Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 17 · 28 April 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 17 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

...sapping work to join together with success; but now, too, they produced nothing but sawdust, and their boring was soon drowned by the confusion of voices of earnest master-builders. Many of the builders at work upon the giant edifice had often submitted only reluctantly to the ideas of the chief architect; now, after he has been called away, each believes he can put his favourite plans into execution, and if the building is to be brought to a successful completion, the further working-out of the project must be fixed in all its features. It must prove possible to reach an understanding about the design of the upper storeys and the roofing; about the interior fittings, too, and in particular about the possible shifting or removal of dividing walls, there may be discussion. But of course no one will be permitted to venture to remove corner-stones or supporting pillars of the masterwork thus far advanced, or even to shake the foundations.

The loving elaboration of the image may be pardoned: comparisons limp, to be sure, and yet they not seldom set complicated relations in the right light and can thus contribute considerably to clarification. Three groups have gradually detached themselves from the confusion of voices: Ugandists, Territorialists, Palestinists — this designation I propose for Ussischkin and associates, because it is the shortest and most pregnant, and does not, as the expression "Chowewe-Zion" by now does, carry an offensive by-meaning — I estimate that it will even be claimed with a certain pride by those concerned! Already at this point, however, I should like to protest energetically against this group calling itself "Zione Zion" or believing it holds the lease on "Zionism loyal to Palestine". There are, outside the circle of the Palestinists, Zionists enough who yield them nothing, absolutely nothing, in the most faithful attachment to Palestine, and who nevertheless must sharply combat the most important components of their programme.

As regards Ugandism, I should like to be brief; the discussion of it seems fairly exhausted, the "middle line" of agreement fairly settled. Only of this point had Elias Auerbach perhaps the right to speak as of something "on which we are agreed". Should the report of the expedition prove favourable, the project will be carried out by the relief societies with the political and organisational assistance of the Zionist movement, or else it will simply remain unexecuted. To engage Zionism more closely in it the overwhelming majority will certainly have no inclination, and even among the steadfast Ugandists the intention of making a grand affair of state out of the matter seems to exist only here and there; for Pasmanik surely speaks from the heart of many who regard the plan with great sympathy when he holds that it is not worth while to let serious differences arise among us on that account.

On the other hand I hold it exceedingly questionable when an attempt is made to deny the Ugandists membership of the party; that the warmest recommendation of the project is compatible with the most thoroughgoing Zionism will have been shown even to the hotspurs by Greenberg's letter, borne by a fine calm and a distinguished objectivity — as indeed, in general, clarified minds are able to unite harmoniously within themselves many antagonisms which immature men of the stencil have stamped as irreconcilable. I go further still. The Territorialists, too, to whom, by the way, I stand unconditionally opposed, I should not like to see delivered over to the intolerance of the party popes; although they undoubtedly hold views contrary to the programme, they may yet be tolerated in the organisation so long as they show the honest will to submit to the majority and to continue active in the spirit of the programme of work laid down by it. Only no heresy-hunting in our ranks! If, however, there are Zionists who — contradictio in adjecto — disown or even combat Palestine, then it would in my opinion indeed be hopeless, if not dangerous, to wish to work together with them in one organisation.

But Ugandism and Territorialism in and of themselves have only slight practical interest any longer, inasmuch as, as matters now stand, they are hardly likely to possess the strength to set their stamp upon the movement as a whole. Far greater is their symptomatic significance. The discussion of the East Africa plan has brought to light the recognition that the old Jewish-State idea (kat' exochen), not bound to Zion, had only been latent, not vanished, and, awakened again at a suitable moment, might yet one day become a factor of power. As a reaction to this phenomenon the fact came to light that Chowewe-Zionism, too — the longing for the colonisation of Palestine at any price — had only been lulled to sleep, not driven out of men's minds, and needed only a far-reaching mistrust to set itself up as pretender to the throne against political-diplomatic Zionism. Herzl, in the purity and fidelity of his heart, could not foresee how terribly he would be misunderstood on this side and on that when he brought the Danaan gift of the British offer; he played — one must unfortunately concede York-Steiner the point here — having arrived at the height of his successes, the best trumps into the hands of his opponents. Thus it came about that, starting from the Uganda question, the most various problems, in particular the old differences over the principles of colonisation, were unrolled, and soon it was no longer organisation and Uganda but above all the Palestine question that stood at the centre of the discussion.

And that is well. These matters must at last be fought out, so that uniform points of view may be gained for further policy and the movement as a whole may be given back the quiet development and firmness of which it stands in such urgent need. For this above all the open and precise statement of the various views is required. The Palestinists have done their part in this respect. Ussischkin opened the round with his pamphlet; then came the Vilna Conference, the manifesto of a Berlin group, the literary arsenal in "Stimmen der Wahrheit". The Territorialists, too, have not been idle, and are doing their utmost in propaganda by word and pen to make themselves felt. Only the tendency that stands between the two, that of Herzlian Zionism, of Charter-Zionism, is strikingly sparing of words, so that it might gain the appearance of having capitulated without a fight. Only thus does it become intelligible that Elias Auerbach could venture, in the official organ of the German Landsmannschaft, to set up the fiction that there was no longer any difference in these matters. This must be contradicted in the sharpest manner, if only so that discouragement may not take hold in the ranks of the political Zionists of the Herzlian observance, and the opinion gain ground that their view no longer found defenders and champions and was hopelessly abandoned to the onslaught of the two extremes.

What, then, are the grounds on which the view of the Palestinists is built? In almost all their literary manifestations there recurs, as the chief argument for a change in our method, the "fiasco of diplomatism". I do not know: should one wonder more at the folly or at the disloyalty of such assertions? In the short span of seven years Herzl's genius of a diplomacy has brought us so far