Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 21 · 26 May 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 21 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…the individual Jews — into a Jewish people to make. One had confidence in the "Chovevei Zion" of Odessa, another believed in Herzl's journeys to Constantinople, a third devoted all his strength to founding a "model school" in some benighted little town and saw there the awakening of the Jewish nation, a fourth saw salvation in schools in Palestine, etc., etc. Often the one denied all significance to the activity of the other — but in no one did he see an opponent, an enemy, since the final goal of all was but one: The rebirth of the Jewish people in the Jewish land.

But now — since the Sixth Congress — there are among us in fact "opposing" currents, that is, such as do not flow in one direction, can never flow together, but rather, moving in opposite directions, draw ever farther apart. Our situation will become more intelligible to us if we picture to ourselves something like the following image: We stand upon a mountain whose interior is filled with masses of fire. Successive eruptions bury thousands of our own and work havoc among us. We have all now perceived that we may not remain standing upon this volcano if we are not to become a prey to its flames. We must go — on that we are all agreed. The only question is: whither? Up to the last Congress there was no question of "Whither?" We were all of one mind that the goal of our striving lay in Asia, in Palestine. We were divided only in our views as to the means we must employ to reach this goal. At that time we were in truth a party, and one, moreover, clearly conscious of what it wanted.

Not so now. We still find ourselves upon the same volcano, and while one points towards Palestine, another points towards — Uganda; a third even points with one hand towards Palestine and with the other towards Uganda; a fourth, however, has hidden his Palestine hand in his pocket — of Palestine, of the land of the Pashas, he is more afraid than of the fire threatening all about him — and with his other hand he points to every possible quarter of the compass, to Uganda, the Congo, Canada, Argentina or other black spots where he believes he can set up a State within twenty-four hours.

And this tragi-comic situation the Ugandists have created.

Mark well, however, Sir, that besides ourselves there exist upon this volcano various other groups which have likewise perceived that we may not remain standing. I mention only the one with which you would surely not wish to be regarded as one party — the purposeful group of assimilationists, which feels the distress of the "suffering brethren" no less than you, Mr. Greenberg. This group does not believe that we shall ever succeed in finding, in any place whatever, a home in which we may revive anew, and therefore they demand, in order to escape the danger of fire, that we mingle with our neighbours and so be rid of the danger. This group has a clear goal before it just as surely as we had up to the last Congress. This group was entitled to regard us as an enemy, and we on our side have fought it as bitter opponents. Were we, then, regarded as one party because we stood upon the same volcano, or because we agreed that we may not remain standing there? Why, then, do you think, Mr. Greenberg, that we form one party with you? The assimilationists do not believe in our rebirth; they seek means of bringing about our downfall swiftly. You with your group of Territorialists do not believe that we shall obtain our land, and you seek some land or other into which to lead our people. Will you find a land? And if you have found one, it is still questionable whether the people will follow you. What matters is that you seek other goals, other ways than we Zionists — and the question now is, how can you regard yourself as a member of the same party to which we belong? The assimilationist group is far more courageous than you, when it openly declares what it is and what it wants.

Should the Uganda project not be carried out, you think, the Jewish situation will not cease to be a sad one. You add, moreover, that many see in the Jewish people's situation growing sadder a salvation of Zionism.

Did the opponents of Uganda, then, ever found their Palestine Zionism on the evil plight of the Jews? Why, the very opposite is true: we Zionists never cease to emphasise that, precisely because Jewish sufferings are so numerous, because millions of Jews have to suffer under them — we are not in a position, by any rapid colonisation and any kind of autonomy whatever, to put an end to these sufferings at a day's notice. We often emphasise that our situation must be improved so that we may endure the sufferings — and gather fresh strength in order to come thither where we wish to build ourselves a permanent home.

You Territorialists, however, must (how sad!) rest your case upon the wretched plight of the people; for the more wretched our masses become, the greater your prospects of winning them. The hungry imagination of the wretched masses alone is capable of lending credence to your promises that help will soon come to them. The hungrier and more wretched the masses, the more they want to believe. It is precisely the hungry man who is not capable of reflecting and of giving himself an account of his feelings.

That we do not rest our Zionism upon the impoverishment of the people is best proved by our resolution at the Fourth (London) Congress, according to which we Zionists are bound to concern ourselves with the improvement of the situation of our people, that we must concern ourselves with all questions of "uplifting".

We must, you say, keep watch over our movement, that no philanthropists penetrate into it; our movement, you further think, must be "in the first place" a political one.

No, Mr. Greenberg, not a political, but a national-political movement our movement must be "in the first place".

The difference is obvious.

If our movement must be, as you would have it, "in the first place" a political one, then we should have to strain every effort to achieve political successes. Then to-day Uganda, as a "political success", would be — Zionism. To-morrow a concession in the Congo, as a "political success", would be — Zionism. We have dealings with great Powers, it would then be said; "they negotiate with us as with a government", and other phrases of like sound.

I believe, however, that our task does not consist in negotiating with "great Powers". Such a feat the Jewish philanthropist Montefiore was also able to accomplish. Baron Hirsch found a willing ear even in "great Russia"; princes dance at a Rothschild wedding, and the "Alliance", once national but now philanthropic, likewise has dealings with "great Powers".

All these "political successes" of individual Jews or societies are of no value from the Zionist standpoint. To-day any commercial group, as a syndicate, is in a position to have dealings with "great Powers", to obtain concessions from them and the like, without causing any great stir.

Your friend Israel Zangwill has often rightly pointed out that the "Ica" squanders millions fruitlessly if it believes that in the lands of the Diaspora the Jews could be educated and prepared in such a way that they, into the colonies founded for them, as finished craftsmen and farm-