The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
5printed page
scan 5 of 52

gram. I had originally not employed the phrase "publicly, legally." I seemed to me unnecessary. I said simply "legally-secured."

In the Program Committee, however, there were some firebrands who thought my expression did not say enough. They wanted to clothe their dream in verbal form. They threatened to make speeches and bring forward motions at the public sittings, which would have done the movement grievous harm on its first public appeal. Herzl thereupon proposed as a compromise to substitute for my phrase “legally-secured,” the expression “publicly, legally.” The radicals expressed themselves satisfied with this alteration, and thus it was brought about that the Basle Program was unanimously adopted by joyful acclamation. You see that I have no reason for attempting to defend the words “publicly legally.” I do so, however, because if we alter the phrase now, we give it retrospectively a signification which would be a grave distortion of its original meaning. A small minority at the first Congress connected with the phrase the idea of a Jewish immigration into Palestine under the auspices of the great Powers, who would recognize this Jewish settlement ot the Holy Land as an integral part of the European concert. But the vast majority of the Congress stood quite aloof from any such far-fetched fantastics. By “publicly, legally.” as well as “legally-secured,” they wished merely to say that the Zionists reject the idea of creeping into Palestine, that only on the basis of expressly granted legal fights will they enter into the Turkish State. That is the meaning of the phrase. This signification was endorsed by our President in his solemn declaration. It is, perhaps, not superfluous for me to repeat it in this connection. Whoever gives the words another signification does not understand their meaning or is not disinterested. A similar reply can be given to the suggestion which has also found expression in reference to government approval which Zionism has to acquire. By “government approval” the reformers ap-

parently have in mind the approval of the Great Powers, which we indeed required so long as the right of settlement in Palestine depended on the will of a despot, but which becomes completely superfluous now that we hope to obtain this rigkt from the elected representatives of the free sovereign Turkish people. But they read the program hurriedly. Look at the text more closely and you will see that there is no mention of the necessary approval of the governments, but merely the necessary approval of tlıe government, i. e., government ın the sınonlar.

That the Turkish government alone is, and can be, meant is perfectly obvious, in the singular. That the Turkish government alone is, and can be, meant, is perfectly obvious, and we declare it here explicitly.

THE BASLE PROGRAM EXPRESSES OUR ASPIRATIONS.

That the acquisition of the necessary approval of the Turkish government for the legal settlement of Palestine is one of the tasks of Zionism will, it is hoped, be contested by no one in this assembly. We may, and will, therefore, alter not one iota of our program. Not because we ascribe to it a mystical immunity. Such a verbal fetish is quite foreign to us. But because the Basle program openly and clearly expresses all our longing and all our aspirations. This frankness of expression I greatly prize. We have no mental reservations. We proclaim our object with absolute directness, namely, the possibility of living and developing on national lines as a modern, highly-civilized people, undisturbed and uncontested in the land of our fathers. This boldness gives us the right to ask for confidence and to answer anyone who attributes to us I do not know what mental reservations, I do not know what subsidiary unexpressed aspirations. Some of our opponents are at the present moment at work in Turkey fighting us with a bitterness which far exceeds the impotent hostility which has prevailed for twelve years with-