The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 2 · February 1908
75printed page
scan 37 of 46

THE MACCABAEAN

Published once every month by the Maccabaean Publishing Company, of which M. B. Lande is President; and D. H. Lieberman is Secretary; whose address is 547 Broadway, New York City. Edited by Louis Lipsky.

FEBRUARY, 1908

Dr. FELSENTHAL was by nature and training a logician, and his adoption of Zionism, after he had given years of his life to reform Judaism, was inevitable to a man of his intellect and education. He saw clearly, after a decade of experience with reform, that its end was the complete absorption of Judaism; that it was, in essence, a compromise with conditions that unceasingly hammered at Judaism in order to get ät to abandon its principles. In Zionism he saw the one solution of the dilemma, and he was brave enough to confess his error and to become an ardent supporter of Zionism. He thus became a powerful influence in meeting the mission theory advanced by rabbis with whom, formerly, he worked hand in hand on all points. He delivered telling blows to reform in his remarkably lucid essay on “Jewish Principles,” which Tue MACcABAEAnN, in its first volume, had the privilege of reprinting. None of our conventions adjourned without a word of approval from the venerable rabbi of Chi<ago, and he was a living protest, for many years, against the assumption that reform Judaism and Zionism were antagonistic. Truth with him was above all other things, and he never flinched from facing the consequences of <onclusions forced upon him by new facts.

DR. NATHAN BIRNBAUM.

DR. BIRNBAUM's lectures in New York have introduced a man of unusual ability, a clear thinker, a poetic force in the analysis of Jewish conditions. Schmaryahu Lewin brought us a powerful personality, with all the incisiveness, the eloquence, the fire of zeal, the sharpness of analysis, which is characteristic of Russian Jewry; Dr. Birnbaum is typical of that Galicia which borders closely on Germany; by temperament, he is a poet; by thor-

ough study, he is a lucid thinker; and his personality is agreeable.

Dr. Birnbaum will be wi:h us for several months, and he will address many Zionist meetings. It need not be expected of him that he will arouse the enthusiasm of the masses, as was done by Dr. Lewin; his lectures will be more instructive than emotional, more like lectures than orations; but, in spite of that, he will give us something of great value if he presents, as we know he will, the interesting develonments in Austria in national nolities.

In Austria the Jewish question has become a political question of the day, and Zionism has had a great deal to do with the progress of nationalistic thought in that country. It would be folly to think, however, as Dr. Birnbaum does think, that America presents an analogous opportunity. While it is true that here we have the commingling of races, or nationalities, America is yet a democracy, in which the methods of Austrian Jewish politics would be either premature or out of place entirely. We lack the compactness of Austria; and inasmuch as so many of our immigrants are new settlers, it is not possible to appeal to national alignments; tearing themselves away from the land of their birth, our naturalized citizens resent the idea of national interests apart from the general interests of the country. Dr. Birnbaum is intelligent enough, however, to rely upon the views of American Zionists as to the feasibility of emphasizing national distinctions in American political life.

We bespeak for him the interest of all Zionists, and hope that his sojourn with us will prove of large benefit to American Jewry at large, as well as to Zionism.

THE PANIC AND THE JEWS.

‘ Tre present industrial depression which has overtaken the United States has had, and is having, a tremendous influence upon that phase of Jewish life here which finds its material expression in institutions, charitable and philanthropic. The New York Charities closed its doors, for the first time in its history, for part of one month, and will, it is anticipated, repeat the performance again each month until the pressure upon its resources decreases. Every New York institution, with few exceptions,