The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 4 · November 1920
134printed page
scan 34 of 44

The Maccabaean

.Two, to include the ‚Chairman, be commissioned to present the statement adopted together with a transcript of the proceedings of this meeting to Mr. Justice Brandeis, This recommendation, on

The Day is satisfied with the resolutions and characterizes as “courageous” the act of the Executive Committee. The most important item in the resolutions, according to this paper, is the statement that the American organization desires to maintain the integrity of the International Zionist Organization. This disposes of all rumors with regard to a “Monroe Doctrine” in Zionism. The Day concludes its comment by saying:

The National Executive Committee apparently understood its task better than the delegation to the London Conference, and it is to be hoped that it will succeed in stimulating fresh and intensive activity among the Zionists of the country.

On the other hand, the New York Zeit thinks that the situation had not changed as a result of the action of the Executive Committee. It regards the resolution as a "compromise."

Henry Morgenthau's "Memoirs"

Mr. Henry Morgenthau’s failure as ambassador to Turkey is discussed by Dr. Alfred Nosig, the eminent Jewish scholar and artist, in an article in the Moment of Warsaw, a translation of which is published in the press digest of the Jewish Correspondence Bureau. Dr. Nosig gives his opinions on Mr. Morgenthau in the form of a commentary upon the latter’s nublication of his “Memoirs.?

Mr. Morgenthau, according to Dr. Nosig, failed in his functions to stop the massacres of Armenians, and to support Jewish aspirations in Palestine. He failed to such a degree that "America found itself compelled to recall Mr. Morgenthau from Constantinople at the imperative and repeated demands of Turkey." His "Memoirs," thinks Dr. Nosig, are an attempt to explain away his failure in the eyes of public opinion, and in it "he changed the scenery, the rôles, and the perspective on the political stage and illuminated his own personality with special lights."

Morgenthau made harder the lot of the Jews in Palestine, thinks Dr. Nosig:

“America sent to Constantinople three successive Jewish Ambas. sadors. To have a Jew as an American Ambassador was a matter which in those days of Jewish hardships in Palestine, was of great importancee. Morgenthau weakened this important position and through him the entire Jewish Palestine question was endangered. I knew, not through German circles, but by virtue of information given me by the Grand Vizier, that Morgenthau’s position was undermined. I conveyed this fact to him confidentially with the idea of influencing him to change his tactics even at the last moment, those tactics which made every step of his both with regard to Armenia and the Jewish question, vain and useless.”

In contrast to Mr. Morgenthau’s failure, Dr. Nosig points to Mr. Elkus, who gained the sympathy of the Turkish government to such an extent that even after the war had broken out he remained in Constantinople for many months (under cover of being convalescent) and served the interests of America splendidly, even while his oficial residence was filled with hiding Armenians.

Mr. Morgenthau has the tendency to draw on his imagination in order to amplify his deeds, and Dr. Nosig relates this instance as proof.

' On his return to New York he felt that he must throw favorable light upon his activities with regard to the Palestine question. Re-

ceiving a group of reporters he declared that he had prevailed upon Talat and Enver that they should give the Jews great domestic and political concessions in Palestine. Entering into details he said that among other things they would let the Jews build the ports of Jaffa and Haifa. The Halhambashi Rabbi Nahum was mentioned ar sh. .2.J:22-.. 2:2 ıha. 2 narartlatinnn

This invention caused the Turkish government as well as Rabbi Nahum a great deal of trouble. They cabled to Washington and when the Ex-Ambassador found himself unable to explain the matter he issued a new version of the affair stating that this political victory of his was merely a joke which had been passed off over a cup of black coffee.

The Death of Jacob H. Schiff

A great deal of space was devoted by the press, both the Jewish and the non-Jewish, to the death of Mr. Schiff. Mr. Louis Marshall, who has been a lifelong friend of Mr. Schiff, and associated with him in his philanthropic work, prints a character sketch of Mr. Schiff in the New York Day. He relates the story of the conference which Mr. Schiff and he had with Mr. Taft, while the latter was President, regarding the situation of the Jews in the Russia.

It was at the time when I started the campaign to induce America to sever its relations with Russia because of the tragic treatment meted out to the Jews of that country. In order to discuss the question President Taft invited myself, Mr. Schiff and a few others to lunch with him. After lunch the President invited us into his library where he produced a paper from which he read us his “decision” in the matter and that was to the effect that nothing could be done and that America’s relations with Russia could not be severed. .

I asked the President: “Can we not even discuss the question?” and President Taft replied: ‘Yes, you may discuss the question with me.” I glanced at Mr. Schiff and noted that he was inwardly greatly excited. Both Mr. Schiff and myself addressed the President but without any effect. The President had invited us for a discussion of the situation but instead of coming prepared for discussion he brought with him a written judgment. We were greatly surprised. At our departure we all shook hands with the President and thanked him for his invitation. What else could we do? This was not, however, what Mr. Schiff did. He took up his overcoat and without giving the President his hand or offering him any farewell, left the White House. In the street he turned to me and said: \

"Mr. Marshall, this is the beginning of the campaign, a campaign which we must win. You can depend on me for any amount of money that may be necessary."

Another member of the delegation who was with us, remarked, "But what can we do? We are after all still in exile." To which Mr. Schiff replied: "No, not at all, and what is more we are going to win out."

Great interest was naturally attached to the will of Mr. Schiff, and when it was published, there was unmistakable disappointment at the fact that he left nothing for Relief or Palestine. .

The Day comments editorially:

Jacob Schiff’s will is a disappointment to all those who had expected that the great Jewish philanthropist would, in the present critical moment of his people rise higher than his customery philanthropy. But Jacob Schiff followed the old beaten path, even in the final act of his life. He died the same philanthropist, the same dispenser of charity that he was all his life, a man with a warm heart and a warm sympathy for the Jewish present, but with no vision for the Jewish future. .

Had Mr. Schiff not done so much good during his life, had he been altogether a stranger to the Jewish people, as is the case with many Jewish millionaires, nobody would think of criticising him after his death. It is just because Mr. Schiff excelled in his devo-