No. 3 — "Die Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…turned against that country, the spirit of revolution made itself felt, and where those who even in ordinary times are the most defenceless of the Czar's subjects fell easy prey to lawless ruffians. The horrible outrages of which our brothers and sisters in Russia became the victims last October and November roused the indignation of the civilised world, and moved even the leaders of the Anglo-Jewish community to hold a meeting last Monday in order to protest against them. With praiseworthy readiness they opened a fund, into which contributions flowed in abundance. We felt bound as Zionists likewise to open a fund, in order to give expression to our disapproval of two points which formed part of the appeal. To the first I have already referred: it is the assurance that the money should in no case be used to promote emigration from Russia to Great Britain. If such a condition had been possible, then under the circumstances then prevailing it would have stood in utter contradiction to the unselfish wish to help our brethren so sorely stricken by fate. At such a moment to make any reservation as to the ways and means of rescuing the unhappy victims ought to have been quite unthinkable. At all events, if those words of the appeal were to be taken seriously, they were an attempt — I will grant that it was no intentional attempt — to forge chains by Jews for Jews, and to give a handle to those who are so anxious to keep Jews from immigrating into our country, a handle which Sir William Evans-Gordon was only too quick to use. Moreover, we felt that the promise that the fund should be distributed through the British consuls in Russia was by no means the best guarantee that the moneys would be distributed in the most suitable manner. It now appears that the consuls were of the same opinion, for they did not undertake such a responsibility, although I have seen no public announcement of this fact to the contributors.
It will certainly interest you to learn that our colleagues in Russia, to whom the distribution of the fund of the Jewish Colonial Trust was entrusted, are endeavouring to find means of more lasting efficacy than that of almsgiving, by which at least a considerable part of the fund collected might be used for the benefit of our brothers and sisters who have suffered in Russia.
Ladies and Gentlemen, this was a task for the Red Cross, and in time of war this work of love and mercy takes no account of the quarrel between those who wage war. It sees only that men lie wounded and helpless in the blood they have shed, and does what it can to save their lives and restore their health. The task of the Red Cross is the healing, not the prevention, of wounds; it mitigates the horrors of war, but does not secure to us the blessing of peace. It is a work of prevention for our people to which we must now turn, now that their blood flows no longer, now that their dead are buried, now that their wounds, of body as well as of soul, are, as we hope, in the course of healing. We must certainly cast many a glance into the past, but only to gather experience, so that we may perceive our faults and errors. But to the future we must ever turn our eyes. How stands it with the future? "Watchman, what of the night?" We Jews have so many watchmen! But they are not agreed as to the direction in which we should look for the dawning of our day.
Is it not wonderful that the tragic events in Russia should have had to quicken our senses, which had been lulled to sleep by the impossibility of foreseeing any coming calamity? In the letter which Lord Rothschild and others sent to the press a few days ago, we must recognise this fact. The old idea that the Jewish problem of Russia, which by reason of the number of the Jews there forms an important part of the Jewish question, could be solved under the existing conditions in Russia, has been given to the four winds — and perhaps not to the winds of heaven. As regards any decided attitude, those gentlemen for the most part rely upon things gradually improving, while they cling to the old methods, which have not only been found useless, but also often show a tendency to aggravate and perpetuate the difficulties they were meant to resolve. The impossibility of a situation, and the danger bound up with it of bringing oneself into a desperate plight, must logically be the forerunner of a measure to end that plight. But since logic is only one among several equally strong combatants in the human heart, people do not always follow its precepts. They wait for the situation to change through outside influences; a kind of fatalism gains the upper hand among them, and grows with every increase of the difficulty in which they find themselves. We must not wonder that the fatalism of those good people is enormous. They speak of emigration as the only solution of the problem, and forget the fact that emigration — the carrying of the evil from one place to another — has called forth the very question with which they are confronted. When in the 14th century almost the whole of Europe had become impossible for the Jews, great masses of our people emigrated to Poland, where King Casimir the Great — some say at the entreaty of his beautiful Jewish mistress Esther — opened the gates of his land to the oppressed and outcast wanderers. Then, without doubt, all eyes were turned towards Poland as the haven of refuge of our people, as nowadays they are turned towards the United States, Canada and the Argentine. Then, surely, large-hearted and philanthropic men thought that if only they could see a considerable number of their brethren safe in free Poland, far from the earthly hell of Jewry in Europe, all would be well ordered and the welfare of their people assured. They had many a reason for it, for they lacked the experience which is at our command to-day; they had in their age no Herzl to point out to them that the emigrating Jew brings antisemitism into the land to which he wanders with the bundle on his weary back; or, to give expression to a terrible truth in his words: "We naturally emigrate to the countries where we are not persecuted, and our presence calls forth persecution."
The attainment of equal rights for the Jews in Russia is by itself no solution of the question either. We certainly strive for equal rights, and for the Jews in Russia perhaps nothing is more desirable. But if equal rights were the solution of the question, there would be no antisemitism in Germany, France or America, nor would that grim enemy be beginning to raise his head in this country, as he undoubtedly is doing. No! We may respect and admire those men for their many brilliant qualities; in the name of our persecuted brothers and sisters we may thank them with all our hearts for their generous and noble help in time of need; but salvation does not lie in the direction to which they point. That would only lead to a postponement of the solution of the Jewish question, and surely we ought to-day to find something better to do than the temporary patching of our injuries.
But there is yet another way, to which much attention is now being paid, and which called forth Lord Rothschild's letter. That way is known as Jewish Territorialism.
Ladies and Gentlemen, there is no more terrible chapter of Jewish history than that which treats of the destruction of Jerusalem under Titus, and the most terrible part of that chapter is the internal strife which led our people to ruin. You know that there was then a war party and a peace party, that Zealots, Sanhedrists and Idumeans fell apart among themselves into countless parties, all of which cherished the most furious hatred against one another, all of which, only too often in the literal sense of the expression, faced one another with drawn dagger. Everyone was ready for the fight; even the peace party claimed to fight with peaceful means — but each had his own views on the best way of fighting, so that, as has been aptly said: "weapons which were urgently needed for the struggle against Rome were used in bitter hatred and suspicion against Jewish brethren." We Jews have our Rome to-day as well, and it looks as though we, too, were turning the weapons of which we stand so urgently in need against the common enemy, with hatred and suspicion against our brethren. It may be inevitable, but are we sure that it is inevitable? Have we, then, while upholding the principles for which we stand, already exhausted all the means by which we might attain to unity?
To strive after it is our duty to-day, and I think it will be admitted that we Zionists have pointed out the right way by having called together a general conference. Let us see whether we can to-day go yet a step further, even if not quite in the same direction. I have set forth in what respect that which I should like to call the policy of Lord Rothschild's letter fails to do justice to the real needs of Jewry. Does the Territorial scheme fulfil this purpose better in any respect? I should like for the moment to put into the background every consideration of the origins of this scheme, but should nevertheless like to say in regard to them that I agree with Dr. Nordau, who in his speech in