No. 3. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…one not over which the despair should be the greater: over the cannibal instincts and the bestiality of the unbridled mob, or over the apathy and malicious glee of the middle classes and of the local so-called intelligentsia, who calmly looked on at what was happening all around them, and who considered it superfluous to interfere in an affair not their own, and even refused asylum to the innocent victims who sought refuge under their roofs, and pitilessly delivered the unfortunates, with their wives and children, out of their houses into the claws of wild beasts.
The only ray of light against this grim and gloomy background was the voice of the Zemstvo Congress in Moscow in the first days of November. After the Congress had for twelve days debated every possible question and passed the most varied resolutions, after sixty speakers had spoken vehemently against the proclamation of martial law over Poland, the Jews too were at last remembered. Messrs. Roditschew and Kowalewski delivered two fiery speeches in defence of the Jews, which the Jews will always remember with gratitude, since nobility of mind and warm feeling spoke from them. The Congress, carried away by these speeches, unanimously adopted a resolution proposed by the speakers, in which it expressed its sympathy with the Jews and gave expression to its firm expectation of the speedy equality of rights of the Jews with the other citizens of Russia.
Now the Jews stand before the dreadful question: What next?
Granted even that, after all the confusion and disturbances, the Imperial Duma will assemble. Will it at last solve the Jewish question?
Unfortunately, given the situation of the Jews just briefly sketched in the phase preceding the meeting of the Imperial Duma, in the period of the so-called movement for freedom, we must greatly doubt an affirmative answer to this question. The Duma will have so much to do that it will have "no time" to occupy itself with the Jewish question. Why, even the Zemstvo Congress, which met several times in the course of the year, only in its last session in November, after twelve days' deliberation on other matters, at last found the opportunity to go into this question. What, then, is one to expect of an Imperial Duma in which, together with the Roditschews and Nabokows, the Suworins and Kruschewans will not only sit, but will even form the majority?
In one case the possibility of a solution of the Jewish question would still exist: namely, if the Duma were to begin its activity by drawing up the fundamental law on the rights of all citizens, a "declaration des droits de l'homme". Then, together with the other great principles of right and justice, the principle of the equality of all before the law would probably be proclaimed as well, whereby the Jewish question would at bottom be disposed of. But even then the question would be solved only in principle, and by no means in fact as well, just as in the Manifesto of the 17th of October all freedoms were proclaimed, while de facto the old restrictive regulations for the most part remained in force. Here too quite special laws will be needed to tear apart this cunningly woven net of restrictions which for a century has spun itself ever more densely about the Jew on every side, from birth to death. Will the Duma have energy and consistency enough for that? There will, after all, be so many questions on its agenda that will be able to claim a certain precedence.
And so it is probable that the Duma will not concern itself with a declaration of fundamental rights, but will rather regard the Manifesto of the 17th of October as such a declaration. That the little formula of the equality of all before the law found no place there will hardly trouble anyone very much; indeed some, perhaps even the majority, will be not a little pleased at it. What all the others need has, after all, been given, and what has not yet been given concerns only a small part of the population, just 4%. Is it worth troubling oneself about that?
The Duma will therefore occupy itself first with consolidating the rights and freedoms given in the Manifesto, with drafting new laws on the press, associations and assemblies, on securing the inviolability of the person and civil liberty, on the reorganisation of the Council of the Empire and of the Senate, of the central and local administrative authorities, on the reform of local self-government, on the share of the peasants in the land, on the regulation of the condition of the workmen, on strikes and workmen's combinations, on the restoration of order in the higher and secondary schools, etc., etc., to say nothing at all of the current and urgent tasks of examining the budget, the revenue and expenditure of the Empire, etc. All these labours will so engross the attention and the activity of the Duma, not only in the first session but far into the future, that it will have no time to occupy itself with the Jewish question. One concerns oneself with this problem, and puts it in the first rank, only when new restrictions are in question; but when there is talk of abolishing them, oh, then the suitable moment is needed, a particular mood, appropriate conditions. Even if the Duma consisted of nothing but Roditschews, the Jews would still have to wait a long time until this moment came; why, even the sittings of the Zemstvo Congress lasted a full year before it could bring itself to a resolution on the Jewish question. But the Roditschews will, after all, form only an extreme minority in the Duma; the majority will be made up of the indifferent and of declared enemies of the Jews of the party of Suworin & Co. And all these gentlemen will say to themselves: What we wanted we have attained, and as for occupying ourselves with quite abstract principles, for that we have no time now. The demand of the Jews for equal rights is just as abstract as the demand for the autonomy of Poland, for the nationalisation of the land, etc. — all things with which we practical politicians cannot possibly occupy ourselves now, which we must for the present ignore entirely, in order to attend exclusively to our own affairs. So the moderates among these gentlemen will speak: "the more zealous, however, will hardly fail to speak of the impudence of these demands of the Jews, which only
