The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 5 · June 1920
204printed page
scan 50 of 57

The Maccabaean

structure, and the flare for exquisite psychological touches in characterization. Compounded and stabilized, and made the instrument of ultimate sincerity, this combination creates the most startling illusion of real life.

Miss Pearl's novel is unusually interesting. "Sarah and her Daughter" is truth told movingly, beautifully, entertainingly, by an artist who has the great gift of always keeping all her characters in perfect focus. S. S. G.

S. S. G.

Reality Through Impression

The Mask. By JOHN COURNOS. George H. Doran Co., New York.

Fact and imagination are here united into a composite strange and beautiful. So harmoniously joined that one cannot mark the line of demarkation. For the truth is that there are in it no forced appreciations, no forced apprehensions. Strange and rich and unreal as the book may appear, it is the natural emanation of a rich and sensitive nature. All natures are not alike; neither are their expressions in creative form.

There was a time when I set the remorseless realist upon the highest pedestal, but that preference implied an exclusion unjust in the extreme. In my passionate desire for the truth and the truth only, I failed to understand that the truth might be borne on the wings of symbol and impression and the lie conveyed in the most faithful, exact and colorless record. The test of reality lies not in the accumulation of emotionless detail but in the impression of veracity that the paragraph, the chapter, the book conveys.

Every scene and every event recalled from memory is enveloped in a haze; men’s choices, omissions, stressings, shadings obscure the possibility of obtaining the perfect record of life or of any fragment thereof. Even photographs may be beautiful if the photographer knows how to focus properly and the photograph is none the less “realistic” because it happens to be beautiful. When the aid of memory is invoked, however, it reconstructs the past, falsifying it from the reportorial view, yet quoting it correctly from the point of view of subjective realism, which means to me fidelity to the fact as it appears to one, not as an unimaginative photographer might have seen it. And the fact ihen appears beautiful for memory forgets the ugly and the hateful or sets it in a border which palliates its character. “And all this early childhood,” writes John Cournos of himself, “re-erected itself before him more like phantasmagoria than life” But that phantasmagoria, as he calls it, sounds real because it feels real. And that is the test of autobiographic sincerity. It is true that the author, depending on memory’s choices, would not—since memory is not inseparable from desire— place all events in their proper relation, but he views the past, not in terms of the past, but in terms of the present stretching out hungry arms for the thing in the likeness of which the past is recalled.

Our people have written generously of themselves in frank autobiographic form. A recent addition to the library of Jewish autobiographies includes Marie Ganz's "Rebels." But John Cournos' book is not an autobiography in that sense. Of a probably more shrinking and sensitive character, he has written an autobiographic novel, under the protection of which form he has been able to offer the revelations he records. It was that type of novel that Randolph Bourne began before his death and of which he might have achieved a perfect specimen, were perfection possible. In both cases memory's evocations produce the same type of beauty.

Cournos' achievement is not unworthy. Rarely, I think, has the realization of sex in a young boy been so sensitively described. The figure of the stepfather is drawn in a manner which evokes the same conflict of love and disapprobation that raged in the hearts of his children. How the city of stone—Philadelphia—beat upon the confused Jewish lad lost upon her streets and bent him ever so slightly without breaking him is a symbolic expression of the soul of America in conflict with the soul of those it rejects. John Cournos has made a beautiful thing out of his childhood and now it is the record which is the truth. He has made it so.

Two Hundred Four

There is another beautiful book of somewhat the same character to which I feel impelled to call the attention of the readers of this review. It is Leon Kobrin's "A Lithuanian Village," translated by Isaac Goldberg and published by Brentano's. It has all the surface indications of a stenographic record, but there breathes through that record a love and a knowledge that transforms it into a piece of literature. Leon Kobrin knows and loves his village yet knows it not so little or loves it so much that he could speak falsely of it. Those with a taste for the gaudy and the resounding will miss the beauty of the book, but the book was not written for them. Perhaps all I have said is that the book is beautiful? . . . Well, there is all there is to say. It is sometimes hard to rationalize about beauty. H. S.

H. S.

Edward Doyle—Prophet of True Nationalism

The Haunted Temple and Other Poems. By EDWARD DOYLE. New York. The Comet: A Play of Our Times. By EDWARD DOYLE. Boston.

On page 195 of this issue is printed a sonnet by Edward Doyle on “The Jews in Russia.” The author of this superb little gem, like Homar, is blind; but, like Homer, his mental vision is clear, and broad, and deep. President Schurman, of Cornell University, commenting on Doyle, once said: “It is as true to-day as of yore that the genuine poet, even thoush blind, is the Seer and Prophet of his generation.” The poem here printed illustrates the point. Did we not know that it was published some fifteen years ago in a volume entitled “The Haunted Temple,” we should assume that it was written on the occasion of the fall of the Czar. In fact, however, it merely foretells this event by some dozen years. And how terribly applicable are the lines to the facts of to-day! The prophecy is one capable of repeated fulfilment.

But it is as a prophet of nationalism that this man compels our particular attention. The prophecy is embodied in a play entitled “The Comet, a Play of Our Times,” brought out as far back as 1908. The play is a microcosm of American life. The chief character is a college president, and he it is that is chosen to expound the true nature of nationalism and to give voice and „utterance to the principle of self-determination. (Is it merely a coincidence that at that time Woodrow Wilson was President of Princeton, or is it a case of poetic vision? Wilson, be it remembered, was already a national figure, and there were already glimmerings that he was destined to usher in a new era in politics.) According to the protagonist, America is not “a boiling cauldron in which the elements seethe, but never settle,” but rather a college where every class is tausht to translate —

".Into the common speech of daily life The country's loftiest ideals—"

and any body of citizens form a part of our republic only in so far— “As they contribute to its character As leader of the nations unto Right By thought or deed, in service for mankind.”

We must lead the peoples of the world to freedom. And what is freedom?

“’Tis intelligence Aloof from harm and hamper, grandly circling Its native sunlit peaks, the highest hopes Heaved from the heart of man upon the earth, In ranges long as time and soul endure.”

What, then, is America’s duty to the oppressed race or the small nation? It is to “wake and and disabuse it of false hope” —

"and urge it on

To the development of its own powers,The culmination of its own ideals,—The star seed sown by God,—the only meansBy which a tribe can thrive to its perfection."

To make this possible, civilization must be given a more human content. It is therefore necessary to awake human intelligence, "the godlike genius," to a realization of the fact—