Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 1 · 5 January 1906
4printed page
scan 2 of 22
Facsimile · scan 2 of 22
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

"Die Welt" — No. 1

THE BRUSSELS CONFERENCE.

It was at the time when the Russian catastrophe broke upon the Jews of every land, stunning them, bewildering them with its unheard-of force. Outbursts of pain, of grief, of indignation followed the first terror; but at once there followed, too, acts of brotherly readiness to help and of sympathy, which Jewish history will gratefully preserve for the remembrance of later generations as a consoling and honourable testimony from days that were full of horror and dread. Men acted, men helped, each after his own fashion, after his own strength. But just as the events broke in unexpectedly and tumbled headlong over one another, so too were the relief efforts hasty, calculated as far as possible for the moment, not concentrated. To the magnitude of the catastrophe, to the misfortune of a people, there should have answered the counsel of a people's representation, the deed of a people. United, systematic, organised action on the part of all Jews ready to help — that was what was needful. All felt it; many said it, too.

The Zionist Actions Committee has made itself the advocate in this matter: while the days were still at their darkest, it convened an all-Jewish conference at Brussels for the 29th of January, with the order of the day: "The Situation of the Jews in Russia."

Weeks have passed since then. The situation of the Russian Jews has perhaps shifted; it has not improved. As in the most terrible days of the massacre, the problem still stands before us to-day in all its magnitude: the distress of the Russian Jews — what can we do to meet it, to relieve it? We, that is to say, the united strength of all the great Jewish organisations, of all the Jewish parties. To this Brussels was to seek the answer, perhaps to give the answer.

The Actions Committee has received various replies to its invitation: assenting, waiting, declining.

The reasons for the refusals will be hard to understand. On principle there could be no difficulties here. It was — expressly so — not a question of a conference with Zionist aims, with a Zionist programme. For that the Zionists have their Congresses. It was a question of preparing the way to an agreement, if not for all aims, then at least for the one great purpose which the order of the day had fixed from the outset. Hitherto some have worked philanthropically, others for emigration, others again politically, some on this side, others on the far side of the ocean — but never yet have their efforts been united in one focus. Therefore much of the work was only work of the moment, decentralised, insufficient work, and every pogrom, every stream of emigration set the Jewish organisations anew before difficulties which they had believed they had just overcome.

Now there exists an enormous state of distress in permanence. It will not, cannot be remedied by isolated actions, by the distribution of moneys, by provision for the injured — however necessary that may be. "In these grave times we must all work together, and for the work of the moment there is absolutely nothing that divides us." That is the first pronouncement of Dr. Paul Nathan on the Brussels Conference — that is, of one who is no Zionist, but whom one can hardly reproach with ignorance of the present situation.

We can also subscribe to what the "Jewish Chronicle," to which likewise no one will impute Zionist tendencies, sets forth in a leading article in its last number:

"Unfortunately, as we have constantly insisted, and as the Zionists themselves, e. g. Mr. Greenberg, have maintained, the Russian distress will never be ended by emigration. . . . Even if the Russian Jews wished to leave their country en masse, they could not. A large community would always remain behind as hostages in the hands of the Russian rulers. For these reasons the thoughts of Jewry turn back unceasingly to the wish to procure for the Russian Jews security and freedom in Russia. . . .

Various proposals have been made to this end: public meetings, petitions, interviews, and even international action. And now we have a similar but wider proposal on the part of the A.-C. of the Zionist Organisation.

The principal Jewish organisations of the whole world are invited to send delegates to a conference at Brussels for the 29th of January.

We hope and believe that the Anglo-Jewish organisations will not be so petty as to reject this invitation because it is of Zionist origin, the more so as Zionism itself will not be on the order of the day of the conference. Nor would it be any reason to reject the invitation on the consideration that no good can come of a conference. No one knows what the conference may bring once it is held. Representatives of the Jewry of the whole world so seldom come together to deliberate on their common affairs that we are hardly in a position to pass judgment on the value of such gatherings. And finally, an assembly of Jewish leaders, speaking with caution and moderation in the name of their race, would be attentively heard by the Christian peoples and governments, whose honour and good name are dragged in the mire by the continuing disgrace of the Russo-Jewish oppression. The course of the Zionist movement has shown that there are many Christians who sympathise with it, and governments which wait only for a leader from among the Jews themselves. . . . We hope, therefore, that the conference suggested by the Zionist A.-C. will take place, and that it will consist of sensible men enjoying such standing in the world that there is assurance that the voice of the assembly will be heard by Russia and by the rest of the world."

The Zionists, let it be said once more, did not take the initiative out of party interest. They held themselves called to this initiative because from the outset they could count upon representatives from the lands beyond the seas, and above all upon the representatives of those chiefly concerned — upon the Russian delegates. They believed they had done their duty. It is for the others to decide upon theirs.