The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 3 · September 1920
97printed page
scan 33 of 74

The Maccabaean

archives and not in that wave of materialism which swept over the world a whole generation before the war. And of this materialistic philosophy of life, which brought about the war, we Jews are no more innocent than the other peoples. The war was not a political one, but the revelation of a disease, unobserved for some time, with which the whole world was infected. In this sense the war was our war as well. Indeed, can we assert that our hands were clean, that we had no part in the filth in which the whole world was sinking? Did not Jews lead in this materialistic dance? Jews became accomplices in creating throughout the world the materialistic pleasures of life, cheap amusement places, publicity for the sensational world of capitalism. Jews are everywhere engaged in supplying fuel to the hell in which we live—can we, then, realizing all these things, say with Klatzkin that the war has revealed only the pagan trend of the Christians?

We are just as guilty as they are, and the war, being a reflection on Jews and Christians alike, as individuals, proves nothing against Christianity or Judaism as a philosophy of life. Besides, both they and we have grown away from the religious world-concepts whose strength could save our souls.

IV

If you read Klatzkin's book attentively, you will find one contradiction permeating it. This contradiction is characteristic not only of the author but of the entire younger Zionist generation. Klatzkin bases his discussion on the assumption that our religion has lost all its vitality and that henceforth our land and language will have to assure the existence of the Jewish people. As he says, the Hebrew land and language will—as a result of the revolution brought about by the Zionist idea—be the sole determining criteria of who is a Jew, and who is not.

Thus we would tentatively conclude that, by granting this hypothesis, all questions and points of view concerning the Jewish spirit and Jewish philosophy of life, etc., disappeared. And, indeed, Klatzkin endeavors in the first part of his book to deny the existence of any such particular philosophy of life. Ethics are the same for all men: There are true ethics and false ethics, but there are no special Jewish ethics, he argues, and justly so.

But suddenly Klatzkin found himself forced to introduce into his theory that Jewish philosophy of life which he previously controverted. I have already cited the points in which he exhorts the nationalist Jews, who fail to see the sham of Christianity and the truth of original Judaism. Is there no manifest contradiction here? If Zionism defines Jewish nationalism in such unmistakable terms as land and language, what matters a Jewish philosophy of life, per se, or in opposition to any other philosophy of life? Accepting Klatzkin's assumption, we might think that the Christian world-concept, if only expressed in the Hebrew language, would also be Jewish.

Klatzkin evidently did not realize how he minimizes the intrinsic value of our religion by reducing it to a mere means of preserving the nation. Religion is not only a means, but an end. It purports to teach the individual and the group their relations to the Infinite, to Deity, and to indicate to them their place in the universe. We may admit that the preservation of the Jewish national identity was one of the functions of our religion. For this was the object of the founders of our religion, "that there shall always be a definite group which uninterruptedly, from generation to generation, shall be the champion of the power of justice against all the other dominant powers in the world" (Ahad Ha'am). Nevertheless, we must not forget that this object of our religion to preserve the nation was only to preserve the representative of the Divine mission. Now, then, if land and language will succeed religion in guarding the existence of Israel, what will be the purpose of this existence? Thus the means will be left us, while the end will be gone.

Nevertheless, although you may seek in vain in Klatzkin's book for an expression of grief over the deterioration of the Jewish religion, as such—for he feels only that the walls which have surrounded us have fallen, but does not point to the impoverishment and void left behind in the heart of the individual Jew who lost his God—he,

too, cannot be satisfied with the external criterion of the Jew, and sets forth demands of a certain philosophy of life in contradiction to all the former hypotheses of his book. He feels that we are becoming reduced to a sort of new Albania, by being satisfied with a linguistically Hebrew Palestine alone.

Thus even our national movement is in need of a world-concept outside of itself. A Judaism, satisfying itself with a land and language alone, may be regarded as the height of assimilation, for thereby the people would sacrifice its ideal being on the altar of modern Europe, since hitherto there was not a moment in our history when we were satisfied with such a national definition.

Zionism does not come to succeed religion, but it sets it free from those national functions as means which prevented it from free development in its true function. Klatzkin shows us our national good fortune in that the Halacha succeeded to the place of prophecy. "Indeed, the Halacha imposed a heavy yoke on the free development of our theology, but in return it was a source of good for the narrow life of the people." Freeing our people from its national worries and guaranteeing it an existence through land and language, the people acquire the potentiality to return to the wide horizons of prophecy. Zionism will not be built on the ruins of religion; on the contrary, through Zionism religion will return to its ancient vitality.

The great conflict in future Palestine will not be, as many of us today are inclined to believe, a conflict between the orthodox and religionless youth. All conflicts of this nature are only a sort of overture to war. For our young generation is one only in outer appearance. At the moment that a real religious movement will arise in our midst, whose aims will be not mere precepts, but the soul of the people and its identity—at that moment there will be manifest a great conflict in the ranks of the nationalists; a conflict between the nationalists at large and those to whom nationalism is only a means for realizing the mission of our people. Two passages, two slogans, are floating in the air about us, and only one of them we can choose and adhere to: "Remember what Amalek hath done to thee," or "And they will all come to worship Thee." . . .

DR. HUGO BERGMAN.

Jewish Education

Jewish Education in New York City. By ALEXANDER M. DUSHKIN. Published by the Bureau of Jewish Education.

Achad Ha-Am seems to strike at the heart of the matter when he points out that the Judenwissenschaft was in the minds of its founders "nothing more than a memorial tablet to our dead spiritual activity." Throughout the scholarly writings of Zunz, Geiger and Frankel, he gathered the impression that these leaders in the "movement towards emancipation" felt that the life of the Jews as a distinct cultural entity had ended with the entrance of the Jews into Western life. Jewish science, which may be regarded as a resultant of the confluence of the Jewish and Western streams of life, is characterized essentially by a negative attitude towards Jewish survival.

The significance of Dr. Duskin’s book on Jewish Education in New York City can be grasped adequately only if we bear in mind this fundamental criterion—what is its attitude toward Jewish survival? It is gratifying to note that the first scientific work on any phase of Jewish life in America, by a writer who has become thoroughly assimilated into American life, not only has a positive attitude toward the perpetuation of the Jewish people, but is itself motivated by the _ Jewish will to live, and deals with the Jewish school, the agent which is central in importance in the task of preserving Jewish life outside of Palestine. One swallow does not make a summer, even less perhaps does one book make a movement. Dr. Dushkin’s work may be an individual and sporadic attempt. A closer examination, however, of the facts concerning Jewish education presented to us in this very volume tends to support the conviction that we have here an expression of the will to live on the part of American Jewry. It is not too much to say that Dr. Dushkin’s book contains the prophecy that in the new meeting of the Jewish and Western worlds here in America, the Jew will use Western knowledge in aidinz him