THE WOULD-BE EXODUS
THE proclamation of a new exodus to the West and the South of the United States is meeting with no great response. Even the oratory of Dr. Hirsch cannot lure the Jews from what they know they have on the East Side of New York, to what they know not awaits them in the West. There is something both plausible and reasonable in this call for a re-dispersal. At least, we could welcome it for its promise of fresh air conditions, but it is a matter calling for the exercise of far more caution than is common to the platform.
To us, at least, this plea for re-dispersal comes as evidence in support of our old contention that nothing has been achieved in the settlement of Jewish problems. The fears that move Dr. Hirsch are not to be misconstrued, but redispersal is not a cure but a quack remedy. As has already been said the plea to go West, based on the fear of anti-Semitism, will have to be repeated, decade after decade, as each new center becomes, as it must become, congested. Dr. Hirsch must go further if he is in earnest with his project, and he must bring some tangible projects to the people whom he advises to pack up their good and chattels and move West.
LONDON'S PRIDE
LONDON, whose huge corporation, with its dignitaries, glitter and wealth, equals half a dozen petty states and still sits calmly a ruling center of the world, has, in its own language, “sent Roumania to Coventry.” State as state, London taboos it as not fit to sit at the table of gentlemen, this same Roumania being so ungentlemanly and unchivalrous as to have broken troth and plighted word with a poor, weak people—which is a mean thing. And even Roumania must find it gall and wormwood to be voted mean and
ungentlemanly by London, through the mouthpiece of its first citizen. London Jewry is full of the froth and exuberance of a battle in which this is no small incident.
Serious, realizing at last that the situation is for themselves grave, that anti-alien immigration will bring anti-Semitism to its doors, and that, moreover, the Jews must themselves understand whereto the battle must lead, the London Jews in fighting for Roumanian Jewry take common scot and lot and fight also for itself. This is in itself a great advance in the understanding of the problem of Jewish existence, and if we mistake not, London sees further and its Jews will go further. There is now in progress a religious struggle in the community, of which little is heard here, and less understood, which amounts to a testing of men and thought. There will be a testing by Shibboleth and Shibboleth ere long through this religious problem as to whether Israel in England is to stand by conscious naturalism or conscious assimilation, and we have little doubt as to the outcome of the struggle. It is that view which kept Roumania from the Lord Mayor's table which will conquer, and though few will acknowledge it, it is Zionism that has taught this manly form of protest.
**The Editor regrets that owing to indisposition, from which he has wholly recovered, this issue is not as perfect in respect to the musical supplement as he himself desired to make it. He feels, however, warranted in believing that as a new experiment the issue is a success, and if it meets with the support of the readers another supplement will be issued before the Passover holidays, which will have special reference to that festival. Owners of collections of traditional Jewish melodies are, however, urged to send in copies of music before the end of February.