Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 3.
(continued from page 5)
…disturbed the representatives of the people in their work on the general questions of the Empire, just as they had, after all, always and everywhere in Russia done nothing but disturb. They were the enemies of Russia under the old regime, and they are now the enemies of the new regime, and against these disturbers of the peace the struggle must simply be made sharper. And if one or more voices are then raised in defence of the Jews — what will they accomplish against the closed chorus of their adversaries, and above all against the utterly apathetic indifference of the overwhelming majority?
But let us suppose even that the incredible could happen: the whole Jewish question is settled with a stroke of the pen. Will the problem then really be solved?
Even in this case the hope of a future peaceful life for the Jewish people in Russia seems to us very vague and doubtful. The decades-long rightlessness of the Jews, together with administrative oppression and the incitement of the rest of the population, have accustomed the Russian people too much to regarding the Jews as pariahs for whom the law does not exist and against whom every violence is permitted. This view has taken root too deeply in the people for the purely legal emancipation of the Jews to be able to improve the attitude of the masses towards them. And if until quite recently the movement against the Jews always bore a more accidental and sporadic character, in the fearful days of the 18th — 23rd of October it showed itself of such enormous dimensions, spread so far over the whole Russian Empire, that it must have left ineffaceable traces upon the broad masses of the people. And given the peculiar nature of the psychology of the masses, the result will not be that people who let themselves be carried away into these infamies will recognise their misdeed and take pains to make amends for it, but the contrary: that they will fasten themselves still more stubbornly upon their wrong and behave still more hostilely towards the victims of their violence. The innocent victims, instead of awakening sympathy, merely arouse a fresh incitement to outrage and a desire to deal them fresh blows. So, too, antisemitism in Russia has hitherto always increased whenever a pogrom took place somewhere. Then the press always coarsened its attacks and preached war against the Jews anew; society became more hostilely disposed, and the Government sharpened its repressive measures precisely when one would have thought that sheer pity for the unhappy victims ought to have brought about an alleviation of their lot. And so now too, in the October days, antisemitism has received so strong a new foundation, has left so thick a sediment in the lowest strata of the people, that it will take many years before this hatred could gradually begin to fade. Moreover, let no one console himself with the thought that with the horrors of the 18th—23rd of October the cup of the Jewish people's sufferings must be drained; nothing guarantees that the pogroms will not be repeated in one year, in two years and, God knows how often, again.
On the other hand, as now, the mood of the masses of the people, of the Government and of the intelligentsia will serve as sufficient excuse for their negative attitude towards the Jewish question. And this appeal to the feelings of the people is too effective a means for it not to be put to the same use in the future as has so often been made of it with success hitherto.
If, therefore, even — and that would be the best case — the Duma were to abolish the Jewish question legally, the danger of new massacres for the Jews would by no means be removed thereby, and the life and property of the Jews would hang, as before, in constant insecurity. And this danger and insecurity will naturally increase still very considerably if the Duma does not settle the Jewish question and the Jews thereby remain in the same rightless position as hitherto. Most of the chances, unfortunately, are in favour of the latter possibility, as was set out above: namely, that the Duma leaves this whole question open.
* * *
Such are the prospects of the Russian Jews of a way out of their present fearful situation. Never yet have the Jews lived through so important a historic moment — a moment that holds within it so many grave consequences. If until now the Jews resigned themselves to their rightless position, if they were content with partial alleviations, they will now, after the scenes of horror they have lived through, after all the sacrifices they have made, when the whole country is receiving freedom and they alone remain excluded, simply be unable to bear this shame of degradation psychically. Materially they are ruined, for the most part given over to hunger and poverty. Nearly 300 small towns have been destroyed, and the terrible crisis throughout the whole country is ruining even those who remained untouched by the devastating effect of the pogroms. Almost the whole people now consists of nothing but the poor and the hungry, among whom the somewhat better-off form a small minority. As during a conflagration, the people run about, mad with terror and confusion, without knowing what they are doing, what they ought to undertake. General despair is the sign of the day.
In this important historic moment the eyes of all Russian Jews are turned upon their brothers in Europe and America. Does not the Talmud too say that the imprisoned cannot free themselves? The Russian Jews do not doubt the sympathy of their Western brothers — the great contributions raised after Kishineff and Homel and now after the October atrocities speak plainly enough. But contributions alone are still little. The Jews now need one thing even more urgently than money; they now need the whole concentrated spiritual energy of the Jewish people; to help them there is needed the gathering together of all its psychic and moral forces. Great historic moments also set great historic tasks. And such a moment Jewry is now living through. Now the time has come when the Jews of all countries must unite in a general Jewish federation and seriously occupy themselves with the solution of the Jewish question. Sixty years ago already the necessity of such a federation was clear. But in relation to the aims and tasks which it had then set itself, was the field of the
