Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 6 · 9 February 1906
5printed page
scan 3 of 24
Facsimile · scan 3 of 24
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 6. — "Die Welt" — 5.

(continued from page 4)

. . . of the Mosaic confession, and they do not permit the whole people to be forcibly boxed into alien political groups.

It appears beyond doubt that the watchword "Full Rights" will be a battle-cry in the first half of the twentieth century. We are contemporaries of exceedingly momentous events; for now the potential of national energy accumulated in Jewry through the last decades is discharging itself. The Renaissance movement is ceasing to be the privilege of particular Jewish classes; it is seizing the whole Jewish population with elemental force and is laying the foundation for the creation of a self-conscious Jewry.

The watchword "Full Rights!" raises us to the height of political unity, brings about the concentration of Jewish forces, and sets Zionism at its post for the political struggle in the Golas.

Jan Kirszrot.


POLITICAL REVIEW

Sir Montagu's Arts. We publish in this number an interesting correspondence between Mr. L. J. Greenberg and Sir Samuel Montagu, which is now making the round of the entire English press. Properly speaking, this correspondence was a highly one-sided one, for the one party — Mr. Greenberg — wrote, while the other — Sir Montagu — merely received the letters and . . . . kept silent. He kept silent, although he ought not to have kept silent, although his political sagacity, to go no further, was called in question by Mr. Greenberg's disclosures. Sir Montagu is convicted, by irrefutable evidence, of a distortion of facts, nay, of an incorrect assertion. And Sir Montagu keeps silent; he accepts the challenge and makes no response. Sir Samuel is, to be sure, a "great gentleman," who by his money, his title and his inherited name holds a considerable position in "Society"; but greater Olympians than he do not leave such disclosures unheeded, forasmuch as they go through the "English" press, before which even the Jewish Lordships tremble in awe.

To understand Sir Samuel one must recapitulate the contents of the correspondence.

Sir Montagu joined with Rothschild and other "leaders" to issue a "manifesto" against the "Jewish State," that is, against the aspirations of Zionism and of Territorialism. He wished to unite the whole of moneyed Jewry for this laudable purpose and cabled, among others, to Mr. Jakob Schiff in New York, whose signature he requested. Mr. Schiff, however, is neither a "Lord" nor President of the "Dispersions Committee," that is, the committee of dispersal, which has set itself the task of transferring the Jews out of Whitechapel, where they live together for better or worse, into all five quarters of the globe — of "dispersing" them. In short, Mr. Schiff refused his signature to a manifesto which "might produce discord and strife at a time when unity is needful." But Sir Montagu would not be deterred. He grew importunate, not at all in the English manner — was it not, after all, a matter of a good cause! And he brought out his strongest weapon: "It is the express wish of the Liberal Government," ran the reply of Sir Samuel the Disperser. The affair became known. The circles concerned, that is to say the Zionists and the Territorialists, were somewhat taken aback. What interest, then, can the new Liberal Government have in working against the plans of the Jewish national movement? Does it not rather lie in its interest to support the Jews in their aspirations to this end, since the awkward situation created by the Alien Act and the unceasing Jewish immigration would thereby be removed? Is not the fundamental principle of the Liberal Party, the party of Gladstone and Roseberry and Campbell-Bannermann, the granting of the widest possible autonomy to the colonies, nay, Home Rule for Ireland? Why should it think otherwise on the Jewish question? And then, have not the most eminent members of the new Parliament openly declared themselves for the Zionist movement? We quote only a few of the declarations that have come in to the English Zionist Federation: Mr. J. A. Brice writes: I sympathise with the plans of the Zionist organisation." J. Keir-Hardie, the Socialist leader in the new Parliament, writes: "I shall gladly support Zionism . . . ." The same is written by Mr. Crookes, Atherley Jones, Cathcart Wason, Sir Samuel Scott and a number of other eminent parliamentarians. The letters of Winston Churchhill and Lord Elgin, which signify an official recognition of the Jewish national movement on the part of the new Government, are, of course, well known. How, then, could Sir Montagu's assertion be brought into harmony with these facts? Our friend, Mr. L. J. Greenberg, inquired of Sir Montagu whether the story was true. No answer. His Lordship wrapped himself in silence. Thereupon Mr. Greenberg turned to the Prime Minister himself, in order to learn the truth at the very source of policy. Sir Campbell-Bannermann, who is quite as aristocratic and rich as Sir Samuel Montagu, was more courteous and answered at once. And the answer turned out, naturally, exactly as one had reasonably to expect. The whole story of the "special wish of the Liberal Government was without any foundation." Sir Banner-mann does not lie. Sir Montagu keeps silent. Has Sir Montagu invented an old wives' tale? Could he so far forget himself as to spread false rumours of this kind, which are so easily checked?

We will not believe in the mala fides, or even in the dishonesty, of Sir Montaga. His past, his title, his money and his inherited name prove that he is a thoroughly honest man who has the best of intentions. He is by no means indifferent to the situation of the Jews. Yes, "his intentions are good." . . . Sir Montagu did not act maliciously. His assertion was probably not plucked out of the air. But though his honesty remains unimpeached, his conduct in this question does not allow one to infer a deep political understanding, nor a high degree of self-respect either. It is told in London — and this explanation is the most probable — that Sir Montagu did in fact speak with some quite insignificant, subordinate member of the Liberal Government, and that the latter expressed his irresponsible and irrelevant opinion of Zionism and Territorialism. Now had Sir Montagu been a real politician, with access to the spheres of high policy, had he been informed at all of the intentions of the new Government, he would have had to ignore the utterances of an irresponsible official instead of making himself ridiculous. But yet another cause is at play here. Sir Montagu is not merely no expert in the