The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
6printed page
scan 6 of 52

out result in England and America. They have pursued us in political circles in Turkey, with slanders that one would not dare repeat in public in Europe but which were found quite passable for export to the Orient. Turkish patriots have been inoculated with distrust against us, they have been told we designed to tear away a province from the Turkish Empire, and when once we were in Palestine would declare its independence and make it an independent kingdom or republic of the Jews. In Europe, no one could circulate such stupidities without being laughed at, but Turkish listeners, who are less experienced, allow themselves to be fooled with such blatant nonsense.

No THOUGHT OF SEPARATISM.

We therefore say to them: Do not let yourselves be blindfolded by our opponents. They are playnig criminally practical jokes on you. No one of us has ever thought of tearing Palestine away from the Turkish empire, of founding a kingdom or republic, and of thanking the Turkish empire for the benevolent reception accorded the Zionists by a blow at the unification of the empire. What we desire is to form a nationality within the Ottoman State like all the other nationalities in the empire. True, we demand the recognition of our nationality; there must be no doubt about that. It will be our ambition to earn the reputation of being the most loyal, the most reliable and the most useful of al the Turkish nationalities, to contribute the most zealously to the weal, the progress and the power of the empire.

But let it be understood that we will do all this solely as a nationality, a Jewish nationality. That is our frank reply to certain Turkish utterances. You have been told: "Come to Turkey as much, as you like. You shall be welcome. You will find everything you like, fertile, cheap, possibly free land, security against persecution, all the liberties accorded to every citizen of the Ottoman empire. But you must become Turkish subjects, adopt the Turkish language, merge with the Turkish

people, so that you cannot be distinguished from other Turks. And in order that it may be certain that you observe these conditions, we shall not permit you to settle in large numbers nor in compact bodies. We will distribute you equally among all the provinces of the Turkish empire, but we will not permit you to enter Palestine. Palestine shall be closed to you, the only province in the Turkish empire."

In the face of such views we are impelled by pride and self-respect to refer to the Basle program and to declare that we must maintain it unaltered and allow not a single word to be struck out. For in the basic idea of Zionism I recognize no opportunism. On this point, concessions are impossible. If the Zionists want to go to Turkey, it is to be as Turkish subjects, but to become Palestinian Jews; they do not want to be made Turks in Macedonia or Asia Minor. If they want to assimilate, they can do it nearer home and more cheaply; they can do it where they are now and save the fare. They can do it where they are now and spare themselves the trouble of emigration and adaptation to new surroundings. You are Zionists, however, just because you will not assimilate. You go to Palestine, to the land of your fathers, to live and develop there as national Jews. If we are told: "We shall not admit you to Palestine; you may not live your Jewish national life; Turkey will only admit you if you surrender your Zionism," we shall make the effort to refrain from any expression which might bring about permanent hostility, and will break off negotiations which at the moment promise no result. The Zionists have waited so long they will wait longer. But meanwhile we must irrefragably maintain the Zionist ideal. I say this now merely in my own name. You will doubtless take the opportunity of declaring in unmistakable terms whether you are of my opinion or not. I am a Zionist who never puts his flag in his pocket. If other Zionists are prepared to conceal their Zionism or even to give it up, then our roads part.