Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 7 · 17 February 1905
8printed page
scan 8 of 20
Facsimile · scan 8 of 20
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 7.

And the lecturer was the well-known explorer of Palestine, Col. C. R. Conder. It was no lecture; it was a hymn, a triumph of Palestinian Zionism. Here spoke a man who is held to be the first authority in Palestine exploration, an outsider, a Christian, and every word was a praise of Palestine, every expression was a hope, a dream. A politician spoke there who does not pursue the politics of the day, but sees events in their historical light, who looks with an equally sober eye backward as forward. Palestine, he says, is a good land, flowing with milk and honey, as it always was. Palestine could become a little Asiatic Switzerland, but for that one needs men who will make it so. No one knows what future awaits Turkey, but it is beyond doubt that the Palestinian question will become an international question. England cannot stand wholly aloof from this question, since the Suez Canal is, after all, close by, and the other countries are not indifferent either. And if the question should one day be opened, then — how does the Talmud say? — "Kol hakodem soche" — then one must make use of the opportunity. And to make this possible, one must work. One must draw forces to Palestine, young ones, capable of work, without troubling oneself about the question of autonomy. Time brings counsel. After Nebuchadnezzar came Cyrus... But in Palestine the work must be done. And I quote a fine saying from the speech of the gallant Colonel Conder: "I do not see why an Ezra or a Jehuda Makkabi should not once again arise there, as it once was, if only you recognise him at the right time.

I do not wish to touch upon outside questions. I stood upon Mount Zion and looked out over Palestine, but if one can reach Mount Zion by railway from the Zanzibar coast, then — I have been proved wrong." I will not touch upon the question either, because it is an "outside" one, not inherent in the nature and the purpose of Zionism, and I likewise marvel with Col. Conder. And I would impress upon my readers and friends the words of the honourable explorer: "I fervently believe that in the course of the present generation one of two things will come to pass. Either you will become a people which, scattered over the whole world, yet has a home that will become the homeland of the people, or you will be swallowed up by the nations among whom you live — and then there will be no Israel any more." Either — or!...

Spectator.


Paris Letter.

Paris, 7 February.

I.

In accordance with the resolution of the meeting of the "Fédération Sioniste de France" held on 25 December 1904, to arrange a series of agitation addresses here, Dr. Max Nordau delivered on Saturday evening last a spirited lecture in the synagogue of the Polish-Russian Jews in the rue de l’Hotel de Ville. A densely packed crowd streamed thither to listen to the words of the revered master. After a warm address by the chairman, Rabbi Dr. Lubetzky, in which he made his confession that he was not against Uganda, since the eventual acceptance of the Uganda project does not exclude Zion, in that we remain mindful of the promises of our Prophets that we shall regain Zion, Dr. Nordau rose to speak amid stormy acclamations. His address developed approximately the following thoughts:

From the first moment of the Uganda project there has unhappily prevailed in many Zionist circles a grave misunderstanding, namely, that Uganda amounts to the setting aside of Zion. No; it cannot be emphasised enough that Uganda was never conceived as a proposal to replace Zion, and that Uganda is not contained in Zionism. We are and remain Zionists. But we are a people without a land, and such a people has not the right to reject a land which a great Government so magnanimously offers it. The Zionist Organisation has all the less right to reject this offer, in that, by the fact that a great Government officially negotiates with it, it is recognised before all the world as the sole organisation of the Jewish people. Not to any Kahal, not to the J. C. A. — that misunderstanding executrix of a great will — not even to the Anglo-Jewish did the English Government turn, but to us Zionists, who do not boastfully protest that we are circumcised Gauls or circumcised Anglo-Saxons, and so forth; but we say, we are the delegates of our people. We therefore could not and might not disavow ourselves by referring the English Government to other, better qualified heads of our people. We received this offer and forwarded it to its destination — to the Congress. If the land is found good, we shall say to the Jewish people: "Do as it pleases thee." Therewith we discharge our task as Zionists; no more. It is not we Zionists who will concern ourselves with the realisation of the Uganda project — we have not, indeed, sufficient ready money to devote to Zionism — but there are surely other Jews, non-Zionists, who will surely be willing to concern themselves with it.

Hitherto it has not been Jews, but Zionist Christians, who have raised the sums required for the expedition. Now the Commission is at work examining the land in all directions. If the report on settlement is favourable, then the Jewish Colonial Bank will receive a Charter in which it will be stated, not only according to the letter, but also with the reservation that sense and spirit be not falsified, that Jewish inhabitants are permitted to order their affairs according to their wishes, and in which it is guaranteed to them that, subject to English rights, they shall in no case forfeit their freedom. The settlers will know what they have, what they owe, when they have to pay. From the first moment care will be taken that the Jewish spirit shall freely assert itself. But should the land be bad, we shall say: "You too did not know what manner of land it is; we thank you most kindly!"

In the year 1648, during the Cossack rising, great calamity was brought down upon the Jews; hundreds, thousands of Jews were massacred, tortured, martyred. Thousands of others escaped the blood-bath by flight. And throughout all Europe one saw a spectacle of Jewish flight. But at that time there was Jewish solidarity. The Jew of the West was affrighted when he saw the gaunt martyr-figures, but he did not turn them from the threshold. Few Jews had houses of their own, one lived in narrow quarters, but one pushed the beds together, one shared the morsel. Now too a flight of Jews is in progress. Eighty thousand have landed in New York in the last months. It is not love of travel, not delight in change, that drives them forth from their home, but the bitter Jewish distress! How, now, do the fortunate Jews behave? They do not stretch out their hand with a Baruch-haba to the newcomers! "We do not know you, Polacks," is the watchword. Efforts are made to be rid of them.

Never was it my wish to be rich. But now I wish it! I wish it with all the strength of my soul, I feel a greed for money like a usurer, in order to be able to relieve this boundless distress! Every day these unfortunates knock at my door, to beg of me a little piece of bread, or with the request to be sent to America. I did my utmost! But ever new ones come. Now, America