tive body must have an individuality independent of the party of which it is composed; it must be something which embraces and acts upon all the parts, thus making up the individuality. The Jews do not have it. All the mind knows is that there are Jews, but it does not see the entity, the Jewish physical unity, the Jewish people, which should be expressed by assemblage and representation, which should comprehend and act upon all the Jews. Having before it only Jews, the parts of the entity, the mind has no true conception and is therefore confused as to what the Jews are. Having before it only a multitude of Jews, the mind cannot psychologically or logically differentiate the parts from the whole and the whole from the parts, and for this reason it sees in every Jew and all the Jews something which it does not understand. The mind sees Jews, but does not see the Jew themselves, the Jewish people. Because the mind can form no true thought of the Jews, it is confused, without, however, realizing this fact, and therefore, naturally, prejudice arises. It is now clear why the prejudiced mind, seeing only a multitude, piled up every act and phenomenon of individual Jews on the whole multitude. We thus also understand why every crime or objectionable act committed by an individual Jew is charged to all Jews. That is the primary cause of anti-Semitism, or the cause of the prejudice against the Jew. It is due to the abnormality of the Jewish people, of which the mind cannot form a definite conception."
This is in essence the theory advanced by Mr. Schomer. It is a striking and original view, which he reaches after much convincing argument and illustration. It is a view that possesses much force and logic and can be considered as one of the best explanations of a subject that has elicited only confusion from most writers.
But Mr. Schomer goes further. Having diagnosed the ailment afflicting the Jewish people, he also prescribes a remedy. The abnormality of the Jewish people con-
sisting in that it lacks the element of unity, to transform it into a normal body or association of people, he suggests the formation of an international Jewish Congress. This is to be formed by the Jews of every locality organizing and electing representatives who shall assemble as a congress which shall possess permanent qualities. Through this congress the Jews of the world shall declare anew the object for which they were originally organized by Moses, namely, to live as an ethical and spiritual people, and through this congress the Jews of the world shall do everything that is necessary to further that object, making of them an organized international society. The formation of this congress, Mr. Schomer believes, will remove the abnormality of a lack of assemblage and representation, which he has pointed out as the cause of the hatred of the Jews; and in the course of time this readjustment which will make of the now unorganized Jewish multitude a unity, will act upon the mind and it will get a logical conception of the Jewish people; the prejudice disappearing, anti-Semitism will also completely disappear.
In considering these views, it is not necessary to either accept or reject them in their entirety. Assuming that Mr Schomer's analysis of the cause of anti-Semitism is correct, it does not necessarily follow that his remedy is correct. For it may indeed be that an ailment may be correctly diagnosed yet the remedy prescribed for its cure may be erroneous or unsuitable to the demands of the case. So also we may disagree with the theory of the cause of anti-Semitism advanced by him, and accept the idea of an international Jewish Congress as an otherwise valuable and practical suggestion. That Mr. Schomer's theory of the "Primary Cause of anti-Semitism" is forcefully persuasive, is, after a reading of his book, undeniable. In its entirety it is a very skilfull structure that he has built, despite certain defects of style and manner.
The flaw in Mr. Schomer's theory, how-