I can say that no better choice could have been made among all the regions of East Africa and Uganda. Last year, when the project arose, it was said that the British Government was placing at the disposal of the Zionist Committee a considerable territory in Tanaland or farther to the north in Gallaland. The story may well be untrue, but I believe I must emphasize that any such offer would have been meant only ironically. It would mean giving the East European Jews a land that is either too hot and unhealthy or waterless and peopled by wild tribes. Under such conditions, which, it is true, from the English standpoint would not injure British interests, the offer would not be acceptable to the Jews. Then again we were told that the land to be chosen lay either near the Kikuyu country, along the Uganda Railway, or on the Nandi plateau. This plan seemed to me not free from criticism, since we would be giving away to non-British subjects a particularly valuable piece of land, which can bring the British taxpayer a return for his outlay on the Uganda Railway, or, in the case of the Kikuyu country, would be offering a territory which was for the most part already occupied by an industrious native population and which we had no right to give away. The final choice of the British Government, the Gwas' Ngishu plateau (if your statements are correct), is, after the modifications I have made, quite unobjectionable. It excludes the land belonging to the Nandi and Kavirondo tribes, leaves to the British settlers the unoccupied parts of the Nandi plateau and the region about Ravine Station, and at the same time scarcely touches at all the districts inhabited by the agricultural Negroes. Nevertheless the land is very desirable — one of the finest parts of the East Africa Protectorate. It is by no means unhealthy for Europeans. It is fertile and very well watered by abundant streams, and possesses several splendid mountain ranges which in places rise to 10,000 and 14,000 feet. Some parts of the chosen territory which contain settlements of Kavirondo Negroes would, as regards their legitimate native owners, not
