Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 17 · 28 April 1905
8printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 17

(continued from page 7)

...as even his blindest adherents would not have dared to foresee: that all governments and peoples became aware of the importance of the Jewish problem and of the significance of our movement, that the Great Powers of the earth began to negotiate with us, after we had for 2500 years been accustomed only to seeing negotiations about us. In these seven years the diplomatic method, despite the open and covert hostility in our own ranks, has risen to ever higher successes, to ever more brilliant results — and then one has the effrontery to speak of a fiasco?! That must truly be branded, with Zlocisti, as a "blasphemous misleading of our adherents". Yet there are Palestinists who would still in future "grant political-diplomatic work one of the chief places in our programme" (Ussischkin); only the method is to be changed. "Thanks (sic!) to the circumstance" that the one great statesman we possessed is dead — one can fairly see how the many little statesmanikins breathe a sigh of relief that the pressure of this towering personality has been lifted from them and the path cleared for the exercise of their little epigone talents — "thanks" to this circumstance (Ussischkin, p. 9), diplomatic work is now to be shaped on more democratic principles: a whole college of diplomats is to share the work, and the negotiations are to be conducted more with the peoples and parliaments than with the ministers!! It is a blessing that, amid the earnestness of our discussion, we are now and again given occasion for liberating laughter. Nowhere, after all, can less be done with democratic hobby-riding of principles than in diplomacy; nowhere does the strong personality come into its own more indisputably — so decidedly, that one must put up not only with its great virtues but also with the faults of those virtues, and indeed gladly puts up with them. That diplomatic work after the Ussischkin recipe "will not be brilliant" he need not first assure us; that its success "is, however, a sure one in return" — that belongs to the category of optimisms for which our departed master would surely have been very gravely taken to task.

In the same pamphlet in which Ussischkin demands that "political-diplomatic work must be carried on much more intensively than before", one reads two pages earlier that for seven years "the exclusively diplomatic road" had been followed, and the Berlin wailing-women second him: "The diplomatic method, in the absolute dominion that was demanded for it, and in the exclusion of all positive work in its favour, has at the same time become harmful to the movement." Well, is that not once again a ridiculous misleading of our adherents? Are these gentlemen so blinded by their enmity towards the Herzlian policy that they no longer see things which lie plain before all the world? So, then, the creation of the Congresses, the mighty creation and steady extension of a world-embracing organisation, the founding of the Colonial Bank and of the National Fund, the whole "Jewish Renaissance", which owes to Zionism, if not its life, then at least its most active impulses and its sweep towards greatness — all this, then, would be a quantité négligeable?! Can one pass over this giant labour of a few years with a disdainful shrug of the shoulders without exposing oneself to the reproach of want of judgment or of dishonesty?

All this only becomes intelligible when one sees clearly what the Palestinists are aiming at. It is above all a matter of discrediting the whole Herzlian system in order to prepare the ground for the new Palestine policy; with the whole tradition hitherto, which the living Herzl represented with the weight of his personality and protected from attack, a tabula rasa is to be made, so as to gain room for the new Zionist Schulchan Aruch! And with that we come to the chief point of the Palestinist programme: practical work in Palestine. I leave aside here the question of rapid or, as the case may be, large-scale colonisation, and everything else that presupposes technical and scientific knowledge; of that I understand as little as most of those who write about it and pretend to hold opinions of their own, while at best they produce sentiments — "every settlement develops in such a way that ..." or "in the political rebirth of a people three elements play a part" — and launch unclear catchwords such as "culture-economic" or "national-political" into the world. Once the requisite guarantees have been obtained, the mode and tempo of colonisation will be determined not by writers of articles and phrase-makers but by informed experts. The difficult Charter question, too, I should like to leave aside here; what form is found for it is a secondary matter, provided only that security of title and self-government are attained. In any case these questions do not touch the heart of the movement. Quite otherwise, however, stands the question: When and under what conditions are we to buy land and settle it? The Palestinists answer: Buy at once and as much as possible, and thereupon begin without delay with the founding of new colonies! These demands lay hold of the programme of our policy at the root.

Let us for once examine the weighty reasons with which the Palestinist programme for the present is recommended.

I. We need living, practical work — this reason is no more valid in the mouths of the Palestinists than when it is advanced by the Territorialists in favour of their plans. As if the noblest field of activity we have, the work of national education, did not now and for a long time to come offer material in abundance to those who really wish to do work among the people. Even so eminent a "worker" as Ussischkin by no means closes his mind to this; but then he nevertheless asserts once more that "official Zionism cannot possibly occupy itself with the radical transformation of the whole Jewish national life in the countries of present residence". Of course Zionism can do that, and it would have to, even if we could begin with large-scale colonisation to-day, and all the more so if, according to Ussischkin's plan, the procedure were by infiltration, and thus the mass of Jewry would certainly remain in the Golus for many generations yet. Unceasing effort towards the thorough transformation of the whole life of the Golus remains in every case one of our noblest tasks, and it alone could give all of us rich practical work.

II. Land prices in Palestine are rising alarmingly, and if we wait longer with the purchase of land, the beati possidentes will later set us prices beyond our reach. Therefore, say the Palestinists, the word is: "buy wherever and whatever we can possibly get". The representatives of the National Fund, of the "Ica", of the "Geula" and of the other colonisation societies form a land committee in Palestine, which alone directs the purchase and will thus be in a position to dictate its terms to the sellers. Indeed, Mr. Ussischkin already holds the other societies so securely in hand that he is already setting about dividing the skin of the bear, with somewhat the same assurance with which Moscheh rabbenu, while still beyond the Jordan, fixed the exact plan of settlement. And the great politician of reality does not think for a single moment of unscrupulous