Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 42 · 20 October 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 42. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…masses, to be able to compete with the Social Democratic agitation. And it turns out that all these parties are honest enough to confess openly their egoistic interest in the coming about of the suffrage reform, and that they leave the justification of the reform by idealistic reasons, the invoking of the rights of man and so forth, to those parties which in the depths of their hearts fear the reform and tremble for their national possessions.

But in order to win over the masses that have come to power, the parties must take the customary road: make promises. They must do so in this case all the more, since the masses expect wonders from the reign of universal, equal suffrage and have only ever been confirmed in their expectations by the parties. So much has been promised that a speedy fulfilment by honest means is scarcely possible. But if it will not go the honest way, then it goes another way: the antisemitic. This is in fact always and everywhere the convenient, base way out when a party wishes to divert the mass of its following from a direction in which it is loath to see it active and demanding. Can it be predicted with confidence of a single one of the parties mentioned that it will for all the future reject that expedient, that even when in a tight corner it will forgo it? Of the Social Democrats, perhaps, who even hitherto have now and then let themselves be caught in a little flirtation with the antisemitic instincts of the mass? Of the Young Czechs, who held antisemitism in reserve, quite semi-officially, as a scourge of punishment and revenge for undesired Jewish participation in elections? Of the Clericals, who indeed do not come out openly against the Jews, because they are sworn by their programme to Christian love, but who pay troops of mercenaries of their own for the unclean business? Of the Christian Socials, surely, we may in this connection keep silent...

So much for the parties. As regards the Jewish point, there are only differences of degree among them. And the explanation lies close at hand: they know the masses with which they have to deal, and they know the ineradicable instincts of the mass: intolerance, hatred of the stranger. But enlightenment! it will be objected to us; and the old proposition will be warmed up again, that political disfranchisement has a demoralising effect, and that the removal of political pressure brings moral liberation in its train. Certainly political freedom is the necessary precondition for an upswing of morality; certainly enlightened humanity does not thrive among those kept in tutelage, the disfranchised and the forcibly oppressed. The high level of general education in Germany surely stands in connection with universal suffrage. But it would be wrong to assume on that account that political liberation must every time have enlightenment and tolerance as its necessary consequence. The connection exists indeed, but it is not a direct one. Between cause and effect there still stands one thing: the leaders of the masses. Leaders of high morality educate the people by leading it to the ballot-boxes; leaders to whom politics is a mere business or a means of satisfying their hunger for power and their ambition corrupt the people on precisely this occasion. And I ask: where are the leaders, where the parties in Austria, who concern themselves with any other than a purely political education of the people? Who have the courage to tell the people now and then even what it does not like to hear, to set themselves against its instincts, to educate the honoured voter into an honest fellow-worker in the general civilisation?

It has become a political habit that many Jewish voters, without agreeing with the Social Democratic programme in its essential points, support the Social Democrats at elections. This habit will become still more general if in future, as is to be expected with certainty, the main political battle comes to be fought out between Clericals and Social Democrats. And in fact, what other choice is left even to the politically moderate Jew who does not simply wish to leave his ballot-paper lying in his desk drawer? But who also does not wish, by supporting a pseudo-Liberalism, a sham democracy, to become ridiculous in his own eyes? It is quite natural and readily understood that so many Jews turn, at least at elections, to the one powerful party, rich in future, by which they have not hitherto been actually betrayed and deceived, the only one which has not declared antisemitism outright as a point of its programme, but has merely admitted it as a — private matter.

Besides these two possibilities — to remain politically inactive or to vote Social Democratic — there would, to be sure, be a third: the organisation of the Jews. But it is precisely with this possibility that the Jews have hitherto concerned themselves least. And so long as they have not done so, no reproach can be made against them, even from the standpoint of a Jewish Realpolitik that everywhere asks after the Jewish advantage, for their Social Democratic polling-day convictions. But one can indeed reproach them for abandoning themselves to the hope that Social Democracy, the more power it gains through universal suffrage, will become the more liberal, the more hostile to prejudice, the more democratic. The very opposite seems to me more correct and more to be expected. And since there are still Jews who, ever since the collapse of the Liberals, have been on the look-out for a new force to protect the Jews, let them above all take it to heart: Social Democracy will never be this new protecting force of the Jews, never can be, for reasons of party tactics. If for no other reason, then because in Catholic Austria it has to deal with a mass far more inclined to Jew-hatred than in Germany, and because it can hope to hunt votes away from its chief enemies, the Clericals and the Christian Socials, only by a cautious — in plain words, cowardly — treatment of the Jewish point.

... All this is by no means meant as concealed reasons against universal suffrage. Universal suffrage will, after all, also confer the vote on so many thousand Jews. We do not grudge it them, we congratulate them on it: for with it a piece of right and a very small piece of power is laid in poor hands. We are only opposed to the Jews giving themselves up to a terrible self-deception about the effects of universal suffrage, to their lulling their vigilance to sleep with exaggerated hopes. We want the Jews to look clearly into the future, not to expect their salvation, say, from the "revolutionary" sense of justice of the strata of the population brought to power by universal suffrage, but to prepare themselves for universal suffrage, once carried through, to result rather in a swelling than in an ebbing of antisemitism.