The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 3 · March 1903
135printed page
scan 4 of 58

in golus; on account of our sins and of the sins of our ancestors we had to go forth from our former country into exile and have now to live in the lands of the strangers—Ba'avonos horabbim—this is the Polish Rabbis' philosophy of history.

But now proceed to another class of Jewish ministers. Go and ask the erudite Rabbis in Janesville and in Knoxtown, in Tripstrill and in Buxtehude, and without any hesitation they will come forward with the results of their profound theological and philosophical speculations: We, the Jewish race, have received from God a great message, and have been charged to deliver it to the nations; in order to fulfill this charge, God has sent us into the diaspora; had we remained locked up within the narrow boundary lines of Palestine, we would never have been able to do our duty in this regard; as one of our talmudical sages has said already so many hundreds of years ago, that the Holy One, blessed be He, has led Israel into the Golah solely for the purpose that an opportunity be given to multitudes of Gentiles to attach themselves to Israel as Gerim.

But, my dear Rabbis in Janesville and Knoxtown, in Tripstrill and Buxtehude, please think a little. Perhaps you may then come to the conclusion that from a centralized nation, honestly trying to become a model nation in its government and its institutions, will go forth a mightier and more wholesome influence upon the other nations, than can be expected from the efforts of thousands of a disorganized and widely diffused multitude of disjoined and unassociated individuals.

Now please do not say, We, standing upon the grounds of Prophetic Judaism, we who, like the prophets of old, are cosmopolitans and decline to be counted among the narrow-minded Jewish nationalists—we do not wish to have a Jewish nation politically resurrected again and a Jewish commonwealth re-established again. Our idea and our ideal is, that the Jewish nation, as a separate family amid the nations of the world, shall disappear, shall become merged among the other races and other nations; we are perfectly satisfied, if only the theistic principles of the Jewish religion will become prevailing among men; we are for Prophetic Judaism.

What? You are for Prophetic Judaism? You? who evidently do not know what Prophetic Judaism is? and what ideals this Prophetic Judaism was striving after? The ancient prophets of Israel were all and everyone, without exception, outspoken Jewish nationalists, and cannot be designated as cosmopolitans—as cosmopolitans in your sense of the word. The prophets did not expect that in the messianic times the barriers between Israel and the other nations would fall, and far from them was the irrational and unrealizable thought that in the future there would exist only one nation in the world. In their visions they saw Jerusalem as the center of the religious world, they saw the Jewish nation as the foremost one, as standing upon a high eminence, and the other nations and their kings and princes coming up to Jerusalem and worship in the Jewish temple there, and bringing their rich gifts with them for the Jewish nation, and acknowledging that Israel was their guide and teacher, their savior and messiah, etc. And you,