The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 2 · February 1908
76printed page
scan 38 of 46

has sent out an appeal for additional support. The reports from the interior tell a similar story of inadequate facilities and resources to meet the necessary wants of the weak members of our communities. It seems that the industrial depression has revealed the weaknesses of our philanthropic structures as they have never before been revealed. The future is dark when the philanthropist sees breakers ahead, and when he must mend his own fences before he gives his mite to relieve the poverty or the incapacity of his "coreligionists" in free America.

The depression also reveals the precarious nature of the position of the Jewish immigrant. All our charities are due to the natural need of the adjustment of the immigrant to his new environment. It is generally admitted that half of our institutions would be unnecessary if immigration ceased; that all of our brethren would in a natural manner adjust themselves, and there would then be no special Jewish problem—at least that problem which is the greatest bother of philanthropists.

But immigration must continue. America must hold its doors open to the persecuted and oppressed of our nation. No matter how short-sighted or provincial a philanthropist may be, he would not think of joining hands with the restrictionists. The present needs of the Jewish people require an open haven for those who flee from persecution.

The Jews being, for a time at least, the weakest class of immigrants, suffering, as they do, a double disability, the one as immigrants, the other as Jews; having been despoiled by their Governments, and therefore being in special need, during the first few months of their settlement, of advice and guidance; and the stream being as constant as the hatred of the Russian and Roumanian anti-Semites, does it not appear that the policy which devotes itself to the erection of institutions is not worthy of the intelligence of the leaders of Jewish philanthropy, and that they are in duty bound to find a more statesmanlike remedy for those ills which are now, by communal lethargy, left to the charities, hospitals and assimilatory educational institutions ?

THE HILFSVEREIN.

ONE of the remarkable phenomena in recent

Jewish affairs is the growth of the Hilfsvereinder Deutschen Juden in genuine Jewish enthusiasm, and its abandonment of that policy, especially in Palestine, which has retarded the development of Jewish consciousness among those whom it has assisted.

‚Dr. Paul Nathan, the enterprising and far-seeing secretary of the Hilfsverein, must be credited with the responsibility for the change. He has made it appear that the organization which he represents is not opposed to the Jewish spirit, that it is not favorable to a policy which makes Germans or Frenchmen of the children whom it educates, and that it prefers a Jewish environment, and the satisfaction of Jewish needs, rather than a policy which paves the way for an ignominious assimilation. Dr. Nathan is, from all reports, interested in the development of Palestine, not as a philanthropist, but rather as a good Jew, and he seems tobe willing to help in all efforts to give the Jewish settlements in Palestine a fair chance to develop their own ideals, regardless of the views of foreien bureaucrats.

The position of the Hilfsverein, in this respect, ought to impress upon the Alliance Universelle Israelite the futility and the harm of its policy in Palestine. The Alliance is rightly charged with being an admirable agency for creating French influence in Palestine; its. schools are not Jewish, but French; its students do not look to Palestine for their future careers, but they see in Paris the centre of their hopes. If there is any one agency responsible for the demoralized condition of the Jewish youth in the Holy Land, it is the Alliance. The lack of patriotism which these stu-dents evince for their fatherland is due prima-rily to the artificial education which the Alliance schools have given them.

There ought to be some way to bring hometo the Alliance the wrong it is doing to theJewish national conscience of the childrenwhose education it is intrusted with. And it would be a fine example of poetic justice if the Hilfsverein itself, which is, by means of those subterranean ties of which the Jewish world knows so little, related to the Alliance, entered a protest against the demoralization in Palestine for which the Alliance is largely responsible.