Page 14 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 21
(continued from page 13)
…looking, expect from the future that it will yet once more awaken in the Jewish people a valuable culture of its own, in which Jewish intellectual life will be wedded to the cultural achievements of the European nations. What he admits only hypothetically, we accept as certain, for the summer lightning already flickers, visible far and wide, as Ruppin himself, moreover, is obliged to admit. Does he not break out into the exultant cry: "Already to-day modern culture, like the spring sun out of the cold winter soil, is kissing quite unexpected blossoms out of orthodox Judaism, so long frozen in artistic barrenness. A great impulse runs through these poets and plastic artists among the Jews of the East. They have a favourable elasticity and an urge to activity such as was not attained even by the German Jews when they entered German culture. And withal there is stamped upon them all, in keeping with the stronger development of Jewish nationality in the East, a far stronger Jewish strain than in any Jewish artists hitherto. Not only do they not give up the Jargon in favour of the language of the country, as the Jews in the Western European lands did, but they consciously hold fast to it, and even seek to revive the old national language, Hebrew, for their purposes. Though the influence of European, and especially German, poetry may not be mistaken in their writings to-day, it is nevertheless their Jewish nationhood that gives them their strongest note. Here, beyond doubt, united forces are struggling to unfold, and if ever and anywhere, it is here in the East, under the influence of modern culture, which is breaking down Orthodoxism, that Judaism will once more put forth a lofty and distinctive bloom in artistic and scientific activity." The young political, scientific and artistic life that is everywhere stirring and rising and stretching among the Jews of Eastern Europe, and the translations of the most important works of world literature into Hebrew, signify the dawn of this new Jewish culture, which in the West is by no means "scarcely perceptible," but by virtue of the driving force inherent in it already gathers a goodly congregation about itself and in a certain sense is forming a school, as the literary activity of York-Steiner, for instance, shows. It is certainly not to be lightly esteemed, and is a sign of the times, that in the metropolis of the nation of poets and thinkers, in Berlin, a publishing house has arisen that knows how to value the renaissance of the Jewish spirit as it deserves, and has the right instinct for the Sturm und Drang of Young Judah.
And now we pass to the chapter on Zionism. Ruppin, who confuses the Jewish religion with orthodoxy or ceremonial religion, already hears the passing-bell that tolls the decease of the Jewish religion. But the fate of the Jewish nationhood is by no means sealed with the fate of the Jewish religion, since a people's right to exist as a separate people is demonstrated when, as an active member of progressing humanity, it enriches the common culture by virtue of its particular natural endowments, strikes a distinctive note within it, and creates high cultural values of its own out of itself. The Jews, after all that has come to light in recent years, and in view of the fact that in intellectual endowment they are one of the most highly bred of peoples, are called and chosen for this. Ruppin, however, would have a clean break made between Jewish nationhood and Zionism. In the first place he sees things too rosily when he finds that the Jew of the West really has no occasion to grow enthusiastic for Zionism, since here he lives not only in satisfactory material circumstances, often in prosperity and wealth, under the protection of an ordered commonwealth. With us in Austria at least, care is taken, better and more effectively from day to day, that the Jews' trees shall not grow into the sky, especially as the Antisemitizing of the schools, which will shortly be a fait accompli, is screwing us back to the days of the denominational school. Ruppin says on this point that the Western Jews, "in consequence of modern education, have a feeling of superiority towards the Jews of the East, and that for them the thought of living together with these in the same commonwealth has something repellent rather than attractive about it." That may be! But the wings of this conceit can easily be clipped. Quite apart from the fact that, as Ruppin himself has acknowledged, the ice has been broken in the East, and the wing-beat of a new era reaches us from there quite audibly, it is beyond all doubt that our Eastern brethren are to be preferred to the herds that let themselves be directed by such enlightened egoists as Bielohlawek, Schneider e tutti quanti are. No man in his right senses will venture to contradict us when I assert that the Jewish Congresses held hitherto tower high above the Lower Austrian Diet and the Austrian, as also the Hungarian and French, Parliaments in dignity and moral earnestness.
The Zionists, according to Ruppin, are so carried away by their goal that they lose all sense of reality. He bases this reproach on the ground that Palestine offers no room for a large Jewish population. It has to-day, he says, no large-scale industry at all and a very slight foreign trade. In the technique and extent of its agriculture, in communications and trades, it stands at a very low level, and, if the several countries are grouped according to the degree of their participation in world commerce, it takes no higher rank than, say, Persia, Afghanistan or Morocco. It would need the labour of several decades, a great capital and the most expert administration to raise Palestine to the level on which the Christian Balkan States stand to-day. If we further assume that Palestine, which is about 28,000 square kilometres in area, could within a measurable time support the same number of inhabitants as the Christian Balkan States, it would afford room for about 1,100,000 persons, that is, since the 500,000 Christians and Mohammedans now living in Palestine cannot after all be thrown out of the country, about 600,000 Jews could find room in it.
To these chief objections I oppose the arguments of Professor O. Warburg in the first number of the monthly "Altneuland," edited by him jointly with F. Oppenheimer and S. Soskin. He there sets forth that Palestine could hold a million and a half more people to attain the relative population of the Province of Posen, which equals it in size, and $2\frac{1}{2}$ millions more to equal the average of Germany, which now has over 105 inhabitants to the square kilometre. And in the neighbouring lands of Palestine, with a population such as Germany has, a hundred million more would find room besides the present inhabitants. Of course a figure of 105 inhabitants per square kilometre would presuppose either a fairly strong industry or a very intensive agriculture. But garden cultivation can feed far more than 105 souls per square kilometre, as Japan and China prove, where in fertile districts 200 souls to the square kilometre