Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 13 · 31 March 1905
1scan
of 20
Facsimile · scan 1 of 20
Scan of scan 1
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Die Welt

Editorial Office and Administration: VIENNA, IX., Türkenstrasse No. 9. Telephone 14.199.

Published every Friday. Correspondence is to be addressed not to individual persons but to the Editorial Office or the Administration: Vienna, IX., Türkenstrasse 9. Unstamped letters are not accepted and manuscripts are not returned. The Editorial Office receives callers daily from 10 to half past 11.

Advertising rates: according to the published tariff. The advertisement section closes on Tuesday evening. Single numbers 30 Heller.

Subscription rates: Austria-Hungary: yearly Kr. 12.—, half-yearly Kr. 6.—, quarterly Kr. 3.—. Abroad: Germany yearly Mk. 13.70, half-yearly Mk. 6.85, quarterly Mk. 3.45; England yearly Shg. 14.—, half-yearly Shg. 7.—, quarterly Shg. 3.10; Russia yearly R. 7.—, half-yearly R. 8.50, quarterly R. 1.75; Switzerland, France, Italy, Turkey, Roumania, Bulgaria, Servia, Greece, Egypt yearly Frcs. 17.—, half-yearly Frcs. 8.50, quarterly Frcs. 4.25; America yearly Doll. 3.40, half-yearly Doll. 1.70, quarterly Doll. —.85.

No. 13. Vienna, 31 March 1905. — 24 Veadar 5665. 9th Year.


Questions of the Day and Points of Dispute in Zionism.*)

III.

At the close of the preceding article we arrived at the conclusion that our goal can only be Palestine. But not merely out of sentiment, which we too know how to value, but which is not decisive. Indeed it seems to us that of late a great deal of mischief has been done with "love of Palestine." People who are thoroughly assimilated, who carry their Judaism in the head and not in the heart, who on the whole can give nothing more than the date by its Hebrew names — and even that only thanks to a calendar translated into German — boast of this "love" of theirs. Much that is artificial, little that is felt, and therefore quite comical. And if one may find in Adam Smith that benevolence plays no part in politics, one may also find in the same author that socio-economic questions are hardly much influenced by sentiment. More comical still is the fear as to whether the Jews will remain Jews elsewhere. After all, the majority of our people will not be in Palestine either so very soon.

Let us leave phrases aside and hold to the facts. These alone suffice to explain that "of all possible and impossible territories, Palestine with the neighbouring lands is the best, the most favourable, and the most capable of development." If we take a stand against empty sentiment, it is not for purely aesthetic reasons. We must make it clear to ourselves once and for all that Territorialism did not come into the world as a deus ex machina, but as the result of objective facts. It is the objective fact of mass emigration and the threatened closing of doors hitherto open that brought Territorialism forth. If we wish to be rid of it, if we wish to cut away from it every right to exist, we must not merely appeal to sentiment, but must strike out on other practical paths, so that Territorialism becomes subjectively superfluous as well.

In short: we must begin colonisation in Palestine with the neighbouring lands as quickly as possible.

Now it is clear that if we confine ourselves to Palestine alone, this demand cannot be fulfilled. We should therefore see the greatest danger to the further development of Zionism in the adoption of Ussischkin's demand that the words "and in the neighbouring lands" be struck out, namely from the first article of the statutes of the National Fund. Ussischkin reasons as follows: "Merely to redeem Palestine and to turn its soil into national property, such colossal sums are necessary that the purchase of land in the neighbouring lands as well, with the moneys of the National Fund, would be nothing short of a crime. For the neighbouring lands, if colonisation is possible and desirable there, other capitalists will be found (the various (?) syndicates), but on no account may even a single groschen of the National Fund be spent on them." "Ewreiskaia Jisn" 1904 No. 12, page 91.)

Should this demand become the dogma of Zionist practice, then every kind of activity in the neighbouring lands is in fact made impossible.**) For let us not forget that Herr Ussischkin claims the already existing Jewish colonisation societies for the purchase of land in Palestine. According to his plan the National Fund is to buy the best and most fertile tracts, Baron Rothschild and the Ica the parcels of land in need of reclamation, while Geula and the small colonisation societies (Esra, the Odessa society, the Palestine Society) are to buy the scattered and dear small parcels of land, all only in Palestine. Then indeed the phrase about the other syndicates that are to colonise in the neighbouring lands is merely a phrase —


*) Prompted by several inquiries, we remark that we by no means identify ourselves with all the arguments of our esteemed fellow Zionist Dr. Pasmanik, even though they are published in the leading position. The Editors.

**) Why? Surely private persons and other societies can be active in that direction? Note of the Publisher.