Page 14 — "Die Welt" — No. 3.
(continued from page 13)
…Paris on the 21st of September said that in the formation of the new organisation the President had made himself guilty of a grave error. It is our business to see whether we can forestall the consequences of this grave error — whether we can, if possible, set it right and protect Israel from its consequences.
I must confess that it is difficult to enter more closely into the Territorial scheme, because its promoters are not agreed. Mr. Zangwill speaks of a Jewish State; Mr. Lucien Wolf will have nothing to do with Jewish national aspirations. Mr. Zangwill informs us that he has written down his proposals and laid them before the Government. Mr. Lucien Wolf declares "the truth at the moment to be that the Territorialists at present have no scheme at all." "I do not deny," he continues, "that a scheme has been drafted, but the Council has not adopted it. We may go further and say that the scheme forms the subject of very serious deliberations and negotiations on the part of the Council, and some time will doubtless yet elapse before it can be given its final form." Lesser pillars of the organisation seem to agree with one another just as little. Here one speaks of the scheme as one that is to bring the solution of the Jewish question; another thinks its purpose is the relief of the evils among the Jews in Russia. In short, it seems to me that the time has been too short to combine the various ideas and ideals, which are to be found almost without exception in every body of men, as yet into a generally approved scheme.
So far, however, as the matter is clear to me, the Territorialists propose that a larger territory be acquired for the Jews, preferably under English suzerainty, in some place suited to the founding of a Jewish colony with the right of self-government. The Territorialists appeal to the wretched condition of our people, the oppression under which the Jews stand, the necessity that something be done at once to secure us an existence as a people, lest we vanish from the earth. And we hear, too, that delay is fatal. If we can win in Palestine a legally secured, publicly recognised home, that is well and good; in the meantime, however, we ought to leave no opportunity unused to found such a legally secured and publicly recognised home in any country that becomes accessible to us. I hope that I have herewith given at least fair expression to the standpoint of the Territorialists.
Now, however, it is clear that such a scheme cannot solve the Jewish question. The founding of a Jewish settlement will not solve the question, and it would be madness to undertake a re-foundation of the Jewish State anywhere but in Palestine; the land to which the Jew, during his exile of two thousand years, has never given up his moral right, and which has always remained the object of his dearest hopes. One thing is certain: however great the territory we possess, however extensive our autonomous rights, and however great the number of Jews who emigrate thither, if this territory is not Palestine it can never become more than a settlement — a colony; it can never be the Jewish State. Our people can regard no other centre than Palestine as its final goal. I hold that Jews in any other country, even if they had rights of self-government there, would still find themselves in the same position as to-day, that is, they would not have reached their goal, but would still be in the "Golus"! If the Territorialists believe and proclaim that their scheme constitutes a revision of the Zionist idea — that is, is a new Zionism — then they are labouring under a grave error, and we must leave them to their delusion and must under all circumstances take care that our aims are clear and that no confusion arises in them.
I believe, however, that the majority of the Territorialists are under no such delusion, and am convinced that this holds good too of those Zionists who have joined the Territorialists. I believe that what they are striving for is an extensive territory with the right of Jewish self-government, which is to offer a refuge to the persecuted of our people and to lighten the pressure that weighs upon Jewry. Such an idea may have a great attraction for the imagination, and contains many of the elements which are inseparable from the Zionist idea and which make it so attractive. Territorialists, however, cherish a certain contempt for such things and consider themselves above all practical. Now it is one thing to acquire a territory, certainly no easy one, but the most important thing is that one cannot be sure of one's colonists. Lately, for instance, I saw in a letter from Mr. Winston Churchill to some Jewish electors in West Manchester that he divides his remarks on Territorialism into two parts: the first part treats Territorialism from the practical point of view, and the second part from the ideal point of view, borrowed from Zionism, from which some of its adherents — for purposes of propaganda — regard Territorialism. The second part has the full approval of the Under-Secretary for the Colonies, while the first brings before his eyes only the doubts and difficulties of the undertaking. The fact at all events is that what has made an impression upon the Under-Secretary for the Colonies is the wonderful idealism with which those practical gentlemen must be equipped who draw up schemes about a territory before they know to what territory these schemes refer. The wise Mrs. Glasse impressed upon her readers that before they could roast a hare they must first catch it. What would she have thought of people who compose a recipe before they know whether their dish is to be fish, flesh or fowl, or whether they would content themselves with an easily obtainable red herring? The acquisition of the territory is, as I have already said, not the greatest of the difficulties. Baron Hirsch acquired an excellent territory for the Jewish people, with inexhaustible resources for its equipment and development. Why did the attempt fail so completely? I will not tell you this in my own words. Mr. Zangwill has made the reason clear to us. "Baron Hirsch," he says, "was the greatest 'Dreamer of the Ghetto' of his age. One of his dreams was that he could fetch Jews out of their overcrowded ghettos and settle them, unexpectedly, on lonely farms at the other end of the world. And yet it is strange — mark Mr. Zangwill's words — that he (Baron Hirsch) could not see that Palestine is the only land whose soil has any attraction for the Jews." I do not believe that rights of self-government will form a counterpoise to the attraction of Palestine, any more than I believe that Mr. Zangwill was wrong when, in the same speech that I have quoted, he declared that the true solution, the only solution of the Jewish question, was a publicly and legally recognised home in Palestine. For two thousand years it has been the prayer of the Jews, not that self-government should be granted them, but that Palestine should be given back to them, and the majority at all events have meant this in earnest the whole time.
It is clear, however, that the Territorialists on the average have been partly aware that no Jewish settlement would succeed which leaves national feeling wholly out of play, and for this reason they strove for self-government. But I hold that in this respect they are leaning on a shaking reed, that they may not hope to awaken national feeling so long as they place themselves — as in fact they do — outside the national movement. The fact that the East African scheme lay within the national movement constituted its best, and perhaps its only, prospect of success. The lesson which should be drawn from this scheme is that in the view of a great majority its locality was not national in the Jewish sense. Much weight was laid upon this point, just as Mr. Zangwill did when he discovered the flaw in Baron Hirsch's scheme. Why should the Territorialists expose themselves to the failure on which other schemes have been wrecked, by such a disregard of local attraction as they appear to show? Why do they not take care that such a failure be avoided in their scheme, and that they secure to the Jewish people a settlement which possesses local as well as political attraction, the only local attraction that is effective for the Jewish people. And surely it can be no disadvantage in the eyes of the Territorialists to frame their scheme in such a way that it makes it possible for them to work together with the Zionists.
I believe that such a scheme could well be made. In this connection I leave every question of Palestine itself out of consideration. They want a territory which they can actively colonise, wherever it may be, and we are eager to colonise actively as soon as this is possible in the lands in the neighbourhood of Palestine. Let them agree that the territory they first strive for shall be one which lies within the limits set us by the Congress, so that we and they can work towards it together. Since the Congress I have worked hard to learn every conceivable fact about such a territory, which I believe to be attainable, to be capable of extensive development, and in a comparatively short time