No. 39. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…openers presented, a problem that was further sharpened by a pogrom which raged in Ekaterinoslaw while the Congress was sitting, and by the horrors of Bialystok, Kertsch, etc., which followed. But what answer did the Congress give to it? None at all! This great task for Zionism was ignored. With the exception of Dr. Nordau, the Congress did not even feel a deep pain and shame at its impotence. Zionism voluntarily renounced being the guardian and representative of the Jewish people. But truly, someone had to take up this work, and if Zionism would not concern itself with it, then a new organisation must needs be called into being for the purpose.
With great hesitation was this conclusion forced upon me — with hesitation, because my dearest dream was the union of all Jewish works and parties under the banner of Zionism. And the original programme of our movement, as it is set forth in the statutes of our Colonial Bank, was broad enough to take in every kind of activity in every country. Under our central administration all movements for the betterment of the conditions of life of our people as a whole could have united. Dr. Nordau's opening speech spoke clearly and plainly of such a broad conception of Zionism. Zionism might have created a moral centre for the whole Jewish people even before it came into possession of a land. But the little Zionists willed it otherwise. In truth the majority are not Zionists at all; they are merely Friends of Zion. Zionism means the political redemption of the Jewish people; one can live in Palestine even now. My conscience is clear. I fought for unity, and even when I was beaten I did not join the Territorialist group until the Bank meeting had voted for the alteration of the statutes and had thereby frustrated the last opportunity of being able to work in a broad way for and through Zionism. The Jewish Territorial Organisation, or the J.-T. O., as we shall call it henceforth for brevity's sake, would have been glad to work as a branch of Zionism, but it was compelled to become independent. It will find its reward for this in the circumstance that many who had neither hopes nor sympathies for Palestine will join a movement whose chief aim is to find for our wandering masses a home secured by public law, in whatever part of the world it may be. Mr. Greenberg regretted the founding of a separate organisation on the ground that, had the Territorialists remained in Zionism as a party, they would then have come into their rights at a following Congress. But what by that time would have become of England's offer? By the immediate formation of our organisation we had at least a hope of striking the iron while it was still hot, and of continuing the negotiations with the English Government. Moreover, the Seventh Congress has found very good means of cutting us off for ever from every possibility of coming into our rights. It is even questionable whether shekolim will be accepted from us, and even had we the prospect of a victory, we should still have the greatest trouble, attended with much expense, in altering the Bank statutes back again. Nor am I a friend of these constant alterations and everlasting civil wars.
We rendered Zionism the best service in our power by leaving it in peace. It is quite possible that we might be victorious at a future Congress, but it is bad tactics to be forever damaging the plan of campaign. A certain continuity of method is necessary. Ussishkin must be given an opportunity, provided only that it is not made impossible for him on the part of the Sultan. At the worst he will improve the condition of the Jews already settled in Palestine. All these Congress battles, in which now one party and later the other is victorious, would be very interesting and amusing if we already had a land; but since the object of our existence is to obtain a land, and we are less a parliament than an army, these constant changes of plan are harmful to the movement. Better a bad plan than perpetual wavering. I do not know whether there are still Zionists who have not yet joined the new organisation, but if there are such, they probably hope to be able to realise their ideals through the Zionist organisation itself. Insofar as Palestine and its neighbouring countries are territories, that is a perfectly reasonable standpoint. And the reason why I personally remain in the Zionist organisation, and have advised my friends to do the same, is that Zionism is itself a Jewish territorial organisation, even though it restricts its territorial aims to Palestine and its neighbouring countries alone. And the good that we Territorialists can still do Zionism is this: to keep it strictly territorial, and not to let it be watered down either into a Cultural Zionism or into philanthropic societies and debating clubs; to remind it always that by its programme it is bound to mother earth and strives for the attainment of a home in Palestine secured by public law, and must not evaporate into every manner of rosy vapour. Not once since Herzl, by his new trumpet-call, awakened the Jewish people and set it marching upon a territory, have there been soldiers who fell out of the ranks and went back to sleep. They had not yet gone a mile when they began to yawn and grumble: "Yes, but we need culture, we must have religion, we want to speak Hebrew! But before ever Herzl awakened the Jews, they already had an abundance of culture and religion; they spoke Hebrew enough in their sleep. But that was not what Herzl had come for. We had teachers and rabbis enough — and they could look on calmly while our people was reviled, plundered and murdered. Herzl appeared in order to give us what we did not yet have — a home secured by public law.
This reminds me of Israel, the little wonder-rabbi, who at seven years of age could already deliver a learned Talmudic discourse. Unfortunately, however, his health did not stand in the same proportion to his learning. He grew ever thinner and paler and was near to death. Then a doctor was called to him. The doctor said the rabbi-child must give up his learned folios and the pilpul and do gymnastic exercises. The child went to a gymnasium and began to practise on the bars. At first he went at it quite zealously and his muscles began to swell, but later his old habit came over him: when he was swinging he looked into a book, when he stood on his head he thought of a difficult passage of the Talmud, and when he sat on the parallel bars he had a Mishnayoth before him. There you have the history of Zionism. No one maintained that the little wonder-rabbi do without study of every kind
