The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 2 · February 1911
46printed page
scan 6 of 40

A Zionist Enquiry by M. David Fresco

N Die Welt of January 2oth a brief ] reference was made to the investigation that iS now being conducted by the Constantinople Ladino newspaper I! Tiempo into the question of whether Zionism and Patriotism are compatible. The letter in which the editor of the Tiempo, M. Iavid Fresco, solicits the opinion of various prominent Jews upon the question submitted by him is now before us, and as this letter is perhaps better calculated than any other fact to expose the nature of the campaign that is being carried on against us not merely in its political but also in its moral aspects we propose to show the manner in which M. Fresco invites a reply by reproducing the exact text of his communication.' His letter dated December 28th, 1910, runs as follows :—

"In view of the fact that Zionism basing itself upon the Basle programme aims at the creation of a Jewish State in Palestine I beg you to favor me with your replies in full to the following questions:

1. Is Zionism compatible with Patriotism, i. e., would a Jew who acknowledges the Basle programme be disloyal towards his adopted fatherland? 2. Have Ottoman Jews the duty of energetically combating this movement or not?"

There are only the two possibilities conceivable: either M. Fresco knows the Basle programme or he does not know it. It would not be right to assume that a Constantinople Jewish journalist who has to occupy himself with Zionism would not know the text of the Basle programme which appears on the cover of every number of Die Welt and also in all Congress reports and various newspaper reports.

We must therefore conclude that M. Fresco has "corrected" the Basle programme in a manner corresponding to his intentions. But this mode of correction is not customary among respectable journalists with a sense or responsibility. By his alteration of the Basle programme M.

Fresco desired to produce an effect upon the recipients of his letters and to suggest to them an opinion which, as he doubtless feared, they did not entertain. This fear seems to have been justified. In his paper M. Fresco publishes the replies of M. Claude G. Montefiore of London, and of Dr. Frank, Senior Rabbi of Cologne, both of which, as we shall show, in no way fulfill the hopes that have been set upon them. Both of these letters have experienced a strange fate. At the same time that they appeared in "Il Tiempo" they also saw the light in Salonica in the Turkish paper "Yeni-Assir," but, strange to say, in a totally different version. The version of these two letters are as follows:—

Reply of Mr. Claude Montefiore:—"Yeni-Assir"

“As President of the Anglo-Jewish As sociation, the council of which comprise among its members both ardent Zionist and anti-Zionists, it would be indiscreet o my part to write on this subject in a Jew ish newspaper published in Turkey. It i well known that I personally am an anti Zionist. On the other hand I must admi that I as a matter of fact and without de ciding whether there is any theorical con radiction involved I know many Englis Jews who are at the same time Zionists an loyal British subjects. Up to what poin this combination is practicable in Turke it will be impossible for me to say. nevertheless insist that all Jews, whateve their opinion of Zionism be, owe above all loyalty and devotion to their fatherlan and especially to the countries where lik Turkey they enjoy the same rights as thei fellow-citizens professing other religions.

"Tiempo"

Mr. Claude Montefiore, President of the Anglo-Jewish Association in London, give the following advice to Ottoman Jews: "Insist that all Jews should above all show loyalty and devotion to their fatherland this duty is even greater particularly in