from the political point of view. Although many of our opponents still attack us for this theory, they themselves are among the most vigorous in dealing practically with the Jewish question with political weapons. That they are using the weapons of politics in attacking this question is very much to their credit—however much it discredits their anti-Zionist theories, for politics in the sense that we Zionists use it, is spiritual, just as all forms of human activity may be spiritual.
J. L. MAGNES.
New York, Dec. 2, 1912.
IT
MY DEAR DR. MAGNES:
I have received your letter of protest against my attitude on the abrogation of the Russian treaty of 1832, and to me it reveals nothing more clearly than your fine, warm-hearted enthusiasm and power of imagination. Nevertheless, although I admire and envy your optimistic imagination, a careful regard for fact will not allow me to concede that you are right.
Had the Russian passport fight been waged as a Jewish fight, I would admit the gain which you claim for Jewish morale. But while the fight was on, we cried aloud without sparing that it was an American question, and not a Jewish question. This claim rigidly rules out all claims of a gain for the Jewish spirit. Under which flag did we fight, the American of the Jewish? The victory was fought and won under the American flag; and I am not willing to stultify my former protestations by pluming myself on having won a Jewish victory as a Jew, when the victory was gained by America in the name of America. I cannot vaunt myself on having won a victory for myself when it was gained by another fighting in another cause.
You say that the fight was carried on in a Zionistie spirit; but my conception of the Zionists’ method of fighting for Jewish questions is that he fights under a Jewish flag. Moreover, my ıonception of his use of political methods is that he does not diffuse his energies fighting for local rights and partial privileges. He has rejected those peddling methods of emancipation which gain him freedom at the expense of his individuality. He rather concentrates his political activity on a constructive program aiming at the Jewish
redemption of catholic Jewry, the world over. Therefore, on Jewish questions the American Zionist acts as a Jew, not as an American. We Jews of America did not act in this spirit in the matter of the Russian treaty abrogation. When we asked for our Jewish rights, we did so while denying our individuality as Jews. Is that the gain for the Jewish spirit which you wish me to recognize?
It would take too long to answer verbatim all the statements you make; but in brief, my contention was and is, that if America succeeds in negotiating a new treaty with Russia which shall give to American Jews in Russia the full and unconditional rights enjoyed by other citizens of this Republic de facto as well as de jure, then your optimism will be vindicated, and I shall gladly confess my dismal prognostication to have been that of a false prophet. But if, on the contrary, the future will show, as I fear it will, that America is unable to enforce its demands on behalf of its Jewish citizens, then I ask you where will be room for your optimism? For in this latter case, what shall we have gained? So far from our experiencing a strengthening of the backbone of the Jews throughout the world, as you claim, we shall rather be compelled to bend our backs still more under a yet greater burden of despondency. If one of the most powerful and liberty-loving nations in the world proves to be impotent to enforce its demands for equal rights for its own citizens when they happen to be Jews, shall we not reap, instead of an increase of confidence, a shattering blow to our own naive trust in political patronage and protection? If even this great Republic, with its splendid traditional love of justice and freedom, is unable to guarantee its protection to its Jewish citizens, shall we not be forced to see that our trust in the modern Assyrias and Egypts is a trust in a broken reed I ask you as a student of history, shall we, Bourbon-like, never forget the past, yet never learn its lesson, taught to us in each generation? Assuming, therefore, as I do, that the United States will not succeed in enforcing its demands, the message brought to the Zionists by the abrogation of the Russian treaty is “Put not your trust it princes, trust yourselves; your greatest need at this juncture is not political pat-