dress. His knowledge of diplomacy is about equal to his knowledge of Palestine, and he seems to know still less of a less recondite issue—the Jewish people. Further, for a man to deliberately tell us now that there is no Jewish nation, and to hold that this is a viewpoint, as though there are no facts and no history, is to come so late in the day that Dr. Silverman should not be in so go-ahead a country as America. These things were well enough for the protest Rabbis of 1897, but we must forcibly remind Dr. Silverman that we have traveled miles since then, that even Claude G. Montefiore has had to put the issue into the balance, and that, therefore, to-day statements on this issue must have the warranty of facts.
ASS=IMILATION
IF Dr. Silverman can only fulminate against Zionism he has, however, a solution of his own for the Jewish problem. And though it is "my" solution, it is only new in that same egotistical pronoun. "See the sun stand still whilst I cry assimilation." But nothing of the kind happens. All the donkeys who have been scurrying that way are scurrying back again. They will not let you assimilate, Dr. Silverman, they being that outer world.
To the Jew the world is no oyster to be pried open. Not only is this Rabbinical offer of assimilation incontinently refused, but the Jew himself for the main part, heroically bold in his endeavors to get lost, unconsequentially refuses to perform the last stage in the disappearing trick. The argument of assimilation in New York is as hollow as the beat of any stage drum outside an old-fashioned dime show. Everyone knows the beat, everyone has seen the show, no one will pay a nickel for a view at the old collection.
But with all its hollowness, pretense, make believe, this doctrine of assimilation is nobly brave. With the recklessness of a Hotspur it begs the Jews in Russia and Roumania "to stew in their own juice." Such daring wisdom, nobility and chivalry combined have not been seen since Dumas' four musketeers rode their life and death race from Paris to London to save the Queen's studs. Dr. Silverman and so many others who give this tender advice to our blood-stricken brethren, truly
belong to that Light Brigade of whom Tennyson sang:
Theirs not to reason why, Theirs but to do and die. Into the valley of death Rode the six hundred.
Other men might describe this doctrine of assimilation applied here or over there in Europe as cowardly and ignoble. But that would be a viewpoint uttered in terms that would offend the softly trained ears of Fifth avenue and its vicinity.
ODIUM THEOLOGICUM
PROF. SCHECHTER certainly promises to avoid all theological odium in building up the Theological Seminary. He himself is a noted anti-clericalist, and what his celebrated address proves is that he is determined that the Seminarists shall be men of character and scholars. The whole trend of his teaching is what we must term national. He favors just that culture which the renaissance created by Zionism has impressed upon the Jews as a true one. In fact, and perhaps unconsciously, Prof. Schechter is a champion of the "Young Zion" and the Culture party who have proclaimed Jewish culture that vague quantity now aptly defined as seeking to make the old Jew equal to modernity, and the young Jew equal to Judaism. The Theological Seminary undertakes the latter task, and it is symptomatic of what thought leads to the desire to do that work, that, excepting the Principal, who has been silent, the more important members of the staff and nearly all the students are avowed Zionists. It is in such coincidences, which are much more than coincidences, that one perceives the deeper significance of Zionism, and the best proof that it is far from a transient movement.
In Europe a Jewish high school has been planned, and "visions are about" of a Jewish university in Jerusalem. No one now can say, or will say, these projects are hazy. Yet why should they be if we were not determined on a new lease of Jewish life to be lived in a Jewish way. How little logic is required to show how dead the assimilating theory really is.