Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 11.
(continued from page 1)
...visionaries can believe that with a charter in their hands they will at once embark millions of people and carry them over into the new lands. A mass colonisation cannot be created artificially: one must so prepare the territory that it naturally attracts masses of immigrants, as America now attracts them. Why do so many poor people go to America? Because in America there is a great demand for working hands. This demand for workers exists only in industrially developed countries. Consequently one must above all prepare the land for industrial development, that is, one must industrialise the land."
On the strength of such considerations, which run counter to all the findings of political economy, one arrives at the conclusion that in Palestine, as in every other uncultivated country, only small-scale colonisation is possible for a long time to come. Truly wonderful! So then: in order to be able to carry on colonisation on a large scale, one must first industrialise the land. But in order to industrialise a land, one must first have much human material and great capital in that same land. "Why do so many people go to America?" Simply because in America there are so many millions of people with their manifold needs, and so many milliards of dollars besides. In fact America began to industrialise only after it already possessed many millions of people and several milliards of dollars. We thus remain stuck in a circulus vitiosus. Large-scale colonisation presupposes the industrialisation of the land, but industrial development has a surplus of human material and capital as its precondition. With the small colonisation of our old and new Chovevei-Zionists one can never industrialise a land.
In truth the solution lies elsewhere.
Mr. Soskin²) has already pointed out that it is essentially a matter of the contrast between unsystematic and systematic colonisation. In order that a large-scale colonisation may be possible, one need not first industrialise the land, which is sheer nonsense, but must set about the colonisation systematically. At all events Mr. Soskin³) holds that "hitherto not a single attempt at a large-scale colonisation, such as may in the common sense coincide with the notion of rapid colonisation, has been brought to a happy success on the part of European peoples." We must remark, however, that the future Jewish colonisation has no analogue whatever in history, that with us it is precisely a matter of an ethical colonisation, which is conditioned by quite other factors. Where it was in some measure a question of roughly similar motives of emigration for the colonisation, there large-scale colonisation has in fact succeeded. A Russian Zionist has already pointed out that 2 million negroes emigrated to Liberia (Africa) in 10 years, 750,000 to New Zealand (Australia) in 60 years, and fully 4 million people to Australia in 100 years. So it was also with the Boer immigration into South Africa.
But when our calculators of genius come and show us that, since the establishment of one colonist costs 5000 francs, 5 milliard francs will have to be spent for the settlement of a million colonists, one must really shake one's head. These people forget the proverb: Where two can eat, a third may find room. If in the first year after the beginning of the colonisation we can establish 5000 settlers with a given capital x, then with the same capital in the following year we shall be able to establish 6000 settlers. The reduction of the costs of settlement increases progressively with the increase in the number of colonists already present in the new land. Even if we take only private-enterprise colonisation into account, it is clear that 5000 tillers of the soil are in a position to support a whole series of artisans, traders and intellectual workers. The more people there are in the area of colonisation, the faster industry can develop, the more cheaply new elements can establish themselves, the more generous in scale the colonisation becomes. One must therefore cease forever repeating the same litany about the impossibility of an early large-scale colonisation: nothing, absolutely nothing, speaks against its possibility. If Zionism really means to solve the Jewish question integrally, it will simply have to carry on colonisation on a large scale; otherwise it will become philanthropy or snobbery.
And now, what kind of land does Zionism need?
We put the question now without going into whether a people can choose its fatherland at its own discretion. Of that later.
In his letter to Sir Francis Montefiore Dr. Herzl formulated the answer to this question as follows (we quote from a Russian translation): 1. The land must be large enough for the immigration of great masses, so that the transplantation can lessen the Jewish distress in the eastern countries. That was said with reference to Uganda. With reference to Zionism this condition must be formulated thus: The land must be large enough to be able to receive the Jewish people; in its extent, its climatic conditions and its geographical situation it must be able to receive the whole mass of the Jewish people.
- The land must suit a people, the colonisation of a people such as ours; that is, it must offer the possibility of physical adaptation. 3. The concession must grant us such autonomous rights as can fully secure the Jewish character of the colonisation; at all events the possibility of the development of an autonomous Jewish culture must be guaranteed not merely by external but also by internal, or rather objective, factors. 4. Finally — and this is also the most important — the interest of our people in the whole matter must be so great that the Jews could easily bear all the great difficulties that will arise in the regulation of the Jewish colonisation. More still: the land must possess a special power of attraction, not merely for the poorest of the people but for all elements; in the contrary case the emigration from the Diaspora would cease as soon as the distress of the Jewish masses had been removed from the world — whether through the improvement of the general social conditions of life, or through the rarefaction of the Jewish ghetto.
After these explanations we now return to our main theme. Let us consider first of all the solution proposed by the Territorialists.
In fact Territorialism is dependent upon Uganda, for territory here, territory there — these are empty words without any content whatever, since for the present no territory other than Uganda exists at all. Or does one mean to draw from the fact that the "Ica" has bought new lands in the Argentine the conclusion that the Jewish autonomous commonwealth could be founded in South America? We can scarcely think that anyone seriously considers it possible that in a country with an advan-
- Dr. Soskin: Gross- und Kleinkolonisation, "Altneuland," Vol. I, Nos. 5 and 6.
- Idem: "Jüdische Rundschau," No. 8, p. 83.
