Q. Of course, you say so, speaking simply as their advocate and on their behalf? A. Yes.
Q. May I not with your permission draw a complete line between that portion of your evidence in which you have spoken as their advocate, and the other portion to which you have been led to speak by some of the members of the Commission who have asked your opinion upon things affecting this country? A. Yes.
Q. I may draw that line? A. Yes.
Q. I am sure you will forgive me if I say to you that it may be we here in this country have more knowledge of what takes place than you have when you express an opinion of what is good for us here? A. Certainly, my Lord.
Q. Do you wish us to pay any degree or a great degree of attention to the latter portion, if your evidence which affects the remedies that are suggested here for the evils, if they exist, do you wish us to pay much attention to what I call the British portion of your evidence? A. I say so in my evidence.
Q. I paid every attention and great respect to what you have said on behalf of your race and your brethren, but when we come to deal with what exists here, do you wish us to pay the same attention to that portion of your evidence as we do to what affects your race? A. I put it before you. Certainly I have less knowledge of the real conditions here than you have yourself.
Q. Let me give you an instance. Your general knowledge of what exists throughout the world, of course, will tell you that overcrowding in houses is an evil. I am sure you will be the first to admit that? A. Yes.
Q. As to the extent of overcrowding in any one locality in this country, have you any knowledge beyond what you have read in the proceedings of this Commission? A. No.
Q. Then the data upon which you could found a remedy are scarcely in your possession, are they? You have not the knowledge of these data which exist in this country with which we have to deal? A. No. I knew about it. I had general knowledge, but the figures I found in the evidence were the most statistical material I have had—the best statistics.
Q. You state on the first leaf of your paper the two alternatives: that we may forbid immigration, or we may allow it to continue as it exists. On those two matters you express your opinion properly enough. Do you wish to express any opinion as to a third course we may take, and that is to regulate and control the present immigration so as to meet the evils which exist here? A. Certainly; I understand there may be an administrative way of dealing with it without changing the laws or the general institutions. I understand that, but I am not sure it will be sufficient.
Q. You do not know yet what any suggested control or arrangement would be? A. But I have two facts to give me a slight instruction, and those are: first, the general conditions of entrance into your land, and, secondly, the misery present from sending to this land, or to any free points, the oppressed Jews. On these two facts I have not the presumption to anticipate what measures can be taken.
Q. Will you repeat the second point that you made? A. I repeat that I think the oppression or the misery is so great that it would defy the victims how to turn if they are dying and they tried to live elsewhere.
Q. That is not quite my point. Supposing we could find some arrangement here to control immigration, and by arrangement lessen the overcrowding and the other evils, do you feel qualified to express an opinion that we ought not to make an attempt to do that? A. From the English standpoint, no.
Q. I quite understand if anything occurs you would wish to allow things to go on as they are in this country? A. I think it would be preferable.
Q. From your point of view? A. From my point of view.
Q. But if the interests of this country require arrangement and control, I understand that you would not say that it would be either inhumane or contrary to any view of charity for us to take the step of control and even arrangement of the immigration? A.