Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 7 · 17 February 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 7

(continued from page 3)

…est places have been ours as the nobles of the world, and that we have survived all this. And, it is said, we can endure still more, so long as those among us who are favoured by fortune stand by the less fortunate, until we become a people again in Palestine. These conclusions, however, leave out of account many important changes in the conditions which have surrounded us during the last fifty, sixty or seventy years, and which until then had not existed since the Diaspora. The bond formed by the Synagogue, in part religious and in great part national, has everywhere been loosened. This has more than one cause. The "emancipation" of the Jews in the Western countries, and the influence of greater freedom of thought in the world, led the Synagogue to water down its Jewish nationality where the Jews through "emancipation" became more and more citizens of the land of their birth, and to relax its vigilance over such members of the community as came under the influence of general culture. The Synagogue, aided by persecution of and contempt for the Jews, was for centuries the only power which protected the Jews from fusion with the other peoples of the world — that is to say, fusion of thought, of spirit, of the unity of human interests. To-day the Synagogue as such a power is everywhere weak, and grows weaker from day to day. Even in countries where persecution still prevails, the Synagogue gives way to "culture," and the young Jew of the ghetto is nowadays often just as little heeded, and has much less respect for orthodox usages, than the young Jew of the West. I need not enter more closely upon this point here. Zionists are agreed that the Jewish question awaits its solution. Many, however, think that the indolent "laissez faire" which they so severely condemn in others is justified for them, simply because they have professed Zionist principles. Once they have professed these, they believe they have done their duty; because they have, rightly, set their minds upon Zion, they are content to let things take their course until Zion becomes their own; they disregard the purposes for the sake of which we need Zion, and the other work which becomes necessary as a forerunner, or can at any rate be very helpful. Indeed, in their case the "laissez faire" is only one step removed from that which animates their opponents. When we, who refuse to look upon the position of our people with equanimity, when we, who refuse to fold our hands and wait for Zion, give expression to our anxiety, they mock us and tell us that we are lacking in faith; they say that we have God's promise and the prophecies. It seems to me, however, that in every case where the fulfilment of prophecies has been demonstrated with mathematical exactness, human labour has played an important, an essential part in it.

If, accordingly, Zionists are not justified in holding aloof from the East African offer, if the responsibility rests upon them that the offer shall not miscarry through its infinite importance being overlooked, I nevertheless maintain that their activity in this regard has limits. The funds at our disposal are none too great, and must be administered with great caution until it is possible for us to apply them to their real purposes in Palestine. This applies also to the time and the energy which the Zionist Federation as a body expends upon any scheme, however important it may be, that lies outside Palestine. Some among our opponents have frequently told us that they sympathise with our ideals and that our aims have their approval, but that Palestine is impossible. And just as the East African scheme does not require the whole strength of the Zionists, so it ought to find the approval of all Jews who profess that they would like to do something tangible for the betterment of the condition of their people. It ought therefore not to be difficult, in view of the advantages to be expected, to form a special league ad hoc which would occupy itself with the offer of the Government, provided that the report justifies the pursuit of it. A company for taking over and exploiting the territory should be formed, the profit of the shareholders should be limited to, let us say, 5 per cent., and all remaining surpluses should be applied to the benefit of the territory. I have no doubt that such a company will without difficulty obtain favourable and just conditions. The company would undertake pioneer work, and a gradual migration of Jews to the territory would take place, which in this way would easily become a Jewish settlement. Its inhabitants would live there under infinitely more favourable conditions than in Eastern Europe or in the slums of England or of the United States. They would be bidden welcome in this settlement; that would at any rate be something new to the emigrating Jew.

An important objection to the East African scheme is, now, that a Jewish autonomy has been granted, and I must say at the outset that for those who wish to regard the Jews only as a religious sect, whose conceptions of Judaism are so parochial that they are afraid to look upon the Jews as a people, and whose ideas of religion are so limited that they can conceive of it only as surrounded and enclosed by formulas and creeds, I mean to say that for such the objection is valid. I can very well imagine that people with such narrow-hearted ideas can be content to see the Jews oppressed and to let them sink more and more into degradation, only so as not to take part in an attempt to raise them as a people. But I should be infinitely sorry to have to admit that our people as a whole has sunk so low, or that of all the patriotism which the Jews with Oriental liberality bestow upon all the peoples among whom they dwell, nothing has been left over for their own people.

This bugbear of autonomy, out of which so much capital has been sought to be made, is in reality by no means so alarming. All that is proposed is that the territory should be placed under the administration of Jews, who would be appointed or confirmed by the English Government. Doctor Herzl laid stress upon this point because such an autonomy is the only natural means by which the whole great territory could become and remain a specifically Jewish one. It is the only possible guarantee, for it would surely be ridiculous to expect the English Government to sanction any project by which the exclusion of non-Jews from a territory under the control of the Crown becomes a definite provision. Nor is it to be supposed that by any other means regulations and laws which a Jewish population would need could be so easily introduced. I give only one example — a very important one — I mean the legal day of rest. Under the contemplated autonomy the Sabbath would naturally be this day. Is it not evident that this would be of infinite value, if only for the physical revival of our people? The essential thing in the proposed plan is that the territory for Jews at-