ronage, but self-help, not political favors and concessions, but braver and more independent self-development; not political guarantees, which non-moral international politics unhesitatingly evades, but regeneration from within." To exult on account of a trifling concession to justice which has been delayed for eighty years is in the undignified manner of emancipation. It betrays the fawning, bent-backed, attitude of the Ghetto. The Zionist sees in it little or no step forward toward the solution of the Jewish problem. At the best it is a doubtful victory for the doubtful blessing of emancipation.
To sum up, my disbelief in the Jewish value of the treaty abrogation is based on two considerations :—first, the non-Jewish manner in which it was obtained, which involved sacrificing any Jewish moral value it might otherwise have had in stiffening our backbone; and secondly, my conviction that Russia will use every possible evasion to avoid acceding to America’s demands. Time may prove me wrong. I earnestly trust that it will. I have no desire to play the part of Cassandra when the fate ot one-half of my people is involved. Nothing would give me more Jewish rejoicing than to be able to share in your approval of the manner of the abrogation of the treaty and in your optimism as to its results. To mv sorrow I cannot.
D. DE SOLA POOL.
New York, Dec. 3, 1912.
III.
DEAR. DR. POOL:
You do not seem to understand the passport issue. We did not ask for our "Jewish rights." We have in this country all the Jewish rights we want and need. No one here is keeping us from being full-blooded, rock-ribbed Jews. We asked for our "American rights" and got them. As long as our Government acquiesced in Russia's interpretation of the treaty of 1832, we were deprived of our American rights. As soon as our Government abandoned the Russian interpretation, and took up, under the impetus of the passport fight, the American interpretation, we won our American rights. As long as our Government maintains the American interpretation of this treaty and of every treaty, we have our American rights, quite aside
from whether or not Russia or any other country concurs in the American interpretation. But you may be assured that if Russia or any other country refuses to adopt the American interpretation of treaties, all such treaties will be abrogated by this Government, and no new treaty will be made, as is evidenced by the Persident's recent letter. But what more can America do for her citizens than to declare that if a foreign country is not willing, for whatever internal reasons—police, religious, social, cultural, racial or what not—to recognize the equality of American Jews, or Catholic priests, or Baptist missionaries, America will have no treaty relations with such Government? Shall America, in addition, go to war?
Of course, we did not fight for American rights under the "Jewish flag." Do the Catholic citizens fight for their American rights under the Papal flag, or the Italian citizens under the Italian flag?
But suppose the Jewish flag were now fliying from the citadel in Jerusalem, and that the Jews had an army and a navy with which to enforce their demands, would we American Jewish citizens have asked the Jewish State to take any steps in the abrogation of the treaty between the United States and Russia? Of course not.
Moreover, are you not aware that political activity in the lands of our dispersion is now a common and legitimate activity on the part of Jews and of Zionists? Are the Jewish parties in the Austro-Hungarian Empire striving for their rights as citizens under the Jewish flag? Of course not. Or are the Jews of the Ottoman Empire striving for their rights as citizens in that Empire under the Jewish flag? Of course not. We have in the United States all of our rights as Jews, and we must continue to see to it that we have all of our rights as American citizens.
Should America succeed in establishing a new treaty with Russia in which Russia will recognize the American principle of equality, you admit that “Jewish morale” will have been strengthened. I am surprised that you should measure a strength-ening of the backbone merely by the stand-ard of success. It is very often the unsuccessful struggle that gains the moral victory. This passport fight was a moral victory for the Jews of the whole world, quite aside from whether or not a new