No. 21 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13
(continued from page 12)
…equality of all mankind, to which the Prophets and the Psalmist gave such exalted and heartfelt expression, had led him to the idea of folk-psychology, and the more he became a psychologist, the more he became a Jew. From the fact that his faith was no mere reflection of love for his parents, but was deeply grounded in his inner life, it follows of itself that Lazarus pleads for a strengthening, a completion and an interpenetration of the inherited religion by the modern world of ideas and culture, and pays homage to a Judaism that carries within itself the capacity for development, and the possibility and necessity of progress through continued labour. He champions the view that only an outlook unfettered by tradition, only feeling that flows from its own wellspring, only one's own intellectual labour in honest examination and free, creative shaping of ideas, can bring forth dignified morality and true religion. Tradition without examination is blind and dull. New creation without piety is cold and barren. The old must be born anew again and again, created afresh, as it were, in the soul; the new must grow up out of the roots of the old. Into the old one must delve deeply; to the new one must rise. Precisely because religion formed an essential, a supreme part of his existence, the heart in the organism of his mind, because he had spoken the words that ring like the harmony of the spheres: "Unless religion be sought for its own sake, it will not be found," he rose up against rigid, outward conservatism clinging to the letter, and threw himself wholly and fully, in word and writing and deed, into the endeavours, guided by the ideas of prophetic Judaism, to bring about a freer religious development within Judaism. The two Israelite Synods which met in Leipzig in 1869 and in Augsburg in 1871 gave expression to their gratitude for this by electing him their first president. Later he took a lively and active part in the founding of the Hochschule für die Wissenschaft des Judentums in Berlin. Thus he was one of the first who, by his example, gave proof to the educated Jews of Germany occupying respected social positions that one could be a warm-hearted Jew and at the same time a sterling Jew, and that steadfastness under the old banner must remain a duty of honour for the educated above all. "Treu und frei" ("Faithful and Free") is the title of the collection of brilliant and devout speeches and lectures, sent out into the world in 1887, in which he took his stand on the so-called Jewish Question. "Faithful and free" was indeed the motto of his life. Yes, he showed himself ever faithful and free towards those who, in religious and political life, carried faithfulness to the point of unfreedom and freedom to the point of unfaithfulness. Glowing with pious enthusiasm for the ideal teaching of Israel, breathed through by the breath of infinity, and for its world-historical mission, he bade his German co-religionists consider that, in order to be complete Germans, capable of the highest achievement, they must be and remain Jews, and must hold fast to and hand on what they possess as a stock in intellectual individuality and as a religion in inherited virtue or inherited wisdom.
An unwavering champion of Judaism was also Lazarus' collaborator and brother-in-law Steinthal, who held the chair of ethics at the Berlin Hochschule für die Wissenschaft des Judentums. A pride of Judaism, too, is the celebrated Neo-Kantian Hermann Cohen, who has recently published the second volume of his system, the "Ethik des reinen Willens" ("Ethics of the Pure Will"). He, too, is bound up and grown together with Judaism in every fibre of his being; in him there beats a rock-firm faith in the ideas of Judaism, in their inexhaustible significance and never-failing fruitfulness. Only the literal, outward view of the source of great, divine ideas, a view at odds with the spirit of history, is repugnant to his inmost soul; he marks out the direction for Judaism: "The words shall not be engraved ( חרות ) upon the tablets, but freedom ( חֵרוּת ) shall be in them."
Yet Ruppin is right in this, that by far the greater part of modern educated Jews are wholly estranged from their ancestral faith, and that the Jewish religion in Western Europe is an almost meaningless phantom. In view of this indifference, which could scarcely be surpassed, it is really a wonder that the Jews do not throng in crowds to the baptismal font. There must, then, be something after all that is common to all Jews and so comprehensive that, despite the most diverse views and degrees of education, it unites them all into a firm whole. This something consists in the community of the historical destinies of all the separated parts of the Jewish nation. We are intimately bound together by our glorious past, enclosed by a mighty chain of historical impressions received from our forefathers, which in the course of the centuries stormed upon the Jewish national soul and left in it a firm deposit. In short, the all-Jewish idea is rooted chiefly in historical consciousness. This, in my opinion, is the last and deepest reason that hinders the spread of baptism, and not, as Ruppin thinks, the consideration that it would be cowardice and treachery to forsake an imperilled minority assailed on every side, that the profession of the Christian creed would involve an untruthfulness, and that the baptised Jew does not at once attain full equality with the autochthonous Christian. How else, indeed, should one explain the phenomenon that it is usually precisely the liberal-minded Jews, the "libres penseurs" and those indifferent in matters of religion, who stand in the forefront of all our national movements?
However that may be, we rejoice heartily at the steadfastness of the Jews, and, on the grounds developed by Fritz Wittels in his pamphlet on baptism, we are not sentimental enough to say with Ruppin: "Baptism will not always be to be regretted or condemned. Estimable as is the motive of the individual Jew who will hold out at the post on which his birth once placed him, the position of the Western Jews as a whole, who in their overwhelming majority are neither believing Jews by religion nor acquainted with a Jewish nationhood and a Jewish culture, is an unhappy and untruthful hybrid position, at best a poor compromise. Who is not saddened to see that so many — not for love of a positive ideal, but merely out of piety — are condemned to fritter away their powers in petty strife instead of employing them on great tasks? That many of the best Jews are forced into inactivity, because full attachment to a nation and work on its behalf is for them the condition of creative effort, and yet they may not be fully enfranchised Germans, Frenchmen, etc., and cannot, or cannot yet, work for a Jewish people? Baptism . . . is at times, after all, the best way out of this dilemma." We condemn this sentimentality, all else apart, if only because we, like Ruppin, beyond the present out-