No. 36 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
In one case the plans of our enemies will come to nothing.
Since the terms of the peace are not yet precisely known, the reactionary papers spin fables about "losses that Russia has won at the diplomats' table." The war, according to the version of the "Nowoje Wremja," was glorious — but the peace is a defeat, a sign of weakness, indeed almost a betrayal of the fatherland. And who was to blame that this peace had to be concluded? The Revolution. The very Revolution that until now was treated en canaille has suddenly acquired an importance in world politics. Namely: out of fear of the disturbances at home Witte is supposed to have been compelled to conclude an unfavourable peace. The Revolution — who is that? Why, that is in good part the Jews... and so: through the Jews Witte was compelled... Anyone can with ease spin out the "Nowoje Wremja's" train of thought further. The pattern is, after all, fairly old. The Jewish men of money, the Jewish workers, the Jewish intelligentsia — they will all be assigned their parts if further building is done upon this foundation. And this ground will then have to serve when it is desired to deny the Jews the alleviations that the new constitution is to bring them. Rights of residence? Civil rights? Rights of education?... why, these people stabbed Witte in the back when he... Through these people we lost Saghalien!
In one case their plans will come to nothing: if Witte now really steps to the head of a responsible government and has to tell it at the first council of ministers that the Jews fought bravely and that they bravely helped to further the peace. —tsch.
A Danger.
Among the reports that reach us concerning the Imperial Duma and its probable repercussions upon the Russian Jews there was lately a small, inconspicuous one that gives much food for thought and concern. In a reply to an antisemitic article which held out the prospect of a Judaising of the Duma, this impudent assertion was refuted. Without difficulty it was possible to point to the high electoral property qualification and the effective electoral geometry, and to prove that only in a few towns — fewer than there are fingers on one hand — would Jews have even a remote prospect of being elected. That, as has been said, was an easy task, but it was nonetheless necessary. Not necessary, however, was an addition in which it was said that even in these cases the Jews would consider themselves represented just as well by liberal Poles or Russians as by Jews.
Certainly a Jew who stands abreast of the times must welcome a Pole or Russian who is, notabene, really liberal-minded; certainly he must strive to enter into purely human relations with them and to work together with them at the great work of European development. But this duty is in a twinkling turned, in a shallow-headed and scarcely conscientious fashion, into an outrage when it is understood as self-surrender. And the outrage is all the worse in that what truly lies behind it is not misunderstood liberalism at all, but a very unwise wish to be wise.
Elsewhere, indeed, there has already been ample opportunity to admire the effect of this policy: how — quite apart from every ethical demand for self-respect and the defiant spirit of independence — in the course of time a grave mistrust arose against the Jews who were so polite and so considerate! How the indirect influence that the Jews exercised upon the community and the commonwealth was borne a thousandfold more grudgingly than a direct influence, lawfully their due, would ever have been borne! How, on the other hand, the peoples were not taught by the self-effacement of the Jews to esteem them more highly and perhaps magnanimously to bring them forward, but quite involuntarily to think less of them and in the end to resent their every independent step!
Are all these lessons really to have availed nothing at all? And are the Jews of the East really to go the same ways as those of the West in their day, and then, no doubt, to arrive at the same "achievements" as they? Are they really to fall under the same fate, although, endowed with other powers, they seem to deserve another? Is the weight of numbers, which was not at the disposal of the others, to be of no use to them? Is it to make no difference that the others' own national soul had already all but fled when they entered European civilisation, whereas they, the Eastern Jews, make their entry in full national vigour, in possession of a young and promising culture? Are the resurrection of the Hebrew literary language and the wonderful birth of the Jewish vernacular and literary idiom to be only passing whims of development, over which it would stride as pitilessly as over the Jewish-cultural tabula rasa in the West?
No, we need not fear that; for the present at least we have as yet no cause to. There are still hundreds of thousands of conscious nationalists. Millions of the people are still so little infected with assimilationist ideas that — save for a tiny fraction — all of them gave the Jewish language as their mother tongue in the last census. The organised working proletariat still stands — and perhaps this very attitude of the section of the people that is socially pressed furthest towards the future means the most — loyal and firm by its nationality!
And yet the article in question must not pass unheeded. Certainly a newspaper essay does not yet hold within it the destiny of a people. But it can be symptomatic, and in our case — in connection with other events and conditions — it is. The strange complaisance towards the Russians and Poles that is there recommended is surely not urged upon us out of assimilationist moods and sentiments. But the counsel grows out of feelings that furnish an excellent breeding-ground for the demagogy of assimilation. The so-called assimilation movement — so called because never and nowhere has it brought forth a real assimilation, but always and everywhere merely a dismal product of disintegration — lives, indeed, positively upon this inherited fear of the Jews of ever claiming their rights openly and resolutely. And the demagogues need not first be born; they are there, they go about in the midst of the Eastern Jewish people, from whom they are worlds apart, pondering how they might win it over. And not all of them merely ponder; some have already begun the campaign.
They are people who represent a particular type of so-called assimilation, a type that we in Austria know from Galicia: the Jewish Pole. Is it because, in the face of Polish Jewry with its pronounced individuality, the contrast has an all the more painful effect? Or is it because the share that fashion, sport, spleen and outward show of every kind have in this "assimilation" is greater than any
