The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
241printed page
scan 42 of 80

PHILANTHROPY ECONOMIZED.

Turning from England to America, one finds that an infinitely vaster amount of philanthropic activity would be economized if the American Jews had not to grapple with the many problems cruelly and unnecessarily thrust upon them by the huge stream of misdirected immigration. The B'nai B'rith Order, for example, has been largely absorbed by foreign politics and immigration problems. In fact the Charity Problem in New York is the Immigration Problem. Fifty thousand Jews arrived last year in New York and 70 per cent. stayed there; stayed in a town where there are already 600,000 Jews, and 300,000 of these settled within one square mile—the greatest ghetto the world has ever seen. The Jewish Charities of New York—apart from all De Hirsch and other funds and all outlays on buildings—spend over a million dollars a year on their poor, and 90 per cent. of this on the Russian, Roumanian and Galician immigrants, who, with a similar yearly expenditure on a practical political plan, might have been prosperously settled in a Jewish land. Nevertheless Zionism has, within the limits already pointed out, nothing but praise for these hard-working institutions. I wish now, however, to direct attention to another aspect of the evils of homelessness by way of an American society, not for relieving physical sufferings, but for developing the Jews spiritually. The Jewish Publication Society is not exactly a charitable society, but by requesting bequests and donations, it shows that it regards its activities as philanthropic. The Jews of America are so little inclined to study their own literature and history that they have to be artificially induced to add a knowledge of these to what they absorb much more naturally of American and English literature. In a Jewish State there would be a natural output of Jewish literature in need of no artificial fostering. “Don't write me any more plays of Jewish color and inspiration,” said a leading American manager to me. “Write me a play showing the Jew moving easily and freely among our fashionable American circles, and I will guarantee you the theater will be besieged by Jews. You could not keep them away with a Gatling gun.”

Indeed, looking at the article "Drama" in the Jewish Encyclopædia, I find that with all the languages of the world to draw from, including Hebrew and Yiddish, and all ages and periods, six pages suffice for the correct perspective of the subject, while the article on Dreyfus fills up nearly thirty pages. This is indeed typical of our history. The free development of our national spirit from within has been stunted, while our attention has been largely concentrated upon the tragedies of external persecution.

"CULTUR" WITHOUT A SOIL.

My whole life, having been devoted to "Cultur," and not least to Jewish "Cultur," perhaps the Congress will bear with me when I say that for spiritual influence on our race, a century of "Cultur" is not equal to a decade of agriculture on a soil of our own. If I am careful not to throw the blame for all our material misery upon our lack of a land, I have less hesitation in attributing the majority of our spiritual troubles to our unfortunate political position. The institutions which artificially try to remedy those evils are poor substitutes for the natural action of a paternal soil, a local color, and a national atmosphere.

At the last Congress I mentioned Jochanan ben Zakkai in terms that displeased his admirers. But no reputation can escape revision, and though one may freely admit that Ben Zakkai saved Judaism from the fall of the Jewish State, perhaps if he could have foreseen the eighteen centuries of tragedy of which even Kishineff is not the end, if he could have foreseen the comedy of Marrano-Christianity and Pseudo-Mohammedanism, he would have preferred to die in Jerusalem with the Jewish patriots than escape alive to the Roman camp in his coffin. That coffin was an ominous symbol of the living death that was to be his people's future; of all the disguises and mimicries—from which even a Maimonides was not to be free—with which they were to replace the free expression of their national personality; even as the decaying meat by which Ben Zakkai simulated for the Jewish sentries the odor of the corpse has proved symbolic of the ill-odor in which his luckless people were to live henceforth in lands not their own. Ben Zakkai saved Judaism, but at what a price! And his work of spiritualization was not thoroughly done. He did not, like the Christian apostles, free Judaism from a soil.