The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
198printed page
scan 12 of 54

ever, exists in believing that the Jewish multitude, as he describes it, lacks only the element of assemblage and representation to make it normal. In the diaspora it lacks also a definiteness and unity of object, the second of the essentials to make it a normal body. Mr. Schomer asserts that the only object of the Jewish people is to lead an ethical and spiritual existence and he advises them to reorganize with that purpose in view. It is true that to lead an ethical and spiritual life was the object for which Moses organized the Jewish people after it left Egypt, but he also intended that the Jewish people should live as a nation and to practice the principles of ethics and morality during a national existence which should become great only because of these principles. But Moses organized the Jews when all the surrounding nations had an ethical, moral and spiritual standard far inferior to that which he gave the Jews. To-day the ethical and spiritual standard of the nations among whom the Jew lives is very little, if at all, inferior to the Jewish standard, with the possible exception of their conception of the Deity. How, then, can the Jews or Gentiles regard it as the object of the Jewish people to organize now, as Mr. Schomer would have them do, for the sole purpose of practising ethics and leading a moral and spiritual life; as as if it were an object different from that of the peoples among whom the Jew lives? Mr. Schomer's explanation of the object for the existence of the Jews as a people

to-day must be described as sophistical. The only possible object that a people can have as a nation, (and Mr. Schomer concedes that the Jews constitute a nation), is to lead a national existence, with common aspirations in developing all their possibilities as a people in science, art, literature and politics. The realization of such an object in the diaspora is obviously impossible. It is only possible in a land of their own. Not having this, the formation of an international Jewish congress would not cure the abnormality of the present Jewish multitude and it would be as impossible of logical conception before its formation as after. This abnormality will only be cured by assemblage and representation of the Jews in a national existence in a land of their own. Then they will become truly normal and may be logically comprehended. While the formation of an International Jewish Congress will not cure anti-Semitism, as Mr. Schomer predicts, it is, nevertheless, a very valuable and practical suggestion as a means of uniting and representing the Jews for their general welfare in the Diaspora. As the realization of the ideal of a land of their own for the Jewish people is probably an uncertainty of the dim future, it is advisable that the Jews organize and perfect their unity as far as it is possible until then. For this purpose the proposition for an International Jewish Congress is the most practical suggestion that has been made. It would represent the Jewish voice in the Golus.