Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 3.
One fine day, therefore, the Jewish teachers of religion residing in the Theresienstadt received a letter signed by the President of the Israelite School Committee, the Royal Notary Weinmann Fülöp, and by the Israelite Inspector of Schools, Dr. Munkácsi Bernát, in which there was much talk of liberal-mindedness, Liberalism and the like, and in which at the close the person concerned was politely — as politely as superiors always are — called upon to express, on an enclosed sheet and with his own signature, his readiness for the "Liberal" work of agitation. Such, roughly, are the facts of the case, in so far as they can at present be surveyed at all amid the welter of accusations and excuses, declarations and counter-declarations.
The affair has meanwhile grown into a regular affair of state. The President of the Religious Community issues a tortuous declaration that the same does not wish to interfere in the electoral contest; "Egyenlőség" also censures the matter, and in particular that the superior addressed written requests to his subordinates instead of doing so by word of mouth; Vászony publishes a sharply worded letter to the President of the Israelite Religious Community; and a large number of members of the Israelite School Board resign their honorary offices. But the climax is not yet reached. On a single day 120 Theresienstadt Democrats announce, for themselves and their families, their withdrawal from Judaism, and many others still wish to follow their example.
Whoever still has any feeling for Judaism at all, and above all the Hungarian rabbis, must take up a position towards this grave spectacle. For years there has been thundering against Zionism from almost every Jewish pulpit, and the profession of Jewish nationality has been declared a crime, high treason. When in the autumn the Misrachist Congress sat at Pozsony, the worst means were just good enough to induce old, venerable, orthodox rabbis from all parts of Hungary to protest against the Zionists, these "enemies of Judaism and of Jewry."
The assimilation-rabbis have now received a loudly audible answer in the Theresienstadt of Budapest. Hundreds of Jews have believed them when they said that Judaism forms no race, no nationality, but merely a religion, such as there are six others besides in the Magyar nation. Of the necessity, of the goodness, nay, of the teachings of this religion at all, the rabbis who preach Magyarism and assimilation have not known how to convince their faithful, but only of this: that out of piety, indolence, indifference, or a certain standpoint of sheer contrariness they must not forsake the faith of their fathers and of their birth, but must regard it as a misfortune and patiently bear it onward. But now something intervenes. A Jewish Inspector of Schools has agitated in an improper manner against the Democratic candidate — and straightway some hundreds of families cease to "believe" in Mosaism and become Roman or Greek Catholic, Calvinist or Lutheran, Nazarene or without confession. A year ago some hundreds of families in Arad wished to "leave Judaism" because the community tax is too high. In future we may well expect mass baptisms when a rabbi preaches with a hoarse voice on Yom Kippur, or the wife of the president of the congregation possesses a finer hat than the others, or when a quarrel arises at the card-party. That a man, even though he be a member of the House of Magnates appointed to represent Jewish interests, should have himself baptized on account of vexations with business friends, and all the more when a public appointment or advancement is in question, are indeed such everyday things that no rabbi any longer grows excited about them, and so the mass withdrawal in the Theresienstadt doubtless explains itself. From the civic rifle club or the volunteer fire brigade one will hardly withdraw at once when a rifleman or a fireman becomes obnoxious to one; but from Judaism?
Will not the occurrences in the Theresienstadt after all be of some use to Hungarian Jewry? There are still hundreds of thousands who cling to Judaism in the old fidelity and prize it as the highest good on earth. The memory still lives of the Jews of Buda who suffered the death of martyrs, who a second time left the country, for without Judaism the Hungarian homeland could offer them nothing.
Vászony, in his letter to the President of the Community, openly and strongly emphasized his Judaism and his love for it, but in doing so expressed the opinion that he was first of all a Magyar, and then a Jew, a Jew by religion. It is doubtless useless to polemize much against Vászony's view, but a small digression may be permitted. Some years ago there passed away a man who, like Vászony, was a parliamentarian. The world called him Earl of Beaconsfield, he himself called himself Benjamin Disraeli. An assimilationist father led the fourteen-year-old son to the baptismal font, but Disraeli knew well that he had not thereby lost his Judaism. "I am a Jew and you are Britons," he said when he stood at the summit of power, and in his novels and words he had untiringly emphasized that he was a Jew, only a Jew. I do not know whether after this confession he could be deputy for the Theresienstadt, but wherever Rule Britannia is sung by the hundreds of millions of Englishmen, Disraeli is held to be his country's greatest statesman. Herr Vászony can therefore see that one may be a great man and yet need not, like him, hold Judaism to be a mere confession, such as, say, the Greek non-Uniate or the Unitarian. No, Judaism is much, much more; it is a nationality, it is a people, and how mightily this works, Disraeli again shows. Brought up in Protestantism, he is led back by the Jewish national feeling to the old faith of his people — and when the hour of parting draws near, the prescribed prayers resound at his urgent wish and, the name of the One and Only upon his lips, he breathes out his soul amid the grief of many millions.
What Disraeli said, many hundreds of thousands, millions, proclaim to-day. "We are Jews and can be nothing else — French, German and Magyar Jews, but Jews, nothing but Jews."
The Magyar Protest-rabbis protest — but it is to be hoped, after the Theresienstadt case, no longer all of them. Now everyone can see clearly how much "religion" remains after the work of assimilation and the ministrations of the assimilation-rabbi. Whoever, therefore, is sincere and honest in his regard for the Jewish religion cannot separate it from the Jewish national feeling; he must and will be a Zionist.
But whoever wishes to be only a Magyar "of the Mosaic confession," let him do at once that to which the example of his Theresienstadt "fellow-nationals" will later spur him on, and have himself baptized forthwith; the assimilation-rabbis, of course, at the head. How they are received over yonder is their affair; we may be firmly convinced, after the example of the Marranos, of Disraeli and others, that the Jewish national feeling will bring their children to land among us again, but
