Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 22 · 1 June 1906
7printed page
scan 3 of 18
Facsimile · scan 3 of 18
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 22 — DIE WELT — 7

(continued from page 6)

…in the sense of right of the Russian people and of the officials, who until now were accustomed to no laws applying to the Jews, will be brought about. In order that the Jewish deputies may confer in every case, they must as a matter of course take their seats side by side, as the deputies of the other national groups do. The necessity of a Jewish-national group further follows from the consideration that one must be prepared for the nearer or more distant moment when the peoples inhabiting Russia, the Jews included, will order their national life on the basis of autonomy. As to the question how far the joint action of the members of the Jewish group should extend, and to which spheres of political life it should apply, some voices were raised to the effect that this obligation should extend to all questions of internal politics. The majority of the defenders of the "group," however, held the opinion that only in regard to such questions as directly touch the Jewish question, whose solution in any sense would affect all Jews, should the deputies be bound to act in common and to go one way; as regards the questions which reach over into general Russian life and concern the Jews only in their capacity as Russian citizens, the Jewish deputies may vote with those parties to which, by their other political views, they feel themselves to belong. The question of club discipline, that is, subordination to the decisions of the majority of the group, was described by some as indispensably necessary, since otherwise the group would miss its real purpose. Other adherents of the group, however, believed that it could be left, without harm to the fruitful working of the group, to the free discretion of the individual deputies whether they should subordinate themselves to the decision of the majority or not. For the formation of the group stand the Zionist deputies and Dr. Frenkel and the numerous Zionist delegates, among them Dr. Bernstein-Kohan, Temkin, Motzkin, Schabotinski, Pasmanik, Brutzkus, and others.

Against a Jewish parliamentary group spoke, among others, the following members of the Duma: Winawer, Bramson, Ostrogorsky, Scheftel and Tscherwonenkis. Their arguments were roughly the following: In principle none of them was against a Jewish parliamentary group. The only question was how far the founding of such a group could already now be expedient and of use. And here it was to be feared that the formation of a Jewish group, the setting apart of the Jewish delegates in the Duma, might prove harmful to the chief aim of the moment — the attainment of Jewish equal rights — since the other parties, in consequence of the setting apart of the Jewish deputies, would in a certain sense shift the moral responsibility for the solution of the Jewish question on to the group. If, on the other hand, the Jews are incorporated into the other parties, they can the more readily use their influence, thereby increased, to move these parties to a favourable settlement of the Russian Jewish question. A further reason against the formation of a group was the fact that this group could not represent a wholly definite programme on all questions; and since a moral unity in regard to the Jewish question existed among the Jewish deputies in any case, the group was even superfluous. It was not to be feared that, in the solving of the Jewish question in the Duma, the Jewish deputies would bring forward differing projects, as the adherents of the group put forward as one of their arguments. This existence of moral unity among the Jewish deputies sufficed, and a public sanction of it, a discipline, was not necessary. It was not now the time, some held, to carry out nationalist tendencies, but to co-operate in the work of reorganizing the Russian state, not to regard things only from the Jewish standpoint, but to think of the welfare of all. The fear was also expressed that, if the Jews united into a separate national group, the Russians would do the same in order to defend their national rights, — and then the Jews would lose everything. These and similar arguments were set forth and supported pro and contra in extremely excited discussions, in the course of which more than 40 speakers had their names entered on the list of speakers. At last, at 3 o'clock in the night, when the excitement on both sides had reached its height, the following resolution was put to the vote by the adherents of the group:

"The Jewish deputies in the Duma form a Jewish group, which acts in common on the questions of Jewish equal rights in accordance with the provisions of the Vilna Conference. The members of this group, in the firm consciousness of their national unity, work out by mutual agreement the principles of their co-ordinated activity."

The opponents of the group propose to use, instead of the word "group," the designation "collegium," and, instead of the second half of the resolution, the following sentence: "whereby the members of the collegium are subject to no compulsory discipline."

This amendment is rejected by 57 votes to 44, and the resolution of the Zionists adopted by the same majority.

Upon the announcement of this result the minority, amid extraordinary excitement in the assembly, made the declaration that the 44 opponents of the group considered their further collaboration in the Union impossible and therefore saw themselves compelled to withdraw. The same declaration was made in the name of 6 deputies of the Duma, namely in the name of Messrs. Winawer, Bramson, Scheftel, Tscherwonenkis, Jollos and Ostrogorsky.

On the following day, however, negotiations were resumed, at first privately, and since on both sides the lively wish prevailed to come to an agreement on the basis of a compromise that took account of both parties, it was at last possible to find common ground in the following resolution:

"The fourth conference of the Union for Jewish Equal Rights declares it necessary that the Jewish deputies in the Duma form a Jewish group for common action on all questions of Jewish equal rights, in accordance with the resolutions of the Vilna Conference. The members of the group are bound by no compulsory discipline. In the firm consciousness of their national unity the members of the group work out by mutual agreement the principles of their co-ordinated activity."

This resolution was then adopted unanimously in plenary session, whereupon the conference, after a speech by Winawer and others expressing their satisfaction at the unity regained, passed on to questions of internal organization.


AN EPILOGUE TO THE VIENNA ELECTIONS

Viennese Letter from Dr. LEO SOFER (Vienna).

The outcome of the Vienna elections is of such importance that, especially when one takes into account the newly awakened interest in a purposeful Jewish policy in Austria, it surely deserves a searching criticism. Its most salient features are: the growth of Social Democracy and the complete elimination of the Liberal party. It is commonly said, to be sure, that no one can be more than dead; the Liberal party, however, has accomplished this feat. It is today in the agreeable position of being able to lose nothing more, because it has lost everything.

The growth of the Social Democrats is not, from the standpoint of our national policy, to be greeted with unmixed joy. We will not recall the old sins of their chief organ, the "Arbeiterzeitung," its shameful conduct toward the Roumanian Jewish question, when that paper, otherwise so mistrustful, held in judging the situation only the official soothing telegrams of the Roumanian Government to be the trustworthy source of information; we will also pass over in silence many another flippant little exploit of press hussarry on the part of this paper. We will simply reproduce how the "Arbeiterzeitung," on the day after the election at which the Social Democrats increased their holding of three mandates by four, curries favour with the Christian Socials. It writes, word for word, in the number of 10 May: "Once again it has been shown that in Vienna only two parties exist that are rooted in the people: we and our Christian Social opponents. That the Christian Socials are a great party we have never disputed, but even Herr Lueger might now be just enough to admit, and to act accordingly, that

2*