"Die Welt" — No. 50.
(continued from page 7)
…differentiation was not a profound one, not a deep-rooted one, and many a catchword has already been forgotten, despite the heated debates it called forth at the time. But at Minsk the question of the economic element within Jewry, and of the work possible in that direction, emerged for the first time. Yet this question was essentially different from the form in which it now presses upon us. It was not an end in itself, it was not a direct path meant to lead to the goal, but a side occupation, a means of holding together the forces needed for the attainment of the final aim, the Charter. The Second Conference, at Minsk, was the culminating point of political Zionism. It was the end of the first stage, the preparatory phase of the party, which was marked by the astonishingly rapid growth of the movement. And therein lay also the germ of danger for the movement. For our real successes fell short of our expectations. We did not know these facts at the time; our leader already sensed them. And in seeking real successes he grasped at a phantom.
The Uganda question played a great and fateful part in the development of the movement. It was a wrestling, revolutionary storm, which swept away many persons and many things, which caused values to be revalued, and which in the end made our movement purer and firmer. We miss a good many in our ranks whose absence we regret. But we believe that the best of them will return to our flag. Did not Zangwill himself say in his epistle to the Territorialists of Manchester: "We should scarcely find a nation upon our globe that would cede to us with a light heart even the smallest piece of its possessions... We shall have all the greater chances of attaining autonomy the less we talk of it... But unfortunately democracy cannot manage with diplomacy alone."
Despite the cruelty with which the separation took place, and for which some of us who did not understand the historical importance of the moment are to be held responsible, the resolution of the Uganda conflict had a salutary effect. And I hope that in the ranks of those who must rely solely upon the one force, the force of conviction, where there may be only a single dictatorship, that of the truth of life and of scientific truth, no secret committees and no dictatorships will henceforth be possible.
The Uganda question made clear to the organisation the significance of Palestine within Zionism. And in so doing one came upon two problems, the philanthropic and the diplomatic. For many among us, especially in the West, Zionism was a kind of philanthropy, a charity for "the poor brethren of the East," in which they left out of account the whole complicated question of Jewish national life. They forgot that our solution is only a minimum programme, that we wish to found an autonomous centre for all the Jews of the Diaspora. But the effect of the Uganda conflict was not confined to this alone. We have also been led to a revision of our view of diplomatic activity and of work in Palestine.
What, then, was Chamberlain's offer? Was it not the greatest concrete success of diplomatic Zionism? But neither Uganda nor any other territory was suitable for us. And although Uganda was a real success, it was precisely this offer that dealt the heaviest blow to the formerly so great prestige of diplomatic work. The words of Dr. Herzl, that one must seek an easier way when the more difficult one is barred, have, as applied to Palestine policy, produced a diametrically opposite effect — namely the denial of the significance of all diplomatic work, of all policy, the return to the old Chibas-Zion. This tendency always sounds through all their utterances; it forms, so to speak, the undertone of their speeches, even if it does not yet come openly to the fore. But they have forgotten the experiences of 1891; they have forgotten the circumstance that conditions in Palestine are by no means satisfactory and normal. And in one respect Achad-Haam agrees with our late leader: that everything we undertake in Palestine must be done upon a legally secured foundation. And when Oppenheimer, in his last Berlin speech, expressed the view that we shall get no Charter and consequently must work in Palestine even without rights, that is the influence of the current of the times. The question is, after all, precisely whether work upon a broad basis is possible in Palestine. To make it possible, we must enter into normal relations with Turkey and win the goodwill of the other Governments. For Governments and ruling classes are, after all, in our capitalist social order the strongest power, upon which our whole cause depends. We no longer hope for the Charter in the full extent of that word, for we know that too great a disproportion prevails between our do and the ut des; but we need normal relations, we must spare ourselves a repetition of the surprise of 1891, we need a broad legal basis in order to attract European capital and to promote emigration. Both — capital and living human strength — will come as soon as we shall have created the favourable conditions. Those who proclaim political Zionism a superseded standpoint render the national cause a very ill service. We need political work no less than before, even though the forms of this work must now be essentially different from those of Dr. Herzl.
Simultaneously with the slackening of faith in diplomacy, the demand for practical work in Palestine makes ever greater progress. And in this respect the development of Zionism is analogous to that of German Social Democracy. As soon as the Social Democrats had lost their faith in Engels' prophecy that the State of the Future would be realised in the year 1904, they turned to work in the present. We are convinced that Palestine will sooner or later, in this way or in that, be ours. The evolution of Zionism has opened the gate to practical work in Palestine. And meanwhile, in the very midst of this work, complaints become audible of resistance to this work, which — proceeds from the centre of our organisation. We heard this complaint at Cologne; Oppenheimer, too, alluded to it.
Is this complaint well founded? Gentlemen, I do not belong to the Inner A. C. and have never taken part in its sittings. I can form a judgment only from conversations with the members of the Inner A. C., among them also with the alleged opponents of Palestine work. I did not receive the impression that there could be any question here of resistance on principle. I have also heard from the other side the complaint that every thought, every attempt at diplomatic work, is received with mockery and contempt by some members of the Inner A. C. And I declare openly that both complaints are the consequences of the abnormal conditions under which our centre works. We shall have to deliberate seriously upon this; it is now one of the most important questions. The members of the Inner A. C. can act upon one another only in common, constant work, and so influence one another that they come to respect all forms of our work. But that is not now the case. So long as the present state of things continues, the complaints will go on accumulating and the work will go on being disturbed. I repeat: there are, with few exceptions, no opponents of work in Palestine. There are only differences of view as to the character and the content of this work.
What, then, must the organisation do — and what are the tasks of its central organ?
I shall draw a certain distinction between the duties of the organisation and those of its leadership. While the organisation, the great masses of our party, must advance unceasingly in their work for Palestine, and of their own initiative bring capital and forces to the land, the task of our centre is the creation of the conditions, the prospering of this work. And these conditions are: rights, credit, and knowledge of the land. We need rights, as the first foundation of normal development; we need credit, since with our own means we cannot accomplish the colossal work; we need exact and not merely theoretical knowledge of the land. There are, again, works of general national significance which we must accomplish at once and without delay. There is the creation of a National Library, of a Museum, of a Teachers' Seminary, etc. But our greatest attention must be directed to the principal aims. Our Palestine Commission is working zealously and methodically at the third of the principal purposes named, and thereby creates the condition for the second. But the first, too, is indispensable. Unfortunately the work in this last respect has slackened since the death of its first master. And only lately have rather timid attempts been made to take it up again. Let us not paralyse these feeble attempts by our mockery and our disparagement!
A further consequence of Ugandism was the so-called proletarian Zionism, which arose under the influence of the awakened question of the necessity of helping the Jewish proletariat, and of the Russian Revolution. In contrast to political and cultural Zionism, these "bourgeois" parties, proletarian Zionism created the so-called economic foundation of Zionism. And it is remarkable enough that the assimilationist Ica, which first made the conditions of life of the Jewish workers, Jewish economy, the subject of research, the foundation stone for proletarian Zion-
