No. 29 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
II.
The Idea of the Palestine Commission.
Under various titles the thought of creating a Palestine Commission made its way, in uncertain, nebulous forms, at all the Congresses. It was called into being now as a Colonisation Commission, now as a Committee for the Promotion and Supervision of Colonisation in the Zionist sense, but, given that the substratum for a Zionist settlement, namely the legal basis, was lacking, and given that the individual members of these committees were elected in different places, which at the least hindered, if they did not wholly prevent, communication among them, it had to be regarded as something unserviceable from its very birth. They were, indeed, premature births incapable of life. It could therefore at most be regarded as a creation for the satisfaction of a certain ideal instinct and, if one wished to take it quite practically, as a cautious preparation, corresponding somewhat to buying an umbrella in fine weather in order to have it already when the rain sets in. For it was thought good that such a thing should exist, and if the case, surely to be expected, should arise that it was needed, it would already be at hand. Little by little one was finally bound to come to the point of stepping out of this caution of the prudent householder and assigning to it a sphere of competence truly corresponding to Zionist needs, but also of organising it so that the possibility of performing and fulfilling its task should not be taken from it and made impossible a priori. In this the original designations of "Colonisation Commission", "Commission for the Supervision and Direction of Colonisation Affairs" and all subdivisions were abandoned, and it was rightly confined to what could, should and must be, and what in the preceding Congresses had been mixed up with other wishes and tasks, namely to the purely scientific side. One might well dispute whether, of the five points which are specified out of the scientific and practical investigation of Palestine and the countries coming into consideration, as they appear set out in the motion of the German Landsmannschaft²), points 3 and 4, strictly speaking, belong to it. But that these should be endowed by the Congress with means of their own and by no means brought into connection with the National Fund, there can surely be no doubt. Already from the principles of the organisation³), as well as from the declaration made ex praesidio by Dr. Herzl upon the motion of Dr. Löwe that the debate on the National Fund be combined with the motion of the German Landsmannschaft on the Palestine Commission,⁴) that these matters are entirely different, that it was quite out of the question to take moneys from the National Fund for this purpose, it clearly follows that the means of the National Fund were by no means to be made, nor meant to be made, serviceable to the purposes of the Palestine Commission.
But it turned out otherwise. The rejection of the Commission's motions and the adoption of Doctor Tschlenow's motion that the purchase of land for the account of the National Fund be begun at once brought it about that the Palestine Commission was placed in such a connection with the institution of the National Fund, to the injury of both bodies, that each was bound to work at the ruin of the other; this, however, must also necessarily lead to a misconception and displacement of the competence of the Palestine Commission, inasmuch as the administrative right of the A.C. in respect of the National Fund would be gradually undermined and finally subordinated entirely to the dictate of the Palestine Commission, which would soon have squandered it. Indeed, a member of the said Commission remarked smilingly to Herr Wolffsohn that the National Fund was entirely spent. Naturally he was then reckoning with items of expenditure which fortunately, and not least owing to my energetically urged objections, thank God were not paid out.
III.
The Acquisitions of the Jewish National Fund in the Light of Turkish Law.
The National Fund is conceived as a juristic person whose acquisitions of land should be the property of the whole people and be leased to Jews in correspondingly smaller parcels, possibly on hereditary lease. Rights of possession and usufruct in these individual parcels of the land are to be transferred to private persons, but the right of ownership never alienated. There would thereby arise a legal form recalling the old German and Italian institution of the fief in its original form. But what we are planning already exists in the Turkish state itself. Almost all land, with extremely few exceptions⁵), is crown land or Wakuf property⁶). The superior ownership, Rakkaba, belongs to the Beït-ul-mal⁷) or to the purpose of the Wakuf, while to private persons only rights of possession and usufruct are granted, though to so extensive a degree that they can encumber and alienate these rights. They are also transmissible by way of legal inheritance, but not by testamentary disposition, that is to say by will.
Turkish law likewise does not know the institution of the moral person, and if certain associations, such as the Tobacco Régie and the railway companies, nevertheless administer their movable property as such and are also able to acquire indispensable immovables, these are without exception exceptions called into being by special laws, or rather Iradés of the Sultan. On the other hand, they may well serve as proof that the possibility does exist of creating, by way of exception, juristic persons with the capacity to acquire land. The aforementioned difficulty, too, in so far as it concerns crown land, Miri land, can be removed by means of the process of Temlik-i-sahih, which consists in concluding a kind of contract of sale with the Sultan as representative of the Beït-ul-mal, whereby Miri land is converted into Mülk land, that is to say, made over in full ownership to a private person or a company with the delivery of a documentary title, called Temliknamé. One sees, therefore, that the two above
²) Prot. VI. p. 272. ³) Prot. VI. page 273. ⁴) Ibid. VI. page 274.
⁵) In towns and villages and a small radius around them. ⁶) Endowments for pious or charitable purposes. ⁷) Treasury of the State.
