Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 39 · 29 September 1905
6printed page
scan 6 of 20
Facsimile · scan 6 of 20
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 39.

(continued from page 5)

…culture and industry, to send out a Morocco commission, and to arrange cheap excursion tours to Morocco — by how much, do you think, would you thereby have been brought nearer to your goal, the conquest of a country two thirds of which is inhabited by Moors, and on which several of the Great Powers have already cast an eye? The only reason why such petty work in Palestine would not be altogether useless is the hope that exists that our historic right to that country might appeal to the sympathies or the mutual jealousies of Christendom, and that in a possible crisis a European congress might establish us there. I cannot go so far as some Territorialists and political Zionists, and maintain that, on account of this hope, petty colonisation in Palestine is entirely worthless. It has indeed a purpose, but only as a possibility of outside help, and not as a means in and of itself of obtaining Palestine, as Mr. Ussishkin thinks. In the event of such a crisis our chances are the better, the more Jewish elements we have there and the stronger those elements are. I emphasise: stronger, because, though I agree with Mr. Ussishkin that the 80,000 Jews already living in Palestine must be organised and united, these elements, which are greatly pauperised and downcast, must receive fresh reinforcement from without, and that not from equally pauperised and degenerate elements, but from people of education and position, capable of exerting political influence from within. It is the duty of every influential adherent of the Ussishkin plan of campaign to embark for Palestine at once, and I was astonished to see so many of them still loitering about here; not a single one seems as yet to have proved his loyalty to the master. However that may be, Mr. Ussishkin is quite mistaken if he thinks that, if he had them there, he could, relying upon them, march unwaveringly upon the goal of the Basle Programme. It is true, petty colonisation is one of the means of conquering a country. — Has not Dr. Nossig already declared that it is England's favourite means, whereby she acquired new territories! First peaceful missionaries and commercial adventurers penetrate the new region, then come interests that require defending, and at last the British flag flies over the land.

But Dr. Nossig forgets a mighty factor in England's successes — behind the petty colonisation stood the heavy gun. To speak with Lord Salisbury's proposition, which has become proverbial: first the missionary, then the merchant, last the gunboat. Germany likewise has colonies in Palestine, but should anything befall them, the whole German army and navy would soon be behind those colonies. And the German colonies in Palestine do not assert that they aim at the entire possession of Palestine. Ussishkin's colonies do not conceal it. And on this point hangs the collapse of his system. There were two ways of working for Palestine: the one was secret, the other open. But it is surely impossible to yoke the two together. It is surely impossible to shout from all the housetops: "We mean to get Palestine secretly!" If you wish to work quietly, why organise congresses! Rather found a secret organisation, unite the Jews in Palestine secretly, and let Jews migrate into Palestine secretly. But to tell the Sultan from the tribune of a world-famous Congress that you mean to work untiringly at conquering one of his provinces is nothing but child's play. Either he consents to give you Palestine, in which case he would say so, or he does not. If in the latter case he permits you to carry on petty colonisation in Palestine, it is only because he is playing cat and mouse with you, as I said, and because he knows that he could strangle the mouse at any moment. Time will soon show what leaps the cat makes. In reality, I think, time has already shown it. An order has been issued in Palestine that those who are not registered with the consuls of their native countries must leave the country at once or become Turkish subjects, in which latter case they must not only pay heavy taxes but also pay various fines and arrears for themselves and their children. What else can that mean but the Sultan's answer to our secret smuggling of Jews into Palestine?

And if the Ussishkin tactics suffer shipwreck on the inflexible will of Turkey with her million soldiers, I am convinced that he will return to Herzl's method with the same frankness with which I should confess my error at the first signs of success of the Ussishkin method. But even now, as a simple soldier of the Zionist army, I am obliged to submit to the decision of the Congress and to adopt its method. I must shut my eyes and pay my shekel. My last act before I left Basle was to hand over to the National Fund of Zionism a sum I had collected during the Congress for autographs.

But that does not prevent me from taking up other work on my own account, a work which Zionism neglects although it properly complements it. While we march towards Palestine at a tortoise's pace, the tragic problem of our wandering masses has come on at a run.

In his statesmanlike opening speech Dr. Nordau said: "The Jewish migration is assuming from day to day a greater extent. It signifies a sum of privation and suffering, of anguish and despair, that can scarcely be put into words. In face of this mass phenomenon we must confess our impotence with deep pain and shame. We have neither a land to offer the wanderers, whither they might confidently direct their steps, nor can we, by assistance in money, ease for them the journey and the founding of a new economic existence in a strange land." It was hardly correct to assert that we possessed no land to offer the wanderers, or to confess our impotence, so long as we had not yet thoroughly examined the amiable offer of England. But let us pass the sponge over that. Immediately upon Dr. Nordau's speech followed the report of Oskar Marmorek, in which it says: "Jewish emigration from Russia has in the last year assumed alarming dimensions. But over against the increase of the factors driving to emigration stands an ever smaller and more restricted number of countries to which the emigrants can turn, and the question 'Whither?' grows ever more pressing and urgent. Of all the many needs, the emigration question is at the moment the one that most certainly deserves the greatest attention. Bare of all means, only to save their naked lives, the fugitives, mostly men but also many women and children, come across the frontier."

Thus was the problem to the Congress by its