As we are not in the promised times I should admit that every country decides for itself the necessities of self-defense.
WHAT CHARITIES SHOULD DO
Q. There is one more matter which Lord Rothschild probably abstained from questioning you about from a desire not to be egotistic. You rather, as I understand, condemn the amount of charity that the Jewish people show in this country to the immigrant? A. I do not condemn it.
Q. But you regret it? A. I regret that the moneys spent in the work of charity are not used in a general scheme which would, perhaps, be more efficacious, and which would avoid creating professional beggars, and which would help real working people.
Q. Will you be a little practical? What would you have altered in the present system of Jewish charity, and into what would you like to see that system resolved? A. That would mean that I should have to give a lecture on the subject. If it would not make you impatient, may I give a quotation from a French author? A lady came back from church and said: "How wonderful that preaching was!" "About what?" asked another. "About charity." "Well," asked she, "what could he have said new about charity? There is nothing to say new about charity." Certainly you ought to be charitable, but you must be charitable in the means, and consider the general conditions of your times. In the time of railways and shipping, and so on, when you can for £3 get from a far-distant land to another, you must have quite another kind of charity to what you had in 1800. I do not condemn charity, I am not foolish enough to do so.
Q. I want something practical, if you can give a suggestion to Lord Rothschild or any of those who lead charity in this country. A. I should do it with pleasure.
Q. What would you tell them to do? What would you wish? Would you say, “Send the Jews to one place,” or “Give them a particular means of living,” or what would you suggest? A. I would give them general advice and say, “Unite your forces and find out the right place and help the real working man instead of the wandering beggars and the professionals.”
Q. Find out the right place for what? A. For settling.
Q. You want a system of settling, probably away from this country? A. Yes.
Q. And you believe that would relieve the strain here? A. Yes.
WHY BARON HIRSCH FAILED
Q. Have not some of these settlements been tried and failed? A. They have been tried and they have failed, because people making these trials thought that money was all in the world; but it is not. With money you cannot make a general movement of a great mass of people. You must give them an ideal. You must put into them the belief in their future, and then you are able to take out of them the devotion to the hardest labor imaginable. I will give you an example. Argentina has a very good soil, and the conditions for agricultural labor are much better than in Palestine. But in Palestine they work with enthusiasm and they succeed. They are not the artificially made colonies; they are self-helping colonies which have that great national idea. I will not make a long speech, but I think it is clear enough what I mean.
Mr. Alfred Lyttleton: Did they fail in Argentina? A. They failed partly because there they were thinking always of the administration of what was given them by Baron Hirsch; and there was a company started which surrounded them with all the necessities, and avoided the difficulties, and so on. They are not self-standing.
This is an extract from a book that is ascribed to Mr. Harry S. Lewis with regard to Zionism. I want to ask whether you subscribe to this paragraph which I will read?
It should be added that the growth of Jewish national feeling is not out of harmony with the claims of English citizenship. It may be a curious question for casuists whether a conflict between the two obligations might arise in any conceivable circum-