The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 3 · March 1903
136printed page
scan 5 of 58

you who speak and labor for the submerging of Israel among the other races dwelling upon our globe, you claim to have prophetic authority for the stand you have taken?

We have to touch another point. Fifty, sixty years ago, great and truly eminent men in Israel commenced to lay particular stress upon the Jewish Mission Idea. Many good and wise ones among our people continue to accentuate this idea. Why did our teachers, assembled in conferences in Braunschweig, Frankfurt, Breslau and elsewhere, do so? Our answer is this: Fifty, sixty years ago the belief in miracles and similar inheritances from former ages had become uprooted among cultured people. Educated Israelites in those times considered the regathering of dispersed Israel and the restoration of a Jewish State as a matter of impossibility. They would just as much had laughed at such an idea, as they would have laughed, if someone had said, In a few years two persons, the one in Hamburg and the other in Berlin, will be able to converse as easily as if they were together in one and the same room. Impossible! Impossible! they would have said; this would be a miracle, and miracles do not happen. Just so it appeared to them, as it would have appeared to almost everyone else in those times, as something impossible that a Jewish Nation should be reborn and that a Jewish State should be re-established. But if now Geiger, and Einhorn, and Samuel Hirsch, and Leopold Stein, and B. Wechsler, and others will meet in Gan Eden and take a walk together on some sunny afternoon, Geiger may remark, Friends, I truly am of the opinion that we have to re-examine and to revise one of the ideas which a half century ago we considered as true and promulgated before our people. It seems after all not to be so impossible that Israel, or a large part of it, may gather in Palestine and may have the right of self-government in their own commonwealth, and may find in Eretz Yisrael a refuge from unceasing persecutions. And the ci-devant rabbi of Luxemburg, S. Hirsch, will answer: I agree with you, Geiger. I now see that we were wrong and that dear Spinoza was right when he said that in political matters all developments depend upon conditions, and that conditions may so change that a Jewish State may become re-established. I move for re-examination of our former opinion in this matter. I second the motion, says Einhorn. We all second it, the others chime in. (For up there in Gan Eden they are not so obstinate as to stick by all means to opinions after they are proven to be erroneous.) Yes, Stein continues, I, in my times, had also seized the Jewish-Mission-Idea, and repeatedly I expounded it before my congregation. Again and again I reiterated certain isolated Midrashic words of consolation and certain haggadic passages of an uplifting character, according to which the true Messiah was born on the day on which the Temple was destroyed, and to these passages I gave an homiletical twist, of which certainly their originators had not the remotest thought. Or I quoted talmudical sayings, according to which Israel was strewn out as seed corn among the nations of the world, so that thereby the Kingdom of God might grow up the earlier and root deeper. Stein having concluded, Hirsch rises again and says, I now make another motion; I move that we all go over to our good friend Spinoza and have a talk with him on the subject. Yes, let us all go, the others said unanimously. At this moment it happened that